The Maccabaean · Vol. III, No. 2 · August 1902
89printed page
scan 31 of 56
Facsimile · scan 31 of 56
Scan of p. 89
Text · transcribed from the scan

Q. The people come from conditions unfortunately worse than the worst conditions in London? A. I do not know the worst conditions in London, but I think they have very bad conditions where they are.

Q. You do not give any opinion as to whether it is to the advantage or disadvantage of this country to import people largely who habitually live under those conditions? A. I have given you already my opinion in an answer to Mr. Norman, saying that I should in every case look at the immigration of a workingman and of a man able to rise economically, I should always see in that an advantage for the whole community; not for his neighbors, perhaps, but certainly for the whole community, because there is more matter for income tax.

Q. Do you think that the Jewish difficulty has actually arisen in this country? A. I think the difficulty is here when you are obliged to discuss it. You must have a reason.

Q. What do you anticipate would be the result if things are left as they are, if there is a policy of laissez faire? A. I should not like to make any prophecy.

Q. You see from "the black cloud that is rising in the East," and from other influences at work, that this question is merely at its inception here? A. Yes.

Q. That we have to face a very big thing? A. Yes; I cannot but look so at the question.

Q. All the tendencies are to drive more and more people to this country? A. Yes; I think so.

Q. In Lord Salisbury's words, "As you close one channel, the flow will come all the stronger down the one that is remaining open"? A. You cannot close it without changing all the conditions of your land. Russia is a closed land, but England is not.

Q. Unlike the heads of the separate Jewish communities settled in various countries, you view these Jewish questions from the point of view of nationalism? A. Yes.

Q. That is the point of difference between you and others? A. Yes.

Q. Is, in your opinion, Jewish nationalism binding on those Jews who share your views? A. In what sense binding?

Q. Loyalty to the Jewish nation and loyalty to the Jewish idea? A. Yes.

The Chairman: Binding upon whom do you mean, equally with him?

Major Evans-Gordon: Binding on those who share Dr. Herzl's views of Jewish nationalism. My first question was that unlike the many heads of the separate Jewish communities all over Europe, you view these questions from the point of view of Jewish nationalism? A. Yes.

A DEFINITION

Lord Rothschild: Would not the best thing be to ask Dr. Herzl what his views are about a Jewish nation?

Major Evans-Gordon: Would you say briefly what your views are about Jewish nationalism? A. I will give you my definition of a nation, and you can add the adjective "Jewish." A nation is, in my mind, a historical group of men of a recognizable cohesion held together by a common enemy. That is in my view a nation. Then if you add to that the word "Jewish" you have what I understand to be the Jewish nation.

Q. What would be the common enemy in this case? A. The anti-Semite.

Q. Under those circumstances, with those people who hold those views with regard to the Jewish nation that you hold, is complete assimilation with the English community possible to those who are politically loyal to the Jewish state? A. Certainly. I think assimilation is quite possible, I do not say that it is always desirable, but it is quite possible. You have the historical example of the Huguenots of France going to Germany and invited after the persecution of the Protestants in France, and you have all the great families who are perfect Germans, and you have General Zurlinden, who has a German name, but who is a French general.

Q. I want to point out to you in regard to the Huguenots that there is no analogy