trust, I should suspect the good faith of those who make the charge; for the utterances of our leaders made with all solemnity and in the fullest earnestness, ought to leave no doubt in the minds of men as regards their and our intention. But let only the facts speak for themselves. You are aware that negotiations were entertained during all last winter with the Egyptian and the English Governments for the acquirement of certain lands in El-Arish, the southernmost portion of Palestine, and in the Sinaitic Peninsula. These negotiations, which were carried very far, were not brought to a successful conclusion, only because of a technical difficulty which could not at the moment be overcome, that of providing the land in question with a befitting supply of water. You will all agree with me in deploring the momentary failure of the negotiations, and in hoping that at no very distant day a way may be found for a solution of the difficulty encountered. It was shortly after this that, upon their own initiation, an offer was made by responsible ministers to Dr. Herzl's representative for the establishment of a Jewish colony in British East Africa. And here, even before I say a word in regard to the action of Dr. Herzl and subsequently of the Congress, may I be permitted to call attention to one or two facts attending upon the offer made. The letter of Sir Clement Hill to Mr. L. J. Greenberg appears to me to be a document not only of the very highest importance, but one that is unique in the history of our people. It contains such a message as has never before been sent to them, and we may be allowed to feel legitimate pride in the fact that it.has come through our hands. We have had messages sent to us in former times; aye, many and to boot. But what have such messages been in the past? Papal bulls, royal rescripts, edicts of banishment, obnoxious and cramping laws and outrageous ultimata. For the first time in our history, a great and powerful nation reverses the order of things, and in fullest consonance with the principles of liberty and justice, upon which its world-empire is built up, comes to the outcasts of the world and assures them "Of the interest which His Majesty's Government must always take in any well-considered scheme for the ameliora-"
tion of the position of the Jewish race.’Such words, I do not hesitate to say, add another jewel to the crown of the British Empire; and whatever position we may take inregard to the offer, we ought to be animatedby sentiments of the most profound thankfulness for this part of the message. But,the offer goes much further; much furtherthan any scheme short of the Zionist one,which looks forward to simple colonization—say in South America, in the United States,or in Canada. It is something totally different; for the offer says distinctly that the details of this proposed colony (that is theword used) shall “Comprise as its main features, the grant of a considerable area ofland, the appointment of a Jewish official asthe chief of the local administration, andpermission to the colony to have a free handin regard to the municipal legislation and asto the management of religious and purelydomestic matters.” I say that such an offerhas never before been made to the Jewishpeople; and its true significance can only begauged if we bear in mind cotemporaneousJewish history in England. For a wholeyear a royal immigration commission hadbeen sitting in London; it had been studyingthe effect upon British commercial and economic life of the anti-Jewish barbarities inEastern Europe and the Balkans. It hascome to certain conclusions which undoubtedly point to legislation by the British Parliament curtailing in a measure the formerfree immigration into England. But thatgreat government does not propose simply toclose its door a little tighter in the face ofthe newcomer; if it feels the necessity to dothat, it feels also the necessity to do something more. It cannot harden its heart; but,having its own problems to solve at home,which it feels unable to do by keeping thatdoor open, it generously opens another doorthrough which perhaps the poor oppressedones may find some measure of relief. Thatis a great action, worthy of a great nation.
Brought face to face with such an offer, what was Dr. Herzl, what was the Zionist Congress to do? The bells of Kishineff were still tolling in their ears, and a probable Homel and a possible Mohileff luring up in the grim distance. What answer was he, what answer were they to give, who spoke in
