The Maccabaean · Vol. V, No. 5 · November 1903
298printed page
scan 21 of 56
Facsimile · scan 21 of 56
Scan of p. 298
Text · transcribed from the scan

change her mind. She has one of two ways of accomplishing her end—extermination or emigration. Is it as illogical, as that surprising contributor makes it out to be, that we do not choose extermination for others—extermination and degradation? Is it such bad tactics for a general who sees his army in the tight grasp of the enemy to prefer an honorable capitulation and withdrawal to total extermination? Is it not the policy of the highest wisdom not to shut one’s eyes to the inevitable, but to face it with resolution and to endeavor by treaty to find a way out? Did not that great philanthropist, the late Baron de Hirsch, do exactly the same thing? What Jewish paper dared to say him nay? But with us dreadful Zionists it is different. What was good statesmanship on the part of Baron de Hirsch is on the part of Dr. Herzl (I am quoting), “His vanity, his desire to spring a surprise, to appear spectacular, to create a sensation and to be talked about.” What then, good Sir Critic, are we to do? You do not want us to try for Palestine, and your editor in the same number does not want us as Nationalists and Zionists to try for British East Africa? Are we then to fold our hands simply, and as a panacea for the ills of Jewry, discuss with you the relative merits of reform and orthodoxy? No, the times are too serious for such bantering. Editors and contributors to Jewish journals should put their adjectives for a while in their pockets and join hands with us in a supreme endeavor to do something that is good and is lasting.

To you and to those who are not with us the word to join hands must go out from this platform. There cannot be, there ought not to be antagonists as between Jew and Jew. We are sick of wasting paper and printers' ink in order to try the sharpness of our tongues and the brilliancy of our wit. We need a new alliance under the old flag; and I look upon it as a healthful sign that on August 24 a meeting was held in Basle of those delegates of the Congress who were at the same time members of the order of Bnei Berith. Of the thirty-four members who were at that meeting five were delegates from America. May this be a good augury that the helping hand will be reached out from continent to continent, and from sea to

sea, so that, tried in the furnace of suffering, the unity of Israel may once more be established.

This meeting, to-night, completes for us delegates the work of the Sixth Zionist Congress. On the festival of the rejoicing of the law, it is customary for us to read the last chapter of Deuteronomy and immediately following to commence again with the first chapter of Genesis. Let us follow this ancient custom, and as we close our work for the past year, open at once the work of the year which is at hand. May the old spirit be always with us; but let it be tempered by new hopes; and if such be the spirit in which we do our work, Heaven would surely grant us success.

Rev. Dr.

Rev. Dr.B. Felsenthal In reply to a suggestionwhich you, Mr. Editor, havemade in the October number of THE MACCABÆAN, I send you here myanswer to the question submitted.

Shall, or shall not, the grand offer of the British Government—the proposal of granting a large territory in East Africa, where the formation of a Jewish national settlement could be undertaken—be accepted by the Zionists?

My answer is, "Yes!" But my "Yes" I would make dependent upon certain conditions:

I. The territory offered by the British Government must be thoroughly explored by competent experts, by agriculturists, engineers, men of good judgment in hygienic, in industrial, in commercial, and in other kindred matters, so as to get maturely considered prognostications that the territory is a fit one for a permanent settlement by white people.

2. If the report of the experts shall favor the acceptance of the offer, respectively if it shall demonstrate that East Africa in its climatic conditions, in its promising soil, in its industrial and commercial possibilities, and in other aspects necessarily to be considered, is of such a nature that it could be wisely selected as a land of refuge for the myriads of our poor homeless brethren, then let another committee be appointed to make the desirable practical preparations before any of the poor brethren are sent there. No mere dumping