No. 42. — "Die Welt" — Page 13.
CORRESPONDENCE
On the Amendment of the Organisation Statute
I.
The remittance of the shekel moneys to the A. C. has always been a sore point with our federations. Much has been discussed and written about it, concessions of a material kind have been made to the L. C.; but what success has all this shown? Has the material position of the A. C. been improved thereby? Its financial reports give sufficient information on that head. In the measure in which the movement grew, the income of the A. C. became relatively smaller and smaller. At first sight this seems paradoxical. But if one inquires more closely, one finds the place that stands in need of reform: that place is the federation.
With the number of Zionists there grew not only the budget of the A. C. but also that of the national centres. But whence is the national centre to take the money to defray its current expenses? The nearest to hand are the shekel moneys. Even if these are not entirely used up, they are so decimated that the A. C. once more comes off short. One sees, therefore, that it is the federations which in the first place need reform; only when their material position is secured can the shekel receipts be remitted to the A. C. in correct fashion. And the strengthening of the material position of the federations can, in my opinion, easily be carried out in the following manner:
Every Zionist must belong to the national and to the world organisation; in other words, he must pay the shekel and the national contribution in order to possess the active and passive franchise for the Congress. For the collection of the national contributions is in a very bad way to-day.
As a classic example I will here cite the District of Moravia and Silesia.
Here there are 1206 shekel-payers; of these barely a quarter pay the national contribution. The Austrian L. C. loses about 1000 Kr. thereby. In other districts matters stand no better in this respect. If one now reckons what sums are lost here, one must come to the conclusion that a change must be brought about. Pressure must, of course, be brought to bear upon the members of the organisation that they fulfil their obligations, and this is easily done if § 1 of the Organisation Statute is formulated as follows: The Zionist Organisation comprises . . . . . . . and pay shekel and national contribution. The receipt for the shekel also counts as the receipt for the national contribution, since from now on every Zionist must pay both. Although I am not optimistically disposed, I believe I may assume that the material position of both bodies — the federation and the A. C. — would be considerably improved.
And now something more. The proposal of Herr J. Berger, which aims at having the budget of the A. C. defrayed by occasional donations, is not open to discussion. The A. C. and the movement would be brought into discredit thereby.
Herr S. Weil is a great idealist if he hopes, in accordance with his proposal, to obtain a shekel of 5—6 marks as a minimum. Let an inquiry be held into Herr Weil's proposal, but not in Germany and in Austria, rather in Russia and Roumania, where relatively the most shekels are sold; Herr Weil will be greatly disappointed by the result. And then this proposal has the further disadvantage that its translation into practice is capable of bringing out class antagonisms within the organisation, which might easily harm the movement.
Julius Fried.
II.
The Actions Committee, at the annual conference in Cologne, expressed the conviction that the Organisation Statute requires remodelling.
What is the use of turning many phrases here and trying to cloak the state of affairs, when the naked facts speak most plainly? The A. K. has come to this conviction because the sum of the shekel moneys flowing into its treasury is not remotely sufficient to cover the current expenses, let alone to undertake anything new, however important it might be. For our comfort and reassurance we were assured that the number of the Scheckolim this year, in comparison with other years without a Congress, may even be called satisfactory. Only the moneys have not been, or not yet been, remitted to the A. K.; they have stuck fast somewhere, provisionally or for good. The form of the franchise for the Congress, too, was said not to be unexceptionable; and the mode of election ought to be changed.
Herr J. Berger, in No. 37 of the "Welt," makes proposals for the amendment of the Organisation Statute which induce me to express my view on this question as well.
I do not doubt that we shall manage to find another form of franchise. Whether the other form will be as good, better or worse in practice, who could say with certainty beforehand? There will be much writing, much speaking, there will even be much work. The urge to activity will find a cheap field in which it can unfold itself. We shall change the mode of election. I assume it is already changed. But where are we to take the money from, by that, to pay the expenses which an organisation such as ours has and must have?
The institution of the shekel has become naturalised in the Zionist world. The shekel has already received the consecration of years. In the widest Jewish circles it is known that the payment of one shekel a year gives a Jew the franchise for the Congress, makes him a Zionist citizen. Experience has taught that, in general, a Zionist has not stopped at the payment of the shekel. He who did so afterwards did not pay the shekel either and no longer comes into consideration as a Zionist, or else he was poor and could not give more, and from such one cannot demand more now either.
To me an alteration of the shekel appears almost like an abolition, and I consider it dangerous to abolish or to alter the institutions which were created in the first, the Herzlian, epoch of Zionism.
The changes hitherto proposed demanded: The amount of the shekel is not to be fixed at 1 franc or mark; everyone is to be free to pay one or several shekels. Or a kind of income tax is to be introduced. Everyone is to pay shekels according to his income. Herr Berger demands: Shekels are to be paid by all; every person to whom Zionism appears to signify something good is to pay the shekel. Why not non-Zionists too?
These are all pious, even very pious wishes. One must, however, reckon with what one has. And now we have arrived at the reckoning. So the shekels, we are told, have for the most part been paid, and this we also believe. We have so much confidence in our Zionists and in Herzl's institution of the shekel that we calmly assume the shekel is being paid everywhere. Well then, the shekel paid in has to be applied fully and wholly to its destination, has to be paid out to the A.-K., or, more plainly, to the E. A. K. Towards this very easily attainable goal we must strive in this respect. I say: very easily attainable goal, and I add that the institution of the shekel will be strengthened if all Zionists are sure that the shekel is duly remitted to the E. A. K., and that the coming to light of the contrary will drive many shekel-payers, and thereby many Zionists, out of the organisation.
The number of our adherents has long been estimated at half a million, and so the heads of many a federation have found out: it would be too much if 500 000 Fr. were placed at the disposal of the Actions Committee every year, and, in consideration that the federations were only too often in money difficulties, they claimed the shekel moneys partly for themselves. Partly does not always mean a part of the whole; one can also take the whole partly. The Actions Committee had the weakness to make concessions; the demands of the federations grew ever greater, until at last we have come so far that there are federations which remit not a pfennig to the Actions Committee. Only wait quietly, gentlemen; the heads of these federations will have the most to say at the next Congress, they will subject the activity of the Actions Committee to a minute criticism, will finally come forward with their better ideas, make proposals and pass resolutions, they will even distribute moneys from the tribune, the moneys given away will be recorded in the minutes, but no one will see them, those many moneys, and least of all the supreme leadership. And why should they? Let
