Die Welt · Vol. X, No. 31 · 3 August 1906
19printed page
scan 17 of 20
Facsimile · scan 17 of 20
Scan of p. 19
English · AI translation, checked against the German

No. 31. — "Die Welt" — Page 19.

(continued from page 18)

…aims directed towards Palestine has furthered so much as precisely this resolution.

In the further debate several speakers declared that they had absolutely no wish to disavow the action taken in Liverpool and elsewhere by means of the resolution before the meeting, but that a vote on this resolution was now superfluous. Mr. Shire's motion to pass to the order of the day, since the meeting held it unnecessary to make its profession of faith once again, was carried.

In conclusion a very heated debate arose over a motion by Mr. Shire: "that every official action of the officers of the English Zionist Federation must first be approved by the Executive Committee." Mr. Shire reproached the leaders of the Federation for their manner of settling matters on their own authority, in particular Mr. Greenberg, for having published, without the knowledge of the Executive Committee, a joint appeal with the Ito in the name of the Federation.

Mr. Jacobs, seconded by Alderman Moser, moved that the meeting express its regret that the appeal with the Ito had been signed without first having been submitted to the Executive Committee.

Mr. Greenberg declared that he took full responsibility for having acted on his own authority in this case. He did not wish to speak here of the reasons that had led him to sign the letter. But it would be ridiculous to reproach him or Sir Francis Montefiore, even for a second, with having adopted Itoist ideas in any sense whatever.

Greenberg's remarks were accompanied by stormy interruptions. Percy Baker then spoke sharply against the independent proceedings of the leaders of the Federation. It was a question here not only of a matter of substance but also of a principle of form. The resolutions moved by Shire and Jacobs were carried. Finally a vote of thanks to Mr. Greenberg was adopted.

Postscript

Above, following the report of the "Jewish Chronicle," we have reproduced Dr. Gaster's remarks relating to the alteration of the Articles of the Colonial Bank and Dr. Herzl's part in it.

We can only assume that a fundamental error on the part of the reporting prevails here. For the facts themselves completely contradict the statements as they are here put into Dr. Gaster's mouth. In order, at all events, to rule out errors or false accusations once and for all, we will establish the actual state of affairs:

Dr. Herzl took no personal part in the sittings of the Bank Committee. The Bank Committee, which was entrusted with drawing up the Articles and the Memorandum, began its work in November 1898 and completed it at the end of February 1899. On 20 March 1899 the Articles were already registered by the court. Dr. Herzl, however, was not in London at all in the period from 8 October 1898 to 25 June 1899. It is therefore wholly incomprehensible how Dr. Gaster could be entitled to speak of Dr. Herzl's participation in the sittings and of remarks allegedly made by Herzl at them.

Equally incomprehensible is the story that in Vienna the word Palestine was struck out of the Articles, which Dr. Gaster is supposed afterwards to have censured.

The case is exactly the reverse. The Bank Committee, to which Dr. Gaster also belonged, adopted the present wording of the Articles on Bentwich's proposal. Against this the A. C. in Vienna protested and expressly demanded that the Bank Committee should keep strictly to the resolutions of the Congress. That Dr. Herzl took no part in the sittings of the Bank Committee, that he did not agree with the addition made by the Bank Committee, "or in any other part of the world," and wished to have only the wording "Palestine and Syria," is clearly evident from his remarks at the Third Congress (Congress Minutes, pp. 79, 80), which we give here:

"... Point 1 of Mr. Motzkin's indictment was that we had altered a resolution of last year's Congress, in that in the Articles of the Colonial Bank we had not taken quite such account of the declared will of this Congress as it was our duty to do. Now I can read you from the minutes of the Actions Committee the following telegram, which we addressed on 8 December 1898 to the members of the Bank Committee then staying in London: "Please take careful account of Congress resolutions in Articles; in particular provisions of Congress Minutes, page 149, § 1, further page 172, presidential remarks. Lasting influence of central leadership must also be secured with founders' shares." I believe this telegram covers us completely against Mr. Motzkin's reproach, in so far as the Actions Committee is concerned. The resolutions here referred to are contained on page 149 (reads): "Under the name 'Jewish Colonial Bank' a bank shall be established which stands under the supervision of a corporation instituted by the Zionist Congress. It has the task of furthering or founding the following undertakings, in so far as they hold out the prospect of a reasonable return." To this there were then added presidential remarks on page 172 of last year's minutes (reads): "Chairman Dr. Herzl: If I have understood rightly, the speakers in favour, who have chosen Dr. Marmorek, wish that in paragraph 1 of § 1, after the word 'Orient,' there should be inserted: 'In particular in Palestine and Syria,' and in the second paragraph, after the word 'agricultural colonies,' the words: 'In Palestine and Syria.'" That was one thing. These presidential remarks we recommended to the Bank Committee for observance in our telegram of 8 December. So far as it lay with us, therefore, what was necessary was done, and I do not doubt that Mr. Motzkin will be content with this explanation, but that, should he have further complaints, he will address them to that body which had to see to the carrying out of this Congress resolution ordered by us. I do not mean thereby to shift any responsibility from the Actions Committee, but only to have it made clear with what careful attention we have seen to the carrying out of the Congress resolutions. For Mr. Motzkin's speech does not concern merely a single paragraph or the disregard of a single word; rather, as the further structure of his speech has shown, he infers from it that no regard is paid to the will of the Congress on the part of the Actions Committee, which, I believe, can rightly no longer be maintained as regards Point 1, which he has brought forward. If, now, the Bank Committee in London has made an alteration, those gentlemen, and in particular their solicitor and collaborator who is present here, Mr. Bentwich, will doubtless be ready to give you the legal explanations of it. (Delegate Bentwich makes a remark.) Mr. Bentwich considers that the discussion of this point does not belong here, and that the proper place to speak of it is at the meeting of the Bank. I may refrain from taking a position on this, for in the present debate it suffices for the Actions Committee to justify itself against the charge that we have not carried out a Congress resolution or have tolerated its non-execution. (Approval.) ..."

That the Bank Committee itself made the alteration, and why it believed it must frame the Bank's Articles so that "the colonisation (which is initiated by the Jewish Colonial Bank) may take place in Palestine, Syria, or in any part of the world" — this Mr. Bentwich explained at the same Congress (Congress Minutes, p. 154) in the words: "If the lawyers did not carry out altogether what was demanded (by the previous Congress), that was owing to the fact that on some points the resolutions were not practicable under English law. ..."

With this the actual state of affairs is completely cleared up.


Miscellaneous News from the Movement

Eger, July 26. The local Zionists held a lecture on 22 July in the great Kursaal at Franzensbad under the title "Old Sufferings from New Times," since a protest demonstration had been prohibited by the district authority. The speakers were Mr. Fleischer, author, of Vienna, and Dr. Margulies of Teplitz, who branded the bloody events of Bjelostok.

Bielitz. The Zionist meeting held on Tuesday at the Kaiserhof was very well attended. Professor Dr. Werner, in his thoughtful and substantial address, drew a picture of the life and work of Theodor Herzl, pointed to his significance as a leader, and closed with an appeal to work in Herzl's spirit. (Lively applause.) Mr. Mich. Steuer, cand. phil., spoke on the massacres of Jews in Russia. The speaker did not omit to point also to the shameful conduct, above all of Jewish financial circles, who for the sake of a hoped-for Judas profit abandon their brethren in the East, with an easy conscience, to death at the hangman's hands, to the torments of the Inquisition and to dehumanizing mutilations. (Stormy cries: Shame on Taussig!) Thereupon the following resolution was adopted without dissent: 1. The Jewish population of Bielitz-Biala gives expression to its deepest abhorrence of the crimes that were committed against their Jewish brethren in Bjelostok. But it also condemns those who have financially supported such a system of government. 2. It gives expression to its admiration for the