18 — "Die Welt" — No. 31
(continued from page 17)
…to point the English Government and public to Zionism as the only solution. Sir Francis regarded it as a merit of his resolution that it contained no criticism whatever of the Russian Government.
It was precisely against this view that Dr. Gaster spoke out in sharp words. He declared it to be the duty of the Zionists, who are distinguished from the so-called Jewish "leaders" by their courage for the truth, to express in such a resolution their conviction of the guilt of the Russian Government and its officials, which had been proved by the Duma. Dr. Weizmann associated himself with Dr. Gaster's remarks, whereupon, after some debate, the resolution was adopted with Dr. Gaster's amendment.
The finances were then discussed, and on the motion of Mr. Bentwich a finance commission was elected, consisting of Messrs. Percy Baker, S. Aronson, H. Bentwich, M. Jacobs (Birmingham), Lewis (Cardiff) and P. Ettinger (Liverpool).
A stormy debate then arose over the question of amending the statutes of the Bank. Mr. Aronson and Dr. Weizmann moved that, in accordance with the resolutions of the Congress, of the Actions Committee and of the Board of Directors, all holders of shares should vote for the amendment of the statutes in the sense that the Bank may colonise only in Palestine and the neighbouring countries.
Mr. Cowen, on the other hand, moved that, in view of the circumstance that the proposed changes cannot guarantee that the Bank's monies will not be used for purposes outside Palestine and its neighbouring countries, the holders of shares should, in order to avoid useless expenditure, vote against the proposed changes at the next general meeting.
He gave as his reasons, among others, that the Congress was not always the best authority for deciding such technical questions. Were the statutes once altered, that would later be a dangerous weapon in the hands of the Territorialists.
Dr. Gaster expresses his regret that the meeting should be called upon to deliberate on matters which had already been declared settled by the decision of the Congress. Mr. Cowen's position as a Director of the Colonial Trust, he said, was not to be reconciled with his activity in this matter. Should he wish to resign, he could of course secure himself full freedom of movement. It was a distortion of the truth to say that the statutes, as they now read, offered a sufficient guarantee that the monies would be used for Palestine alone. There was the strict obligation to subscribe to the decision of the Congress and to concur in its resolution. — Dr. Gaster further declares that he by no means wishes to enter into a discussion on the original form of the wording of the Memorandum and the Statutes of the Colonial Trust, but — since he is exactly informed on the matter, it is his duty to bring forward one single fact, known to him alone. He was betraying no secrets, for it had been before the full meeting of the Board that the incident had occurred which he intended to mention here. — So far as his memory reached, there had been present at the meeting called for the purpose of settling the definitive wording both of the Memorandum and of the Statutes: Dr. Herzl as President, then Messrs. Wolffsohn, Kann, Luria, Barbasch and Bentwich, Dr. Jelsky and he himself. — Possibly one or two others had also been present, as for instance the late Mr. Schalit, but he could not vouch for the names. It was then for the first time that he became convinced of the change which had been made in the wording of the Memorandum. This had been sent to the Actions Committee with the word "Palestine" contained in it. To his very great astonishment he now found that this word had been entirely left out. This was one of the points on which he did not agree with Dr. Herzl, and that was why it had engraved itself so deeply in his memory. He protested against the word "Palestine" being struck out, and insisted that it be put back in. — Dr. Herzl opposed him and put to him the question of confidence. Dr. Herzl said emphatically: "Do you trust me?" whereupon he (Dr. Gaster) had answered: "With my whole soul! But," he had added, "not every one of us lives for ever, and what securities have we that the Congress will not meet and develop quite other views on the matter than it holds at present?" whereupon Dr. Herzl had answered: "Then it will simply no longer be a Zionist Congress." Dr. Gaster was then informed that there was a general clause which in such manner covered the whole of the Statutes and Memorandums and was further to govern all the statutes, and that moreover Palestine occupied a prominent place in the prospectus issued. That, then, was what had happened at the time, and thus far, further, went his responsibility with regard to the wording of the Statutes as they now read. Circumstances had shown that the fears which had been expressed at that time were entirely justified, and that the Congress might possibly come into danger of being no longer able to determine exactly the statutes of the Trust and their limits. "You must," Dr. Gaster concluded, "amend the statutes of the Trust, or else by tomorrow there might be nothing left of the money. —"
At these closing words a stormy scene ensued. Mr. Cowen felt himself insulted by the last remark and apostrophised Dr. Gaster in the most violent manner. The incident was settled by Dr. Gaster's declaration that his remark referred to the danger threatening from the Territorialists, and by an apology from Mr. Cowen.
Mr. Bentwich turned decidedly against the Cowen resolution. He said, among other things, that the English Zionists would set an evil example of disloyalty towards the Congress if they, upon whom a special responsibility was laid because the Bank had its seat in England, were to use some momentary majority or some other accident in order to nullify a resolution of the Congress of the Zionists of all the world. As for the alleged danger that the changes now made would open the door wide to later aspirations of the Territorialists, one must know that the sanction depended upon an English court of law, and that it would be quite hopeless for all opponents, after the present changes fixing the fundamental character of the Bank, to try to divert the Bank's monies in any other direction.
Mr. Greenberg declares himself against Cowen's motion. This is thereupon rejected and the Aronson-Weizmann resolution adopted.
The next item on the agenda again produced a very heated debate.
Mr. Cowen brought in the well-known Liverpool resolution for acceptance by the half-yearly conference:
"The delegates of the Central Committee of the English Zionist Federation place on record their conviction that only in the establishment of a legally secured and publicly assured home in Palestine lies a permanent relief for the Jewish people. They believe that nothing but failures and disappointments would result from an attempt to establish a Jewish state elsewhere than in the ancient homeland of the Jewish people, and that continual and increasing confusion would arise should the Jewish question remain in its present unsatisfactory and dangerous condition, which is alleviated only by philanthropic efforts that admittedly cannot prevail against it. They call upon all Jews, as well as all persons in sympathy with them, to support the Zionist movement standing under the leadership of the Actions Committee. A copy of this resolution is to be sent to the Prime Minister, the Secretary of State for Foreign Affairs and the Colonial Secretary."
Among the speakers who spoke to it was Dr. Gaster. He declares, among other things, that many speakers had regarded the resolution from the standpoint of a declaration of war against the Ito. If it were that, let it be said straight out: war or not. But it would be a downright insult to the intelligence of those present to ask now for an indemnity for a resolution passed months ago, when everyone knew that in the meantime pourparlers had taken place and joint declarations with the Ito had been brought about by the very same Zionist gentlemen who now laid the resolution before them. Why then a pretence of war in the resolution, if afterwards quite another tactic were to be adopted? He speaks against the resolution, since the Zionists, mindful of their interests, ought surely not to disturb the Ito if it should really bring something good.
Mr. Greenberg declared that the reason for bringing in the resolution at the time had been that it had been found that the English Government had been informed from some quarter that Zionism was finished, had been without significance since Herzl's death, and that the former Zionists had turned away from Palestine to another country. As this information had penetrated into many high circles, it had been time for the Zionist side to bring forward the proofs to the contrary. He was of the opinion that the plans of the Ito could bring our people nothing good, indeed could even bring it harm. It was therefore the duty of the English Zionists to make it clearly known that they are for Palestine alone. Some had said that the English Government put such resolutions into the waste-paper basket. He would state as a fact that nothing our
