Die Welt · Vol. X, No. 38 · 19 September 1906
14printed page
scan 12 of 20
Facsimile · scan 12 of 20
Scan of p. 14
English · AI translation, checked against the German

Page 14. — "Die Welt" — No. 38.

REPORT ON THE SOUTH GERMAN ZIONIST CONFERENCE IN MANNHEIM

(Sunday, 16 September 1906)

On the eve a public meeting was held in the Casino hall. The hall, which holds over 300 persons, was completely filled, and that by all circles of Jewish society. The speakers, the advocate Dr. Hantke, Berlin, Dr. Dreyfuß, Kaiserslautern, and Dr. Isaak Strauß, Munich, spoke in excellent terms before an audience giving the most complete attention. 10 new members enrolled in the Mannheim local group. Afterwards the members of the Mannheim local group remained together in pleasant conversation with the delegates who had already arrived.

The Proceedings

The advocate Dr. Hantke, Berlin, opened the meeting shortly after 9 o'clock in the morning in the name of the Central Committee and as deputy for the President, the advocate Dr. Bodenheimer, Cologne, who was prevented from attending. In his address he also made mention of the present jubilee of the reign of the Grand Duke of Baden and of the gratitude which we Zionists owe for the constant interest of this prince.

The presidium and bureau were unanimously elected from the following gentlemen: Julius Simon, Dr. Friedemann, Dr. Kaufmann, Freiburg, Dr. Cahen, Mannheim, J. L. Goitein, Frankfort, and Bickard, Strasburg.

Thereupon Dr. Moses, Mannheim, delivered his address on the

internal situation of Zionism in Germany.

In broad outline he traces the development which Zionism has taken in Germany. He compares the inner dissension and impotence of the German Landsmannschaft at the 7th Congress with the discipline and the clear political conception at the earlier Congresses. That must change again. We must struggle through to complete clarity, so that at the 8th Congress we should have a firm standpoint to represent and to defend. This standpoint, however, could rest only on this: that it would be the task of the 8th Congress, whose watchword had indeed already been given out at the annual conference, to confirm the resolutions of the 7th Congress, but faithfully to see to it that the limits which the 7th Congress had drawn were respected. No dogma might confine us; neither the one that for the present no political successes were possible, nor the one that a charter was impossible after activity in the land. We must perform both Palestine work and diplomatic work. As regards the latter activity, we must indeed expressly state our expectation that the leadership follow the political constellations with unremitting attention and let fall none of the threads which Herzl had spun. As for the Palestine work, however, it was only the consequence of the German Landsmannschaft's own motion to set up the Palestine Commission that it should also approve an activity of that Commission in Palestine, and not merely one of pure exploration. What sense would there otherwise be in it, if we might only discover, but not carry out? Not, to be sure, with our own means, since these unfortunately fail us for that purpose, but rather by vigorously stimulating Jewish private initiative. We are creating an information bureau. For whom?

A duty of honour for the German Landsmannschaft, precisely at present, in view of the conditions in Russia, which made an orderly financial administration from there impossible, must consist in the shekels being remitted to the organisation to the last pfennig.

At the Delegates' Conference the Palestine shekel had been resolved upon; now we must also take care, to the best of our powers, for the carrying out of this resolution.

Then, however, as regards propaganda, we should devote ourselves especially to individual propaganda among the young. The older people we could seldom induce any more to think their views through formally anew. Them, however, we must interest in our practical work, in the Bank and in the National Fund. He had also proposed the founding of a neutral Palestine society, which he regarded as a valuable bridge between those who stand aloof from us and ourselves. This Palestine society could, should it meet with a lively interest on the part of the Zionists, who must recruit for it in wide circles, furnish means for tasks which would hold the interest of wider circles as well, but in the last resort would benefit our Palestine work alone. The broad public was to be continually enlightened about our aims, the press was not to be left out of account, our relations with it were to be cultivated, and neutral societies too were to be interested in Zionist lectures.

Then, however, the internal work of the groups must be given the attention that is its due. (Lively applause.)

From the discussions, that of Dr. Friedemann may be singled out, who does not agree with the speakers that the standpoint of the 7th Congress must remain untouched, since that Congress had created no clear programme. Meanwhile, however, a basis for an understanding had now rather been found, since the Zione-Zion had apparently proved that they too did not go along with everything that Ussischkin proposed to them.

The speaker welcomed an activity of the Palestine Commission which would meet the desire of the masses to take part in the work. The work, however, must be of such a kind that it did not awaken the mistrust of the Government. In so far as the work did not harm the political activity, it was to be welcomed. Any colonisation from the means of the National Fund, however, was to be rejected.

The immigration of well-to-do elements was desirable; but only the means of livelihood for the immigrants might be created, and they were not to be colonised without system.

Dr. Hantke, Berlin, sums up his remarks in the following principles:

He recommends advocating the economic exploration of Palestine and of its resources. For this, agricultural experimental stations were necessary. The strengthening of the Jewish element demanded the creation of conditions of livelihood, the stimulation of private industry and the enlistment of valuable forces. To be rejected were all subsidies, all colonisation from the means of the whole body, and all promotion of immigration on a charitable basis. The Bank must be conducted only on commercial lines, and the National Fund used only for secured purchases of land. There also took part in the discussion Messrs. Sontheimer, the advocate Dr. Veith, Goitein, Dr. Halpern, Reich and Simon. Even though the discussion diverged in many particulars, it could nevertheless be stated that a convergence of views is gaining ground, and that in particular the mutual mistrust has vanished. At bottom no one raised objection to Dr. Hantke's theses. Whoever wished for restrictions did so less on grounds of principle than because his confidence in the practical feasibility of individual undertakings and foundations was still lacking; and whoever wished for more intensive work in Palestine had to acknowledge that the present means of the movement were not sufficient for it. There was unanimity, however, in condemning the still unsettled position of the Bank, of which a complete reorganisation was demanded. It was agreed that in Ger-