Die Welt · Vol. X, No. 50 · 14 December 1906
13printed page
scan 11 of 20

No. 50 — "Die Welt" — 13

(continued from page 12)

…sertion is § 5 straight away. It has been objected from various quarters that many societies evade their obligations towards the Country Associations and in this way compel the Country Committees, in order to make their existence possible, to draw upon the Shekel moneys belonging to the A. C. But § 5 of the Statute expressly states: "In so far as the laws of the country permit, the Zionist societies are to unite in a Country Organisation". According to the clear wording of this paragraph, therefore, all the societies of a country are obliged to attach themselves to their Country Organisation, or to establish a Country Organisation, and of course also to fulfil their obligations towards these institutions. De facto, however, this provision stands only on the paper of our Congress Protocol. In Austria, for example, the Poale Zion refuse to subordinate themselves to the District Committees set up by the Country Committee, and, as it seems to me, with perfect right. In America there are a great many societies which do not belong to the Federation at all and are not united in any other Federation either, evidently in wholly unfounded contradiction to the provisions of the Statute.

The Poale Zion maintain that they would gladly place themselves directly under the Country Committee, but that for reasons of principle and of tactics they will have nothing to do with the District Committees. The question is most closely connected with the question of facilitating the formation of Federations, to which I shall return. Tactically and organisationally, the manner of setting up District Committees as a superior authority over the societies, which are in this way deprived of the possibility of dealing directly with the Country Committee, seems to me impractical and also in contradiction to the Statute, which expressly states that the societies must unite in a Country Organisation. In and of itself there is certainly nothing to be said against the establishment of District Committees, but they should come into consideration only as auxiliary and subsidiary organisations, without administrative powers over the societies being conferred upon them. So far as I can survey the matter, this independence of the District Committees has indeed in fact given rise only to delay and procrastination in the work of the Austrian organisation.

I hold, therefore: The provision by which all the societies of a country must unite in a Country Organisation must unconditionally be declared mandatory law. Every society that does not belong to a Country Organisation or to a Federation does not belong to the Organisation as a whole either. The insertion of independent intermediate instances into the sequence — A. C., Country Committee, society — must be forbidden.

On the other hand, no Shekel-payer is to be obliged to belong to a society.

That might under certain circumstances mean a constraint of conscience and could easily be abused. Nor, indeed, is any such provision contained in the present Statute. But if a Shekel-payer wishes to exercise his right to vote, he must first have fulfilled the obligations which the Country Committees demand of their members. He can then vote either with a society, by mutual agreement, or in a group of Shekel-payers who likewise belong to no society.

§ 7 of the Statute would expediently be supplemented to the effect that every society should send a copy of its list of Shekel-payers and of its Shekel account directly to the A. C. as well as to the Country Committee. In this way a control of the accounts of the Country Committees with the A. C. would be achieved without more ado, which today, very much to the detriment of the organisation, is entirely lacking.

Unconditionally necessary, in my view, is a provision which facilitates the formation of Federations. First of all, the number of 5000 Shekel-payers required for their formation should be reduced to 3000. Then, however, a provision should also be brought into the Statute expressly stating that the formation of Federations is not hindered by national frontiers, that there is accordingly nothing to prevent, for example, the Poale Zion of Russia from combining with those of Austria in one Federation, provided of course that the laws of the countries permit it. I hold that it can only be in the interest of the movement if views and opinions which have a fixed programme and a considerable number of adherents behind them come to unfold themselves and to be taken into account, instead of withering in the dark and — in listlessness and mistrust. And why should the same tendencies be refused representation or organisation because their adherents live in different countries? This possibility does not seem to me to be hindered by the Statute in force, but it appears as though practice has not sufficiently considered this possibility.

Concerning the greater A. C. the Statute states that it is to consist once for all of 52 members, and that the election by the Congress is to be preceded by the submission of nominations by the Country Organisations. This latter provision is evidently meant to express that the Country Organisations are to have a certain influence on the composition of the A. C., that the Country Organisations are to be represented in the A. C. But the provision is so unclear that in fact the opposite of what was intended has been achieved. Thus, for example, the Austrian Country Committee sends no representative to the present A. C.; and it has also happened several times that the list of nominations of the Country Committees has been disregarded by the Congress or by the Standing Committee. Everyone remembers the agitated scenes at the Congresses which arose in consequence. It is right that the A. C. should consist of delegates of the Country Organisations. In this way that intimate connection of the Country Organisations, and thus also of the societies, with the leadership is established which is unconditionally necessary for fruitful work and in the interest of mutual confidence. On the other hand, it is only justified if the seats in the A. C. are distributed in proportion to the importance of the Country Organisations or Federations. In praxi this mode is indeed already practised, so that, for example, the Russian organisation has the most A. C. members. But such a provision is nowhere precisely stated, and the door is opened wide to arbitrariness. I hold, therefore: the election of the A. C. members should take place through the Country Organisations, or through their delegates' conferences. Each Country Organisation should send 5 members to the A. C. for its first 5000 Shekel-payers, and one further member for every further 5000.

Those countries in which no Country Organisation exists, or where the Country Organisation numbers fewer than 1000 Shekel-payers, are to be united by the A. C. into one group and elect their representative to the A. C. jointly.

The President of each Country Organisation or Federation should be eo ipso a member of the A. C., but should be counted among the number of A. C. members to be elected by the individual countries. This simple condition guarantees the close connection of the Country Organisations with the leadership.

For the reckoning of the Shekel-payers only that sum should come into consideration which has actually been remitted to the A. C. In this way the Country Organisations which set store by an adequate representation in the A. C. will be compelled to deliver their Shekels in full to the A. C., which must of course be free to grant subventions to the individual organisations.

The inner leadership — that is a delicate chapter, which in my opinion can only ever be solved from case to case, according to the personalities available for it. One arrangement, however, would have to be made: the election of a General Secretary by the Congress. The General Secretary should be subordinate to the A. C. and in particular to the E. A. C. or its President. For the rest, however, he should conduct the business of the movement independently — in accordance with the instructions given him. He is the head of the Central Bureau of the movement, takes part eo ipso in all sessions of the E. A. C., of the A. C., of the Annual Conference and of the Congress, and has a consultative voice in the E. A. C. and in the A. C.; naturally he is salaried.

This arrangement would signify a great advance. It would resolve the difficulties which lie in the necessity of not salarying the members of the inner leadership, and would give the organisation the possibility of seeing at the head of affairs a man of its confidence, of whom it knows that he is more than a mere official blindly submitting to the instructions of the leadership, that he is an independently thinking mind who of himself gains an influence over the manner in which the movement is led.

These would be, broadly speaking, my proposals; naturally there are still many blemishes that would have to be removed. At bottom, however, I believe the Statute in force can remain, if it is remodelled in the points I have sketched in accordance with modern requirements and with experience. ibr.


A Suggestion for the National Fund

Troppau, 10 December 1906.

Dear fellow Zionists!

Permit me a few words in your esteemed paper under the heading "Suggestions for the National Fund".

The importance of the N.-F. has been well enough known to every Zionist since its founding, but in recent times it comes, with the