Die Welt · Vol. X, No. 50 · 14 December 1906
12printed page
scan 10 of 20

12 — "Die Welt" — No. 50

Itzkawitsch is not satisfied with the report of the Z.-B., since it contains insufficient factual material. Among other things, not a single word has been said of the Zionist assembly which met in Odessa some months ago. How can one pass over in silence such an assembly, which contributed so much to sustaining the energies of the party? The Z.-B. evidently does not know the situation exactly. One must not forget the changed situation. The Minsk Congress was the time of poetry, — now we do not wish to be lulled to sleep nor to deck ourselves out; we are serious enough and know our responsibility. We must lay bare our sufferings and infirmities. I demand an answer from the Presidium as to why it has not submitted a report on the state of affairs in Russia. One should not come to us with trifles and plans. The Conference ought to lay bare everything that goes on in the organisations.

Dr. Tschlenow gives explanations regarding the absence of many Russian members of the A. C. Seven are abroad two have sent excuses, from two no answer has been received, three are here, three are coming tomorrow, Rosenbaum is ill, Temkin is still expected.

Grünbaum, by way of clarifying the question, reports on the activity of the Polish bureaus. The Bureau in Poland has never received the information circulars directly from the Cologne Centre. One must therefore distinguish the activity of the members of the A. C. from that of the Bureau. It is the fault of the structure of the organisation as a whole that the Z.-B. in Vilna is only a chancery. Zionism, like every party, must have an organ that is to lead it. In Odessa a great mistake was made, namely in that the questions of organisation were placed above the questions of programme. One must first know whither one is going. We must define our present-day work in Palestine and in this country. Make of a conglomerate of persons a party, and we shall become a dominant party in Jewry.

Dr. Pasmanik: For the first time, perhaps, we hear such criticism of the leadership. But we must judge the matter from a different standpoint. We must regard Zionist phenomena in their social context. What is critical in our situation goes much deeper than some believe. It is conditioned by the general causes of Jewish and of general Russian life. Zionism is no party; it is the people. And we now see two currents in it contending for mastery. The one is the purely territorial, which has as its aim only the building of a State in Palestine; the other regards Zionism as an evolution of Judaism, as a result of the gathering of the energies of the Jewish people. But neither the one current nor the other will hold the field. I am convinced that the present critical condition will be overcome through the synthesis of both opposites. . . . The conditions of life also bring many an inner struggle with them. We often wish to be more revolutionary than the revolutionaries; the Bureau of the Zionist Organisation in Poland, for instance, committed a breach of discipline when, contrary to the resolutions of the Z.-B., it boycotted the elections for the first Duma. It should not be a matter of persons for us. Persons can be removed. We must create a synthesis of principles! . . . .

After several other speakers had spoken, and after the closing speech of B. Goldberg, who among other things went into the question of the omission of the Odessa Conference and pointed out that this conference ran counter to a resolution adopted by the conference of the Russian district leaders who had been present at the Annual Conference in Cologne, and was therefore a breach of discipline, Dr. Tschlenow took the floor to clear up the question of the disunity in the inner A. C. The inner A. C., he said, suffers from being composed of heterogeneous elements. But it is absolutely untrue that personal frictions have any place among certain of the Russian district leaders. Each one serves the movement simply according to his powers and his understanding. He did not wish to paint everything in rosy colours. But neither may we sharpen the antagonisms. As regards Kremenezky's letter, no objection could be raised against the principle laid down by him as to how the N.-F. should be administered; but the form of Kremenezky's letter had certainly been tactless. The greater part of the N.-F. moneys must be invested in landed property. That this is not being done is due, in his opinion, not to the resistance of the inner A. C. but to the inadequate equipment of the Palestine Commission. We must beware, the speaker concludes, of suspecting one another. We need mutual tolerance and collegiality.

Thereupon a motion to pass to the order of the day, approving the report and expressing thanks to the Z.-B., is adopted.

END OF THE FIRST DAY

* * *

According to telegraphic reports which have reached us, the most important resolutions of the Conference concerned the question of organisation and of work in Palestine. The Central Bureau remains in Vilna and has been invested with substantial powers. On the question of practical work in Palestine it was resolved in principle to give the most emphatic support to a number of undertakings proposed by the Palestine Commission.


CORRESPONDENCE

(This column, for which the Editors bear no responsibility, is, as we repeatedly remark, open to letters from our readers and to the free exchange of opinion.)

On the Amendment of the Statute of the Organisation

The flood of proposals for the amendment of our Statute of Organisation has somewhat subsided, and thus the opportunity and leisure are given to pass the mass of motions and opinions in review and to sift out what of value they contained.

And it then appears that all the proposals went no further than the Shekel, that all the discussions confined themselves exclusively to the manner of organisation (and that chiefly in regard to the financial side of the movement). I do not believe that the question of the amendment of our Statute is thereby exhausted. I am of the opinion that there are still more, and perhaps still more important, points in which our constitution is either defectively framed or else functions badly. In any case the critical examination of the opinions so far put forward shows that the handling of contributions to the organisation is evidently not practised irreproachably, and that in wide circles the organisation of the Shekel is regarded as not entirely successful. It seems to me, however, that this question cannot be treated apart from the general questions of organisation; that, just as it is necessary that the Statute be built upon a common, unified fundamental idea and move in a definite direction, so too the criticism and the proposals for reorganisation must regard the Statute as a whole, and must not put forward individual demands which stand in contradiction to other points of the Statute hitherto in force or take no account of them. In what follows an attempt shall be made, on the basis of these considerations, to put forward proposals for the general reform of the Statute of Organisation.

First of all it then appears that the existing Statute already contains a whole series of the proposals which have been put forward by the various correspondents as fundamental innovations. It appears further, however, that these provisions are observed only in part or no longer at all, and herein is to be sought not least the reason for the view which describes the existing Statute as no longer in keeping with the times. But even the best Statute cannot, after all, guard against its clear provisions not being fulfilled. That depends exclusively upon the zeal and the discipline of the fellow Zionists. Nevertheless, in a certain respect the Statute of Organisation valid today is also to be held responsible for its fundamental provisions having fallen into oblivion, for this reason: first, because its regulations are not always so framed that they must be regarded without more ado as unconditionally binding; and then also because the Statute has made no provision whatever to prevent its provisions from being thwarted by the regulations of subordinate organisations, or to enforce the observance of its rules. A textbook example of this, my as-