10 — "Die Welt" — No. 10
(continued from page 9)
…ciple let be bound, which may eventually become an obstacle to the attainment of our national aims. It is no logical postulate that every monarchist must be an opponent of our equal rights and all the parties of the Left friends of the Jews." In reality we should find in the "Union of the 17th of October" men who are for the equal rights of the Jews, while on the other hand there are not a few antisemites in the liberal and progressive parties. We ought therefore to rely on no single party, but to support only those candidates who stand up for the rights of the Jews, without letting ourselves be misled by the fact that this or that candidate belongs to the "Union of the 17th of October," which stands to the right of the Russian Constitutional-Democratic party. When the whole Jewish people is united under our national flag, the means will also be found that will lead to the attainment of our full rights . . .
The speech of Achad-Haam, which, proceeding from the national standpoint, contained a ruthless vote of no confidence towards all the liberal parties of Russia, aroused, as has been said, lively opposition in the meeting, which, however, owing to the deep respect the speaker knows how to inspire in spite of everything, kept within the necessary bounds.
It must be admitted that, if Achad-Haam was logically right, it is nevertheless not in fact true that it is a matter of complete indifference to the Jews which party gains the majority in the Duma; and many delegates rightly replied that the members of the "Union of the 17th of October," which unites within itself so many reactionary and openly anti-Jewish elements, are not to be trusted. The Russian Government and all the reactionary parties allied with it have sufficiently shown how they behave towards the Jews — and what guarantees had the Jews that a member of such a party who is not avowedly hostile to the Jews will later, when the Jewish question comes up, turn against the antisemitic majority of his party?
To be sure — how the liberal and democratic parties of Russia will stand towards the Jewish question, which liberal and democratic elements will reach the Russian Duma at all, is a question not to be answered offhand. Those delegates were right who maintained that Jewry as such has received little proof that the Russian liberal parties are ready to stand up actively for it. Of proofs to the contrary there are enough.
The majority of the delegates also resolved not to attach themselves directly to any single one of the existing parties. The resolution adopted reads as follows:
"The Conference finds it necessary that during the electoral campaign one should unite only with such parties whose programme and activity correspond in all points to the programme of the 'Society for the Attainment of Equal Rights for the Jews,' and which, in respect of general policy, strive for a democratic organisation of Russia on the basis of universal, equal, direct and secret suffrage.
Note: "Should it prove impossible to carry a candidate in accordance with the wishes of the League, the members of the League shall vote for that delegate who belongs to a progressive party."
"Of the candidates one should demand:
A) Of Jewish candidates:
-
In their activity in the Duma they must abide by the resolutions and the programme of the League.
-
They must demand that the Jewish question be solved in the Duma together with the laying down of the foundations of the Constitution and of the general civil liberties.
B) Of non-Jewish candidates who are to be supported by Jewish votes, it must be demanded that they abide by Point II and support the Jewish demands for equal civil, political and national rights."
On one further point opinions clashed sharply, and it became apparent how many strata even of Russian Jewry still shrink timidly from the Jewish national idea. The question was that of the formation of a Jewish faction in the future Russian parliament. From the Zionist side the proposal was made, with which Dubnow also agreed, that the Jewish deputies in the Duma should form a separate faction bearing the Jewish name, that they should take all their decisions in common and act together in every case where the Jewish question is concerned.
The motives that speak for this, and that were put forward in St. Petersburg, we need not set out at length for Zionists. It would, however, be of interest to learn the counter-arguments — if they were new. Some delegates shrank, for assimilationist reasons, from the thought of pursuing an openly Jewish policy in the Russian Duma. The others, who had nothing against a Jewish faction in principle, maintained that the time for it had not yet come, since the Jews in Russia are themselves not clear what national rights they ought to demand. Opinions were also voiced that the Jewish delegates would be able to accomplish far more if they were distributed among various parties, because they would then be able to bring their influence to bear in all parties. Perhaps the Jews in Russia still have the right to be so naive!
In the end two resolutions stood opposed to each other:
The one (brought in by the Zionist-Dubnow group) reads:
"The Jewish deputies in the Duma form a separate faction, which calls itself Jewish, and act together in all questions of Jewish policy leading to Jewish equal rights. In general questions the Jews support those parties which in their programme also demand Jewish equal rights. If a delegate joins another party, he must stipulate for himself the freedom to vote independently on the Jewish question. The Jews may not join factions of other nationalities."
The second resolution (Ratner), which was adopted by a majority of 10 votes, ran as follows:
"The Conference declares it necessary that, in view of the firm consciousness of their national unity, the Jewish deputies must unite, without prejudice to their general party programmes. On all questions touching the rights of the Jewish people they must meet together to deliberate upon them and, where possible, to act together in order to attain national rights for the Jews of Russia. At the same time the Conference deems it well that Jewish deputies should not join non-Jewish national groups."
These were the most important points that the Conference had to settle. As for the practical value of all these resolutions, under present conditions it is in many respects a doubtful one. We have indeed seen how sceptical and irresolute the reports from the various districts of the Pale of Settlement sounded.
The decision itself, however, lies in the very nearest future, since the Duma is to meet as early as the spring.
