Die Welt · Vol. X, No. 46 · 16 November 1906
14printed page
scan 12 of 20
Facsimile · scan 12 of 20
Scan of p. 14
English · AI translation, checked against the German

14 — "Die Welt" — No. 46

(continued from page 13)

...too the friends of Palestine so far very weakly represented, indeed hardly at all, especially the Eastern ones, who, according to the discovery of Mr. Ussischkin and his faithful, are the full-valued, the only friends of Palestine, while the Western ones are tolerated by him, so to speak, as the Moors who are there to do their duty and . . . . to go!

This bringing to the fore of an opposition between Eastern and Western Jews is, be it said in passing, a very ugly feature in our movement; when Zionism arose there were for us no Russian, German, American Jews, but only Jews.

Our enemies, as is well known, do not recognize this distinction, but on the contrary make all Jews responsible for every piece of knavery that any Jew anywhere commits.

It was reserved for Mr. Ussischkin and his faithful to stress ever anew this distinction between Eastern and Western Zionists, which constantly and quite needlessly clouds the friendly relations necessary in our movement.

After what has been said earlier, it is understandable that many a participant in the Conference felt quite oppressed when the many new claims on the N. F. began to rain down. . . .

Dr. Marmorek hit the nail on the head when, among other things, he raised the question whether we all wish to carry on the political movement in Herzl's sense, or whether a part of the gentlemen of the A. C. wish to represent the old Chovevei Zion standpoint and lose themselves in petty things?

Several answers followed upon this; I shall concern myself chiefly with that of Mr. Ussischkin, because it is of fundamental importance. Mr. Ussischkin threw out his chest, and could not refrain from appealing to the majority created for his ideas at the last Congress and asserting that he will possess a like majority at the Eighth Congress as well. I will not now inquire how the majority of the Seventh Congress was constituted and in what manner this majority functioned. I wish to concern myself principally with Mr. Ussischkin's ideas.

What does Mr. Ussischkin want? And what separates us from Mr. Ussischkin?

Mr. Ussischkin wants Palestine work. Why do he and his friends not work for Palestine? I mean really work, not merely with catchwords!

I have shown that at present we may grant no more N. F. moneys, nor may the Bank leave its prescribed limits. The capital of our Bank, too, we must guard against being tied up, just as we guard the moneys of the N. F.

The thousands of shares, for which the money was brought together penny by penny, like the famous share of the water-carrier of Jassy, must not be withdrawn from their purposes.

There remains, then, the only possibility, namely to stimulate and support private initiative. To put one's own hand in one's pocket and induce one's friends to do so, in order to create viable conditions of work, above all to bring able, capable men to Palestine, that is the way and the best propaganda. to attain our ends in Palestine!

But to squander the laboriously gathered kreuzers of the people's property, that is bad work, and it will not be hard for us to convince the people that Ussischkin's eternal catchwords have no practical value. There is no sense in always having resolutions passed at the Congresses and Conferences which cannot be carried out for want of means. That only means calling out of the window to the world: "See all that we accomplish for Palestine!" That is an irresponsible proceeding, if only because it awakens false hopes.

At the Annual Conference much time was spent on proposals of Mr. Ussischkin which had no practical value. The resolution was passed to grant workers 20000 Frcs., with which they are absolutely not helped. At the same Annual Conference some people, without making long speeches, did real work for Palestine, without proclaiming it from the housetops.

I should like to ask Mr. Ussischkin to set out for us a clear programme — if he has one — and to tell us what he actually wants to do?

The programme with which he came forward about 2 years ago was unpractical, and therefore thoroughly bad!

If he has proposals which we can carry out, we shall gladly seek to come to an understanding about these proposals; but if again he has only proposals which are impracticable and fit only to disturb the unity of our party, then we must enlighten the people in this regard, so that it knows what we have to do and what to leave undone. That will not be hard for us.

The trumps, "here Western Jews, there Eastern Jews, here Palestine work, there secret resistance!" etc. — these Mr. Ussischkin has played against us quite long enough.

We wish now at last to hear clearly with what programme Mr. Ussischkin means to create a majority against us at the Eighth Congress. I repeat: we are not against systematic and fruitful Palestine work; we wish only to guard the people's pennies from being squandered; on the other hand we are willing to give for Palestine as much as each of us can. It will be seen that many whom Mr. Ussischkin treats as enemies of Palestine make far greater sacrifices for Palestine than he himself.

Of the many speeches by Mr. Ussischkin's most intimate friends, one touched me most disagreeably: it was that of Dr. Weizmann, who is for unconditional, immediate Palestine work. Dr. Weizmann, who is engaged in practical life and knows that nothing can be created with phrases, complains that he has no arguments with which to carry on an effective propaganda for Palestine. So far as I know, Dr. Weizmann is an able chemist. The best speech Dr. Weizmann could make for Zionism would be for him to go to Palestine and create a small chemical industry, producing articles that are needed in the country and can possibly also be sold in the rest of the world. In such a factory he could, with relatively small means, create a secure livelihood for a far greater number of workers than through all of Mr. Ussischkin's proposals.

I will not merely serve Dr. Weizmann with advice, which he perhaps does not need at all, but I declare myself gladly ready to help him raise part of the sum required for the creation of a viable, ably managed undertaking.

That is one of the ways in which we can procure a secure livelihood for a larger number of workers in Palestine, and such examples we already find, thank God, in Palestine now. In this direction our excellent President of the Palestine Commission, Professor Warburg, has developed a programme on a large scale and created a ground on which great things could be created in Palestine with private means.

In conclusion I should like to advise Mr. Ussischkin not to continue the old fight with the old means. If he knows how to read the signs of the times aright, he will have to see that these are wholly used up.

For the rest, we shall take care to prove how wrong Mr. Ussischkin is to reproach us with a "secret resistance" to Palestine work.

If I apostrophize Mr. Ussischkin in particular, this is because Mr. Ussischkin, since the rise of our movement, has pleased himself in the pose of a predestined hereditary leaseholder of the Zionist movement. It was Mr. Ussischkin who gave our youth the ugly example of indiscipline. It was Mr. Ussischkin who pushed aside with a rough hand the most deserving of our fellow Zionists.

The letter from the "Mountains of Israel" was the welcome moment for mounting the high horse. The fraternal strife that shook the whole party was a wanton one, and the split need never have occurred had the East African question been treated calmly and objectively. Mr. Ussischkin should have known that whoever sows the wind reaps the whirlwind, and that it is the most ruinous thing of all to stir up still further the already vehement passion of our youth. One must not wonder if some luminaries now push themselves forward in whom presumption stands in glaring disproportion to their abilities and achievements.

Mr. Ussischkin would do well now to descend from his height and, as an ordinary mortal, strengthen our party in good accord with the others, instead of fighting it with false catchwords; that luxury we cannot permit ourselves.

I seek in vain for positive works that Mr. Ussischkin had accomplished for Palestine. It was, for example, bad work that Mr. Ussischkin lately sent a young rabbi to Palestine (if I am not mistaken, the travelling expenses were met from shekel moneys), so that he, without understanding anything of a bank, might pass disparaging criticism at the Annual Conference on the activity of the Bank and its officials.

Mr. Feiwel has complained that the Jews of means their