The Maccabaean · Vol. III, No. 2 · August 1902
90printed page
scan 32 of 56
Facsimile · scan 32 of 56
Scan of p. 90
Text · transcribed from the scan

at all between the Huguenots and the people with whom we are dealing. The Huguenots were essentially an intermarrying people and were speedily absorbed by marriage into the general population. In this case it is not so in any shape or form? A. Then it is proved that they will not assimilate wholly.

Q. It does not seem to matter whether the objection to intermarriage comes from the Gentile side or the Jewish side, the result remains exactly the same, that there is not intermarriage, or in very few instances is there intermarriage, and consequently no real assimilation is possible. Do you think that the relief and hospitality to the oppressed Jews of Roumania and the Russian Poles involve any possible danger to the English working classes by competition and so forth? A. No. I do not think that. Why should charity do a harm to others?

Q. I mean the charity that brings the people here? A. We have spoken already about that question.

Q. We have also spoken about dissemination; you do not believe in that either? A. No.

Q. You say that a Jewish question exists wherever Jews live in perceptible numbers? A. In the same way that you have an Irish question where Irish people are in great numbers.

O. And therefore you would not disseminate? A. No.

Q. And you say further that the plan of dissemination carries with it the idea of exclusion in detail. If you disseminate you say to them in practice, "So many of you may live here and so many may live there." That is exclusion of them in detail? A. Yes.

Q. So that exclusion in detail involves the exclusion in gross. If you say, "You may not live here" to one lot, and then to another lot, "You may not live there," it amounts to the same thing? A. It is against the principle of free movement.

Q. You consider that the efforts of the Jewish Board of Guardians and the Russian Jewish community here have broken down? A. In that sense. I think they are not able to supply the need.

Q. They cannot deal with the number of people who come here? A. They cannot.

THE ARGENTINE FAILURE

Q. Baron Hirsch left large benefactions for the Jewish people? A. Yes.

Q. Have those benefactions increased or diminished the evil? A. I think they were rather indifferent.

Q. They did not have any effect on one way or the other? A. No effect.

Q. With regard to the enormous question they were nothing? A. No.

Q. A drop in the ocean? A. I really think they did not do more than provide for schools and for several small agricultural stations.

Q. Did it do any good, or was it, in your opinion, money wasted? A. It was rather money wasted.

Q. The money was spent in sending them to Argentina, partly? A. Yes.

Q. And partly also to Palestine? A. No.

Q. Was none spent on the Zionist Movement? A. No.

Q. But they went to Argentina. Has that attempt to settle them in a country set apart for them been a failure? A. It has been a failure because when you want a great settlement you must have a flag and an idea. You cannot make those things only with money. As they had not these, they could not succeed.

Q. It has been suggested to me that Baron Hirsch's charity tended to increase the number of what you call schnorrers? A. I think so.

Q. It did? A. I think so. So many people know there is a large bag of money and they come.

Q. And have a go at it? A. I think so. All that is so natural—I do not think it is merely Jewish.