Die Welt · Vol. X, No. 23 · 8 June 1906
5printed page
scan 5 of 24
Facsimile · scan 5 of 24
Scan of p. 5
English · AI translation, checked against the German

No. 23 — "Die Welt" — 5

(continued from page 4)

…since the people is not ripe, incapable of cultivating it. The task of the present, he said, is to organise nationally; in Germany, to be sure, this course would be mistaken, but not so in Russia, Hungary and Austria.

We ought to seek to further the education of the coming generations and, beyond that, do nothing, absolutely nothing, but propagate the idea of Zionism; above all we must not engage in any practical activity in Palestine, because it discredits us, since for such endeavours, besides legal security, milliards would have to be at our command if they are to succeed. We must therefore not touch the National Fund, and must see to it that the money of the Jewish Colonial Bank remains liquid and bears interest, so that through the years the millions may accumulate. The speaker further begs that all hostility be laid aside, since it is only the path that is to be combated, not the final goal; the path which the ruling party wishes to take, but whose impossibility I shall soon demonstrate. (Lively applause on the right.)

Dr. Mühsam, Berlin, moves the following resolution: "That the Central Committee initiate the founding of a national-Jewish organisation for the country as the political and economic representation of the interests of the Jews in Germany."

It is pointed out that in Austria and Russia large economic associations have combined within the Zionist organisation, especially the Poale-Zion, who, alongside the political-Zionist programme for the future, strive for the economic elevation of the Jews in the present upon a social-democratic basis. That the need for, and the possibility of, economic organisation upon a national-Jewish basis exists for Germany as well is proved by the existence of the Union of German Jews, the Association of Jewish Artisans, the organisation of the foreign Jews in Berlin (Jewish People's Association), etc. etc.

It would be the task of the organisation to protect common Jewish interests. Within the national organisation there must be sub-associations divided according to particular economic interests. The advantages would be, among others, the following: numerous Jewish forces, which are now absorbed by the national parties representing their economic interests — moreover insufficiently and badly — will be set free for us. Further, by taking in questions which are already at present of elementary importance to the individual, we shall have a far larger field for the propagation of our political programme for the future than now. Finally, we shall become a factor in the politics of the country, which will strengthen our standing abroad and our self-respect. (Applause.)

Hugo Schachtel, Breslau, complains that our leadership too has apparently forgotten the positive part of the resolutions of the last Congress. Nor, apparently, has any step yet been taken towards carrying out the resolution of the Brussels Conference tending in this direction. Meanwhile the situation has grown worse. Thus, for example, in Cyprus the best lands are meanwhile being bought up by an Anglo-Egyptian speculative company. (Jeremias calls out: "Aha, Cyprus!") Or does Cyprus perhaps not belong to the neighbouring lands? Less so than your Rhodesia? We need new institutions, because the old institutions are in part so barricaded that nothing can be done from them, not even much of what the "politicals in inverted commas" desire. — The present-day economic work which Dr. Mühsam desires was already resolved upon at the IVth Congress, but was not carried out. Had that been done, we should also have the democratic and social-democratic circles, whom Dr. Klee and his friends suddenly do not wish to have, although it is precisely they who otherwise canvass for "quantities" in agitation. The Social Democrats are, after all, human beings too. That these circles should suddenly be unwelcome among us contradicts the resolutions of various Congresses; such a "national-miserable" spirit should be banished from our ranks with all speed. (Lively applause.)

Finally the speaker asks the Central Bureau to exert itself, even more than hitherto, in the direction of having Zionist university men go to small towns — not, however, merely to take up seats on communal boards and town councils there, but to lead Zionist local groups. (Applause.)

Dr. Friedemann: The successes in Germany are not slight. The German organisation is only 5 years old; the National Fund receipts have risen every year by 20%. In spite of the differences of opinion in Germany, and in spite of the lack of a watchword such as there was in Austria, there are as many shekel-payers as in the previous year. The reproaches against the party leadership are unfounded. Immediately upon the news of the pogroms becoming known, the A. C. did everything to stimulate relief work.

The Brussels Conference has for the present produced only an exchange of views, but — had it not taken place, the very gentlemen who now find fault so much would have found fault with its not taking place. It is also possible that a positive result may yet come about after all.

The neighbouring lands could hardly be taken into consideration, because of the Turco-Egyptian Akaba dispute, because of the disputes on Cyprus and the like. For our work in Palestine the Marmorek-Ussischkin resolution must remain decisive: everything for the exploration of the country, everything for the furtherance of industry, but no furtherance of immigration and no planless, aimless and purposeless small colonisation.

Professor Dr. Warburg remarks that, as a delegate who is at the same time a member of the A. C., he wishes only to correct here the reproaches which have been levelled against the A. C. in the course of the discussion. As regards the Brussels Conference, the speaker announces that negotiations are still in progress, and that these are being conducted with particular diligence with regard to the countries of the Orient. For this purpose a committee has been set up in Berlin, consisting of delegates of all the larger relief organisations, and which is in a position to lend the negotiations greater weight. This committee, which has also turned its attention to the South American states and the Southern States of the Union, in order to divert the stream of emigration thither, has drawn up a statute in which it is said: The committee shall create new possibilities of colonisation, with special regard to the Orient. The committee will thus, in our sense, keep the Orient especially in view and seek in an entirely legitimate manner to make immigration there possible — that is, it will carry on no "smuggling." The speaker further touches upon the question raised concerning the neighbouring lands of Palestine. We must nowhere intervene as disturbers of interests. El Arish, he said, had for the moment receded into the background, which had been brought about by the negotiations between England and Turkey. Above all, the Zionists must exercise caution lest in the end they should serve as the scapegoat in political quarrels. Likewise the speaker remarks concerning Mesopotamia that here too negotiations of the Powers are pending. All these, he said, were long-range matters, whose end was uncertain and not to be foreseen with certainty. The speaker then refutes at length the reproach that the A. C. had resolved to colonise with National Fund moneys, a reproach which, he said, was absolutely baseless. If land had here and there been given out on lease, that was still no reason to suspect a danger to principle, and Zionism would certainly not thereby become a "colonisation company." (Lively applause.)

Second Session

(Opening: Monday, 4 o'clock in the afternoon.)

Estermann, Hamburg: The opposition of the "political" Zionists is directed chiefly against the attempts made on the part of the Zione-Zion to push the Actions Committee into the policy of the pre-Zionist Chowewe-Zionism. After the declaration of Prof. Warburg that the A.-C. will undertake nothing that could be regarded as a relapse into Chowewe-Zionism, we may be reassured. We naturally reserve to ourselves, however, the right to work for the repeal of the restrictive resolutions of the 7th Congress.

Simon, Mannheim, protests against the attempts to spread mistrust of the leadership ever further, and sketches briefly the method of work which is needed in Palestine and which does not cease to be political, even though it does not rely solely upon working on the Sultan merely by arguments, but upon strengthening our position of power in Palestine itself. In the further course of his remarks the speaker expresses his sympathy with the Palestine pioneers, whose devotion to our ideal compels his high admiration.

Theilhaber, Munich, refers to the practical work of strengthening our means and carrying on agitation. Thus he announces, with regard to the National Fund, that the Zionist student societies will make self-taxation obligatory for their members, namely 0.5% of their income (monthly). This course should, if possible, be followed by the Zionists. Agitation among the youth, the merchants, the girls cannot be accomplished through the local groups, but only through separate societies. He calls for the founding of such sub-groups everywhere.

Dr. Isaac Strauß, Heidelberg: The receipts of the year 1905 are shown to be 20% higher than those of the previous year, but in absolute terms the yearly contributions for the great aims are small, and, what is more important, they flow in irregularly, mostly as the outcome of charitable moods.

2*