Die Welt · Vol. X, No. 46 · 16 November 1906
13printed page
scan 11 of 20
Facsimile · scan 11 of 20
Scan of p. 13
English · AI translation, checked against the German

No. 46 — "Die Welt" — 13

(continued from page 12)

...if they are rightly carried out, a great promise for future colonization.

This experimental station will naturally hardly be able to maintain itself and will probably have to be supported from the interest of the N. F. Meanwhile, for about two years, the N. F. has acquired, on the proposals of the Palestine Commission, two estates, together to the amount of about £8000. According to communications from the Palestine Commission these must now be rounded off. The sum needed for this is undetermined; let us for the present assume only £1000.

Further, the Bank, on the instructions of the A. C. and the Bank directors, has acquired land for about £8000, which was intended partly for the N. F. and partly for resale to private persons.

Since the Bank cannot for the present dispose of this land, the N. F. must take it over entirely, because no one can wish the Bank to leave its moneys lying permanently idle in such a way. That is a further £8000 to be taken from the N. F. Part of this land is now to be used for the Kishineff orphans, who have meanwhile grown up.

It must be remarked on this occasion that the said estates, which have been in the possession of the N. F. for about 2 years, neither yield the N. F. anything worth mentioning, nor can for the present be colonized with Jews, nor are suited for the projected experimental station. Other suitable lands will now be sought for the experimental station. This, however, is a settled matter and one of the most important establishments we must make in Palestine in the interest of a rational colonization — the sooner the better. For the land required, the buildings with their equipment, etc., we reckon about £15,000.

Then, further, 50,000 Frcs. (about £2000) have been granted to the Bezalel for the building of a house; let us hope that it will manage with this sum. This institution, too, is just as necessary for Palestine as the experimental station, and has therefore likewise been unanimously resolved upon.

For the planting of the Herzl Forest, for which olive-tree donations are being collected, a piece of ground has been in view, for whose acquisition the Palestine Commission has for some time been in negotiation; this too must be paid for with N. F. moneys.

If these works, raised to resolutions, are carried out even with the greatest caution, we shall not only have far exceeded the use of N. F. moneys permitted by the Congress — in my opinion far too high — but shall have totally exhausted the N. F.

Now we must further consider that after the building of the experimental station, this, as said, cannot possibly maintain itself; the N. F. will have to grant it an annual subsidy if it is to accomplish what is expected of it.

Added to this, the N. F. must place about 10,000 Frcs. a year at the disposal of the Palestine Commission for its works in Palestine. Besides this the N. F. has undertaken the payment of an agronomist at about 5000 Frcs. a year, who for the present can as yet do no productive work. Moreover there are still other expenses for Palestine for which the N. F. must on occasion foot the bill.

The total property of the N. F. now amounts to about £53,000. From this £1000 must be deducted for olive-tree donations, which have an account of their own and are now to be used.

Consequently, from the remaining £52,000 we must deduct the items of £8000 + 4000 + 8000 + 15,000 + 2000 = £37,000. There then remain about £15,000, which at best can bring us about 12,000 Frcs. in interest, which are not even sufficient to cover the works granted in Palestine and to subsidize the experimental station, to say nothing of unforeseen expenses.

Every reasonable man will have to admit that we have far overstepped the bounds of what is permissible, and that it is a great, unpardonable mistake if the N. F. is not allowed to grow strong to a certain height, so that it may become the instrument that all have imagined it to be. And even if one might or must abandon the original standpoint, it is still very questionable whether it is economically admissible to commit the Fund, through continual new, unproductive and uncertain purchases and expenditures, to such a degree that the lands and institutions established by the N. F. can no longer even be maintained from the interest on the remaining sum.

That would be, let us say it shortly: the National Fund crash!

Who will answer for that before the whole world? For my part, I publicly decline — if things should go on like this — all responsibility.

Now come the Zionists who call themselves practical, who would gladly persuade the world that they are the only friends of Palestine, and say: "If we do not go on using the N. F. to buy land in Palestine, nobody will give anything more to the N. F.; Palestine work with the money of the N. F. is the only method of enlivening our movement and carrying it into wider circles."

These assertions are, knowingly or unknowingly, untrue.

There are, above all, in our movement no friends of Palestine and no enemies of Palestine, but so-called practical Zionists, who would like to carry out unpractical Palestine work à tout prix, and political Zionists, who are intent on doing in Palestine only practical, systematic work, so that everything we do in Palestine may have lasting existence.

As may be seen from various speeches delivered at the Annual Conference, some gentlemen, with Mr. Ussischkin at their head, have again pleased themselves in asserting that one must only with difficulty — let us not say wrest — but coax something for Palestine out of the political Zionists.

Presumably some of these gentlemen need grist for their mills, which run the risk of drying up; others perhaps act in good faith, and wish to talk themselves and the world into the delusion that the political Zionists will do nothing for Palestine. Both thereby produce false opinions which must be refuted.

I should very much like to know the names of those who have offered a "secret resistance" to the resolutions cited, as has been asserted. That these resolutions have not all been carried out up to now is due, as is well known, to quite other circumstances.

Among other things, 20,000 Frcs. were granted for the immigrant workers in Petach-Tikwah, who have neither land nor house. With this sum the workers can do absolutely nothing, and the finest of it is that the workers themselves, according to the letter read by Dr. Scheinkin, wanted nothing from the N. F.

Truly, these poor people have a far higher opinion of the significance of the N. F. for the Jewish people than their supposed friends. These people are to be helped in quite another and a surer way. I shall come back to this later.

Just like the N. F., the Bank in Palestine, too, is far too heavily committed for its circumstances. But everything has its limits, and everyone who possesses the right sense of responsibility and has the future before his eyes must shrink from a headless use of the property of the N. F.

No unctuous speeches and reproaches that a "secret resistance" exists against Palestine work are of any avail. That is not true; it does not exist. We wish only to prevent the laboriously scraped-together, tiny property of the N. F. from being added to the dead millions that lie buried in Palestine!

I would recommend to all those who talk and write so much about the use of the N. F. that they rather employ the time in pursuing the canvassing for the N. F. more zealously. For I will say it here once again: only a few individuals have ever worked for the N. F. at all; otherwise it would truly look quite different now!

For the rest, the N. F. alone can now accomplish very little for Palestine. The contrary assertion is a clumsy invention. If private initiative does not take a hand, if above all capable, practically proven, acknowledged able and self-sacrificing people are not found ready to go to Palestine in order to create something there, then one will wait in vain for the miracles of the N. F.

With love for Palestine alone, with people who are only friends of Palestine, we shall not carry our cause further.

It is of no importance whether of the 40,000,000 dunam in Palestine a tenth of one per cent (it is not even as much as that) or a somewhat larger fraction belongs to the N. F. this year. What is important is that everything which is done there should bear any criticism.

Professor Warburg, who submitted a programme on a large scale to the Annual Conference, gives all those who wish to prove their friendliness to Palestine privately opportunity enough for work, and it will soon be seen what the great majority, to which Mr. Ussischkin so likes to appeal, will contribute to this Palestine work. If the necessary means are supplied to Professor Warburg, he will surely also provide the suitably able people who will accomplish something proper in Palestine.

Unfortunately we had to learn from Professor Warburg that so far, for example, the friends of Palestine have contributed least privately to the Bezalel. I have also seen the list of the Industrial Syndicate which Professor Warburg has established; there are