4 — "Die Welt" — No. 47
(continued from page 3)
...sudden precipice was drawing near. The most oppressed and the most enslaved were the Jews. But so too was all Russia. But Finland too was Russified with blood and iron. And "when everything falls, nothing falls" — says a French proverb. In a time of general depression the Jews felt their misfortune less. The heaviness of the atmosphere surrounding them weighed in a less sensible way upon the shoulders of the Jews — since it weighed upon the whole Russian Empire. . . When there could be no political questions, because there were not allowed to be any, the Jews' political direction was clear to them — at least to those who thought egoistically. If we have nothing to hope for in Russia, then we must seek our salvation elsewhere. And the national elements in Jewry joined Zionism, unquestioningly, devotedly. . Plehwe grasped the mood of the Jews and permitted the Conference — an event which at the time filled all Russia with astonishment — and with envy.
Minsk was over. And the mood too was soon to change. Russian reaction all at once perceived the approach of the struggle for life and death. The Russian Revolution drew near with thundering steps. Plehwe took up the struggle, gave the signal — and the first sally against freedom was Kishineff. The murderer in the minister's armchair knew where the weakest side of the Russians and of the Jews lay. He knew that neither of them could defend themselves — the one against the lure of the brutal force of raging and murder, the other against this crude physical force. And as in a whirl of events, in which one cannot rightly see where the beginning is and where the end, there followed one upon another the shocks that overturned the whole of life in Russia and created entirely new conditions. The war, the Revolution, the pogroms, the Duma, the era of the courts-martial, the era of Stolypin. What was once clear — hopelessness in Russia — has now become a tale of olden times. What formerly even the boldest optimists did not believe — the Constitution quand même — has now become a banal fact. What formerly even the gloomiest prophets of evil did not fear — the repetition of the frightful, organised pogroms — has now become almost an ingredient of constitutional Russian policy. And not only politically were these five years of revolutionary significance for Russian Jewry, but economically as well. What the theorists of the "Bund" and of the other Social Democratic parties could not achieve — the proletarianisation of the Jewish masses — these five years have accomplished. Countless Jews have been brought to the beggar's staff; most have been declassed, thrust out of their inherited, long-established order of class. A new economic situation brings new socio-political ideologies with it. And in the bosom of Jewry there did in fact arise new currents, new theories: the "Poale-Zion," the Wosroschdjenzi," the S. S., the Territorialists. The last are to be set down to the account of Zionism. So for Zionism too the five years have had an incisive effect. "Incisive" indeed, because they cut the formerly united and undivided movement into two parts that feud with one another. But even apart from this, so many problems have grown up for the Zionist as a normal man can scarcely digest. What is now understood by Zionism is not merely the Basle Programme. It is also national politics, national-social and national-cultural. Formerly, to be sure, people also spoke of "culture" and of "work in the present," but these were mere titles for programmes yet to be defined; they were headings for rubrics as yet empty. And now the time has come when the emptiness cries out to be filled, when words must be turned into deeds. And the hardest part draws near. How are the contradictions between willing and being able, between what ought to be and what is, to be reconciled? How is Zionism to be so extended that it could take into itself each and every national work without its capacity being exceeded and its beginning to burst at the seams? How is national work to be conceived; where are the limits; where does Zionism stop? And more still: is Zionism too narrow; ought one not to undertake a revision; ought one not to open afresh the question of how the re-establishment of the Jewish people is to come about? Zionism has found a general formula for the future. When it was laid down, the questions that now chiefly occupy men's minds still lay at rest in the darkness of times to come. But those times have come; the questions have pressed into the light of day and forced themselves upon us. Does the formula suffice? Formerly official Zionism meant as much as the exclusion of general, or better said internal, politics. "We are no international debating society" — such was the answer to the velleities of many Zionists who wished to seek all solutions in Zionism. Nowadays such an answer would no longer suffice. And there might well be found many a one who would boldly declare: "Yes, we are an international debating society! We are one because we have made the existence of the Jewish nation the starting-point of our movement, because we strove to make of our Congress a Jewish parliament, because a movement that has a renaissance for its goal must reach into the fullness of life, must not wrinkle up, must not shrivel." And if theory proved nothing, the facts prove it. Russia is an example. Ask the Zionist agitators what they did when the desperate struggles were going on in Russia, what they did when the elections to the first Duma were being prepared. Did they preach the Basle Programme? No — they taught the widening of the programme; they developed a programme of autonomy; they carried on national politics in the fullest sense of the word. Nor can it be done otherwise. Else they would have been swept away by the storm of the struggle. Where facts and ideas collide — so much the worse for the facts — Hegel once said, but he was mistaken.
A new structure of the party itself, a shifting of relations within as well as without, a new order of things in Russia, a disruption of the national equilibrium — such is the situation which the second All-Russian Conference in Helsingfors finds before it, and to which it must do justice. And new watchwords will emerge. One of these is the well-known "Ssejm project." A Jewish self-
