"Die Welt" — No. 39 — Page 4.
(continued from page 3)
…the calculating, merely intellectual element, — and this is a form of philanthropy.
If, then, the course of development within the Zionist party had of "immanent necessity" to be the one described above, all the fears which this possibility inspires would be entirely justified; it would then really be a "question of principle, upon which the Congress will have to decide in its sovereignty."
But if one looks at the matter more closely, the fears prove to be unfounded. Unfounded, because the movement cannot, will not, go the way of losing itself in the sand of individual work. It cannot, because it is a popular movement, because in this alone lie its strength and its greatness. But a people demands great prospects. It demands mountains, and beacons upon the mountains. In the lowlands it is hard to breathe. If the movement means to be a popular one, — and that is indeed its only possibility of existence —, it will have to remain upon the heights, will be broad-minded, as before. But however beautiful an idea may be, some day it must after all be realised. An ideal attained is no longer worth the longing, — that is true — but none the less all men wish to have attained their ideal. A political movement is like a pyramid. Airy on high, in the steep and beautiful height, enthroned, towering, storming the heavens, stands the idea, the ideal. Only a few can behold the summit in all its golden splendour. The many see it only dimly, indistinctly. And it materialises as it descends. It grows ever broader, ever more accessible, yes — flatter too. And when it reaches the base, one has before one a broad mass, level with the ground, but solid, unshakable, bearing the whole.
The fear of the adherents of the "pure idea" in Zionism is the fear of the descent, of vulgarisation. The shyness of the adherents of the "applied idea" is the shyness of one who looks up from below at the dazzling sunlight that plays about the summit of the pyramid. And yet it is but one pyramid, una et indivisibilis.
Politics embraces both: idea and reality, height and valley. On the summit alone one cannot live. The base without the summit is no whole; it is a trunk, a shapeless mass. One hears much now of the struggle that is to break out at the next Congress; one hears announcements of this struggle on this side and on that. The gauntlet flutters in the air. — And yet no thinking politician will be able to say that the struggle is "necessary," really conditioned by circumstances. Struggle — so be it. It is, after all, the father of all that comes to pass. But for what? What prize will fall to the victor? For many a long day men have been speaking and writing of the necessity of a deepening of Zionism. But what does deepening mean? — It is the prevention of one-sidedness, of excessive height and of boundless breadth. Deepening means reconciliation, because it means the abolition of antitheses, which are indeed often only apparent. The deeper treatment of Zionist questions, their subsumption under general sociological principles and methods, has long since proved the non-existence of the antitheses lately brought into prominence. It has shown that practical small work and political large-scale work are bound up with one another in the closest fashion, that they are but two sides of the same idea. Shall we now once more commit the error of which Herbert Spencer once spoke, of seeing the shield from one side only, the concave or the convex? I hope that the sound instinct of the people will preserve us from this. Cor.
THE YEAR 5666 IN OUR HISTORY
(Continuation)
Roumania
The past year was the saddest imaginable. No pogrom — the pogrom is but a popular edition of the annihilation of the Jews — but cobweb nets of legalised barbarity. The Jews are murdered insidiously, by systematically curtailing for them the minimum necessary for existence. Hundreds of thousands, fitted into a fixed order of injustice, are perishing slowly but surely. The guides of their destiny are not only Roumanian bureaucrats, but Roumanian representatives of the people as well. Roumania is proud of its progress, of its constitution — for the Jews it is a cancer which imperceptibly gnaws at them, undermines them, destroys them. The number of Jews is diminishing, but worse still is the situation of those who have remained behind. Lack of rights and insecurity of domicile make the Jews consume themselves in a fruitless struggle. Thousands have in the course of the last years lost their livelihood entirely. It is also the source of all the vices and of the misery — the mutilation and crippling of existence. If one ventures timidly forward, he is shamefully thrust back, or he becomes a renegade. It is regarded as an especially favourable dispensation when in the course of a year a few Jews are naturalised, that is, receive the rights that belong to them. The "naturalisation" of all the Roumanian Jews should accordingly take about a geological period. Rough is the path, the way is long. Meanwhile there develops an undignified place-hunting, which dies away in humility before all authority and squints with lustful interest towards being singled out. The morally fallen fancies himself superior.
A leaden, hopeless Goluth. Sprung not from fury, but from a system of worldly-wise, even "liberal" scoundrels. It is death — but not the death of the brave in a lion's cage; it is the death of a fly, torn, gnawed by a spider. The worst of it: it grows tedious — just because everything violent, every leap, is wanting. And where is the Alliance spirit that once bestirred itself to bring about interventions? The enterprising flight has ended; the wings of fancy have dropped. "There is simply nothing to be done." Weary from unsuccessful attempts, the Alliance providence gazes helplessly upon this scene of annihilation. "Lasciate ogni speranza"...
