6 — "Die Welt" — No. 23
A systematic carrying-out of self-taxation can provide a remedy here. A fixed, if small, percentage of income or expenditure should be required of everyone as a member of a Zionist local group. These regular, fixed contributions will take the place of, and supplement, the hitherto voluntary and therefore irregular ones. The collection is best made at each first meeting of the month by placing the contribution in a box, so that indiscretions are avoided. He moves: "The Xth German Delegates' Conference recommends to its local groups an early resolution upon this financially important question and requests that the result be communicated in the press."
Dr. Klee emphasises that Warburg's remarks, according to which Zionist moneys would on no account be used for purposes of colonisation, would have a reassuring effect. Mr. Simon, to be sure, had already roused fresh disquiet by his remark that a platform must be created in the country. A platform in the country, he said, was a most dangerous experiment. and it was extraordinarily hazardous to take upon oneself the responsibility for emigration to Palestine being in any way encouraged before public-legal security had been attained. Let us not forget that the elements emigrating from Russia come for the most part from a revolutionary milieu, that they will be readily apt to arouse the mistrust of the Turkish Government — doubly so if they use the "platform" in the country to strive for any autonomous rights whatever. It was not a question of the few groschen — although even there it must be stressed that the Zionist means were so limited that every costly experiment ought in itself to be avoided — but of the principle. Either the Porte is at all inclined to entertain the plans of the Zionists, and then it would also be diplomatic work in Herzl's sense to settle the modalities — the old charter policy of Theodor Herzl — or it is not, and then it will not let the raisins be picked out one by one by "Palestine pioneers" from the birthday cake which it will not give up of its own free will. (Lively applause on the right.)
Dr. Halpern, Hamburg, in reply to Klee's attacks upon the work in Palestine, points out that the Jewish pioneers who go to-day from Russia to Palestine have unlearned the fear of any danger. The first immigrants worked under the greatest exertions; they created the colonies, and the fate of the Armenians never threatened them! If some of them had no successes to show, that happened because every system and every support was lacking to them. It is sad that to-day, at a Zionist Delegates' Conference, one must positively beg for the toleration of work in Palestine. (Applause.) An exact distinction between exploratory work and the beginnings of colonisation, he said, was hard to draw. Prof. Warburg is the man in whom both sides have confidence, and it is he, indeed, who is called upon to lay down the guiding lines for the work in Palestine. (Lively applause.)
Dr. Elias Auerbach, Munich, maintains that those who are now so energetically opposed to all work in Palestine, even private work, should bear in mind that everything we have so far in Palestine was created by private work. They themselves in their agitation always spoke with pleasure of the "flourishing colonies"; but now it is to be forbidden to do anything. The speaker asks: how do the "politicals" conceive of attaining Palestine? From Dr. Jeremias comes the saying: as Herzl fell into our lap as a miracle, so we must wait until Palestine too should one day fall into our lap by a miracle. And that is supposed to be the "political" tendency? To-day Dr. Jeremias had declared Herzl's way, the use of political combinations, to be a vague and dangerous thing. From Dr. Klee one had heard to-day the same principles against the practicability of work in Palestine which our opponents have otherwise a hundred times held up against him: "If the Sultan did not wish it, the whole thing would not work." The speaker asks whether, then, what Dr. Klee had replied to our opponents on this point for eight years had been mere phrases; whether he himself had not been convinced that, in spite of all difficulties, we can reach the goal. The speaker maintains that to-day the "political" group has declared its bankruptcy: diplomatic work "stands before a wall"; practical work is to be forbidden. What then remains to be done? Nothing, save perhaps the meagre catchword of "national education of the people." The "Ito" has taken the course prophesied on the Zionist side; it is neither national, nor has it achieved anything, as Dr. Kalmus admits. — The speaker warns against too great timidity in regard to work in Palestine. It sounds almost as though it were a crime to do anything there. But work must be done. If we wish one day to be in Palestine, we shall have to go there. (Lively applause on the left.)
After remarks by Dr. Dannenberg, Metz, who sees in the present work for and in Palestine no breach of the Basle Programme, and regards this work as valuable from the standpoint of agitation as well, and by Dr. Zlocisti, Berlin, who warns against the so-called practical work in Palestine and regards the immigration of the "Palestine pioneers" as a fact by no means to be welcomed, which will yet bring disappointments, the discussion on the reports is closed for the present, and first of all, amid lively applause, discharge is granted to the Central Committee.
Thereupon the
Questions of the Press
are placed upon the order of the day.
Rechtsanwalt Hantke, Berlin, gave the introductory report. At the beginning of the movement the Jewish press stood so hostile towards Zionism that a Zionist party organ was an urgent necessity. The founding of the "Jüdische Rundschau" publishing house has accordingly furthered considerably the agitation and the spread and deepening of Zionist ideas among the Zionists. Meanwhile the general Jewish press has become more neutral, without a staunchly Zionist party organ having thereby become superfluous. Nor has the transfer of "Die Welt" to Germany in any way made the existence of the "Jüdische Rundschau" superfluous. The needs of the German organisation make it necessary that the party organ should report the German local news of the movement in the fullest detail, and that it can be delivered to all party comrades at a low price (for 75 ₰ quarterly). "Die Welt," he said, could not yet fulfil both these requirements to-day. It was, however, urgently necessary that both organs should co-operate in editorship and management. (Applause.)
There thereupon ensues a lively discussion on the "Jüdische Rundschau" and the manner in which it is edited, which at times becomes very heated and in which some 15 speakers take part, among them the editor of the "Jüdische Rundschau," Dr. H. Löwe. The Delegates' Conference finally adopts by a large majority the following resolution:
"The Xth Delegates' Conference of the German Zionists expresses its fullest confidence in the "Jüdische Rundschau" and its editor, Dr. Heinrich Löwe, and requests the editor to avoid, as far as practicable, everything that might wound fellow Zionists.
Dr. Alfred Nossig, Berlin, lays before the meeting a plan with which the Propaganda Commission has occupied itself. It concerns the founding of a national-Jewish daily paper in the German language. Such a paper would have to concern itself not only with Zionist and general Jewish questions, but also to illuminate world events from the Jewish standpoint. We have, he said, received the assurance from eminent representatives of non-Zionist groups of Jewry that a national-Jewish paper would find ample support. We have had the financial conditions and prospects of the undertaking ascertained by experienced experts in the field of newspaper publishing. The idea can be carried out if we are willing to begin, not with a great capital beyond our reach, but quite modestly, and to develop the paper gradually. We must amalgamate "Die Welt" and the "Jüdische Rundschau," and upon the basis of these two bodies of subscribers build up the national-Jewish daily. Then we shall create for Zionism a new instrument of power of the first rank.
The speaker proposes the following resolution:
-
"The Delegates' Conference considers it necessary and desirable that a Zionist daily paper, to appear in the German language in Berlin, be founded.
-
The Delegates' Conference entrusts the examination of this matter to a commission of nine members, and empowers the commission, should the plan prove practicable, to take the necessary steps." (Lively applause.)
This resolution was, as we may state in anticipation, adopted by the Delegates' Conference, and a commission was elected, to which the editors of "Die Welt" and the "Jüdische Rundschau" also belong.
Close of the Second Session.
* * *
In the evening a public meeting took place, at which Dr. Heinrich Löwe spoke on "Palestine, Land and People." The speaker, who from his own observation, and with the exhibition of exceedingly successful lantern slides, described the present conditions of Palestine and dwelt with particular affection on the Jewish colonies, found for his remarks, delivered with great warmth and filled with heartfelt enthusiasm, stormy
