The Maccabaean · Vol. III, No. 2 · August 1902
91printed page
scan 33 of 56
Facsimile · scan 33 of 56
Scan of p. 91
Text · transcribed from the scan

Q. I agree with you. Do you know of the pressure that has been brought to bear upon the Russian Government with regard to improving the condition of the Jewish people who live under that government? A. Certainly; there is a general movement in what you call public opinion to work upon the mind of the Russian Government. I think since the times of antiquity there was no example of helots, and they are really helots or pariahs in Russia.

Q. Do you know anything about the financial position of Russia? A. No.

Q. It has been suggested that pressure could be brought to bear upon Russia by withholding financial assistance? A. I am not informed upon that.

Q. Have you ever seen it stated that the Jewish community helped the Russian Government in 1894, and at other times gave the Russian Government considerable financial aid? A. For what?

O. Loans? A. I am not informed on that question.

Q. You do not express any opinion as to whether the withholding of such pecuniary facilities would enable us to bring pressure upon the Russian Government? A. I should prefer not to speak about questions which might do any harm to my friends and brethren in Russia.

Major Evans-Gordon: I am sorry to have troubled you at such length, but I think I have come to the end. You have been most kind and most helpful.

Dr. Herzl: I am sorry that I could not answer you more readily.

After the adjournment L. W. Vallance took up the cross-examination.

Mr. Vallance: There was one reference you made to the difficulties of assimilation. I do not know exactly what you mean to apply to the word in your sense. Do you mean assimilation by intermarriage or in any other form? A. By assimilation I understand verbally what the words contains, to become as similar; that you are no more distinguishable. That is assimilation.

Q. Then assuming that dissemination is possible, would not that lead to an assimilation in your sense? A. No. Dissemination has been going on for 1,800 years. For 1,800 years the Jews have been scattered and they have not assimilated.

Q. Looking at the question from an English standpoint, and assuming that the aliens had not concentrated themselves so much in one district, and had been distributed over different parts of the country, would the question of alien immigration have arisen then? A. I think so.

Q. You think that the evils which you have pointed out would still be existent? A. I think so. It would come later on. It had to come.

Q. And there is no possibility of the question being dealt with other than at its source? A. I think so.

Q. I am not quite clear as to what you have in your mind when you speak of diverting at its source the stream of immigration into this country. Have you any particular scheme in your mind? A. Yes.

DR. HERZL OFFERS TO CONFIDE IN CHAIRMAN

Q. Would you mind describing that? A. I should prefer to point it out here only in a broad manner, and I should be very glad if I could give the details to your Chairman privately, and if he thinks it worthy then he could give them to your colleagues. For doing so I have certain reasons that will be apparent to you.

Q. You look upon dissemination as impracticable in this country, and almost a senseless proposal in dealing with the large question? A. It seems to me to be one of the schemes proposed. I read in the English-Jewish newspapers of so many schemes of this and that to alleviate the question, but it seems to me that it is only one of the schemes.

Q. Looking at the question of alien immigration from the standpoint of the United States for a moment, you have referred to the fact that America excludes? A. Yes.

Q. The exclusion is a partial exclusion? A. Exclusion, as I know, is worked in this