10 — "Die Welt" — No. 51
(continued from page 9)
. . . the delegates were elected by the "Convention"! And so glaring a violation of the Statute was tolerated for years. Another example of the absence of system is the franchise for the Zionist conferences of the individual territorial organisations. In Russia the Shekel is the basis of the franchise for the party congress of the territorial organisation; in Austria, on the other hand, not every Shekel-payer is at the same time a voter for the party congress, but only members of societies who pay a special territorial tax. The party congresses of the individual organisations gain more and more in importance with the growth of the movement; it can therefore by no means be a matter of indifference to the Congress organisation whether the Zionist conferences represent the broad masses of the Shekel-payers, as in Russia, or merely an aristocracy of societies, as Austria. But let us set these defects aside. Let us consider the effects of this unrestricted "territorial autonomy" upon the Shekel and the financial position of the organs of the Congress.
From the report laid before the Helsingfors Zionist conference we see that the Zionist organisation of Russia administered its Shekels perhaps very expediently, but without regard to whether the (50 per cent) quota falling to the territorial organisation was exceeded or not. Moreover, expenditures were granted which can surely only be of use, in particular for cultural and economic institutions in Palestine, but which a territorial organisation is not at all empowered to grant or refuse, — they belong to the competence of the executive organs of the Congress and not of the Russian Zionist conference. We have here, then, to do with an encroachment of a Territorial Committee upon the administration of the Shekel moneys.
The Austrian territorial organisation does not grow so zealous for Palestinian practical politics, and so it does not come to exceed its Shekel budget at the expense of the A.-C. On the other hand, however, it suffers from the total want of a Shekel budget and from the impossibility of sending the Shekel moneys to the proper address. For the Austrian territorial organisation has made a curious use of the "autonomy" granted by the Congress: it has ceded this autonomy of the Territorial Committee to seven other bodies not provided for in the Congress Statute, the so-called District Committees (D.-K.). These alone may deal with the individual organisations; the D.-K. retain the Shekel quota and dispose of the Shekels, they direct the agitation and the National Fund collections, may have their own press, and so forth. The Territorial Committee has only the "supervision" and . . . the responsibility before the Actions Committee for the Shekels collected by the D.-K. One sees that the Austrian territorial organisation has used its right of self-government to set seven similar bodies in its own place, in other words, to decentralise itself in fact, or even to dissolve itself. If, for example, the Bukovina district organisation is far too weak to set a vigorous agitation on foot, the Territorial Committee stands powerless before this evil; it may not claim for Zionist agitation in the Bukovina a surplus that may arise in prosperous Bohemia. The Bukovina is no concern whatever of Cracow or Prague. So — there really exists no Austrian Zionist general organisation. Now the A.-C., or more correctly the Organisation Statute of the Congress, ought not to stand indifferent towards such measures, which may become fatal to the existence of Zionism in the country. But then we may well assert that Shekel moneys which do not flow directly into the treasury of the Territorial Committee, but are controlled by seven D.-K., arrive in Cologne in a badly worn condition.
The principle of the autonomy of the territorial organisations is inviolable. It would go too far if the A. C. had the right, and therefore also the duty, to assert its rights of supervision down into the detail of the Zionist work of a territorial organisation. That too would only be a superfluous overburdening of the Actions Committee. But the right of self-government of the territorial organisations must not be so unlimited that the financing of the movement might thereby be endangered by unwise strivings after autonomy on the part of individual sections of the organisation.
Let us dwell a little longer on the decentralising tendencies which reached their climax in Austria in particular. The same District Committees which, in their zeal for decentralisation, even proceed to create "Rayon Committees" in turn within their districts, show a fine feeling for centralisation when it is a question of helping reasonable and justified demands for autonomy to break through. There arose in Austria a socialist workers' party, not to be underestimated and well organised, which is Zionist and wished, in conformity with the regulations of the Congress, to join the territorial organisation. The Austrian Territorial Committee, bound by the famous territorial statute, may not, however, take cognisance of the adhesion and answer it with the dispatch of the Shekel blocks desired. It refers to the District Committees, which for their part, on the ground of the same statute, may not, and at first also will not, negotiate with the party executive of the Poale-Zion. They wish to deal directly with the individual organisations, they turn out to be centralists . . . in their own sense. One D.-K. even wished to make the issue of the Shekels dependent upon the payment of the district contribution, thus aimed at an indirect increase of the Shekel contribution. All this with appeal to the Congress Statute, which obliges every Zionist to join the territorial organisation. Naturally the Poale-Zion refused to concede to the D.-K. any right of disposal whatever over their societies, to say nothing of a district contribution. Only consider, — the D.-K. demanded of a workers' party that it dissolve itself in respect of Zionist work and subordinate its societies to bourgeois working committees, nay, that it pay contributions which belong exclusively to these committees and are not prescribed by the Congress Statute! Had the A. C. not spoken its word of authority in good time in favour of the Poale-Zion, the tactics of the D.-K. would have made the adhesion of several thousands of Jewish workmen to the territorial organisation impossible.
In order to avoid such frictions between currents and parties of Zionism, the federation principle — a legacy of the organising genius of Theodor Herzl — was taken up into the organisational provisions of the Congress. Only, in fixing the number of Shekels necessary to form a federation — 5000 — Herzl probably had Russian conditions in view. And even for these it is set too high. A party need not first have 50 societies with 5000 Shekel-payers in order to be ripe for separation from the territorial organisation. Even if it has 2000 or 4000 members, there arise, as the example of the Austrian Poale-Zion proves, occasions enough for antagonisms which, if they are fought out within the territorial organisation, will certainly not make easier a prosperous collaboration for the good of Zionism. We believe, therefore, that it is necessary to lower the federation minimum to about 3000 and to create provisions for a transitional state. One cannot and must not force upon a strong faction, even if it has not yet brought its adherents to 3000 or 5000, forms of organisation that run counter to its principles. It would surely be too light-minded to barricade the road to Zionism with paragraphs of statutes.
The federative principle, this fruitful idea of the Congress Statute, must be developed, must come into application, and not, as hitherto, remain a dead letter. Thus, for example, the mode of election to the Congress belongs, according to the existing provisions, to the competence of the territorial organisation; but now the Congress has an eminent interest in an act whose course and shaping are decisive for the composition of the Congress. In Austria the procedure follows the territorial principle in dividing the electoral groups. In Russia there exist supplementary provisions which represent a kind of system of proportional election. Here too the Congress would have to intervene in order to make impossible every element of the outvoting of oppositional groups. This will most readily be achieved through autonomist concessions in the disposal of Shekels to organisational bodies which are not yet federations. This would be one of the chief provisions which in their totality would characterise the transitional state towards federation indicated earlier. Thus this year the Poale-Zion of Austria received Shekels directly from the Territorial Committee, bypassing the D.-K. A share, which is in any case smaller than that of a federation, has also been conceded to them. It is self-evident that on the basis of the Poale-Zionist Shekel lists P.-Z. electoral groups should now be formed, whereby outvoting and party strife would be avoided, which are unavoidable in electoral groups composed with regard to the place of residence of the Shekel-payers and without regard to party differences. Such rights, which the Poale-Zion first had to fight for, ought to be provided for in the Congress Statute.
Let us then sum up our arguments concerning the Shekel: The Shekel must be preserved as the basis of the Zionist organisation. As regards its amount, the Statute fixes only the minimum. The territorial organisations are responsible for the Shekel; the number of Congress mandates falling to each country (each federation) is determined by the Inner Actions Committee in proportion to the Shekel moneys received by it. The Congress Statute lays down guiding principles concerning the form of organisation of the federations, insofar as the securing of the revenues of the Congress organs and of the franchise provisions
