Die Welt · Vol. X, No. 3 · 19 January 1906
7printed page
scan 5 of 24
Facsimile · scan 5 of 24
Scan of p. 7
English · AI translation, checked against the German

No. 3 — "Die Welt" — 7

(continued from page 6)

…activity too small, so that in the course of time it fell apart again. Now the times set greater tasks before us, whose solution lies not within the power of single individuals, nor of single societies and federations, but for which the gathering of all the forces of the whole of Jewry is required. All these scattered forces, working apart from one another, must now unite to form a general Jewish federation, and this federation must make the solution of the Jewish Question its programme. More than ever must the Jewish people in its entirety now recognise the deep truth of the saying of its ancient sage: If I am not for myself, who then is for me — and if not now, when then?


TERRITORIALISM AND ZIONISM

BY DR. M. GASTER

I have the honour to lay before you the following resolution: "This mass meeting of Zionists expresses its regret at the recent manifesto of prominent members of the London Jewish community, declares its unalterable conviction that the only solution of the Jewish Question is the restoration of the Jews to Palestine, and urges upon the members of the Actions Committee that they initiate active Zionist work." These are the words of the resolution which I wish to comment upon and to support. Since my last speech, which I delivered here before my journey to the Basle Congress, many things have happened — unspeakable, terrible, shattering things. A black cloud has settled upon our people; the cries of the death-agony have echoed through the world. The darkness was lit by the flames of burning houses and of burning men, and we stand to-day mourning at the graves of thousands of our innocent brothers and sisters who were so cruelly driven to their deaths. Our Zionist life, too, has passed through some strange transformations. I prefer not to return to the last Basle Congress, because it is painful to me to recall the scenes which took place there. Were it not for the first part of the resolution, had not things occurred there which gave some people a strange notion of Zionism, had not some results of that assembly contributed to the weakening and not to the strengthening of our Jewish consciousness, — I would have passed over these events in silence; I would have drawn a curtain. Nor would I return to the attempt which some made at the Congress to seize the mantle of Herzl for themselves, until they had torn it to tatters — were not the impression thereby produced so bad that certain people, who confuse Zionism with the Zionists and identify small personalities of a passing nature with the great enduring idea, came to the conclusion that Zionism lay dying. And when they approach the great problem of what is to be done with our unhappy people, they now speak of Zionism as one speaks of the dead and departed, after the fine principle: "De mortuis nil nisi bene"; their criticism, however, they reserve for Territorialism. But I hope to-day to be able to prove to you that Zionism lives and is conscious of its strength. I am of the opinion that those who would pronounce Zionism blessed among the departed have grievously miscalculated; Zionism is not dead, nor will it die, but Territorialism does not live — it is a still-born child. After the wise heads of the Jewish community of London had launched their attacks upon us, what is it that they have now devised? It was a cry of despair which they contrived to utter, nay, more, it was a wail of despair, a public confession of their total impotence, an exposure of their nakedness before the whole world, for they had to confess in all the newspapers that they "do not know what is to be done." That is the last word of their practical wisdom. The only remedy they propose is that of the English policeman": "Move on, please," and the second time, more sternly now: "Move on" (now without the "please"), "you are blocking the way." It would have been wiser had they kept this panacea for all the ills of Judaism as their deepest secret. But it is still more deeply to be regretted that they should have chosen precisely this critical moment in our history to show how little they have grasped the Jewish problem, sowing discord at a moment when concord is needed. We have long known that they are powerless, and because we knew it we set Zionism in motion and gave them the answer. But they would not listen to our answer. It is hard for me to accuse my own people, but I am certain that history will say: Had these very men, who now rise up, wring their hands in despair and ask, "What is to be done with the unfortunates of Russia?", joined our ranks, there would have been no Kishineff, Odessa would never have come to pass, and millions of human beings would not have had to live in indescribable terror. It is no excuse to say, "Who could have foreseen it, who could have foretold it?" Those who speak thus are like the oyster that buries its head in the sand and believes itself safe when it does not see its pursuers. They bury themselves behind their fire-proof safes and their ledgers, and will not see the signs of the times nor hear the storm-signals. Had they laid weight not upon their strong-boxes and their money but upon their conscience and feeling, upon their solidarity and Jewish sentiment, we should not have had to stand here to-night to weep for our dead; we should have risen up years ago to protect our people and to prepare for it a great and glorious home. Whoever reads history, whoever has eyes to see, can see it if he will. It is not my habit to quote myself or my writings, but I cannot refrain from referring to an article which I published in the "North-American Review" some years ago. I recapitulated the history of Jewish life in the nineteenth century and said that the twentieth century would open under the sign of reaction, of persecution and of bloodshed; that the spectres of the Middle Ages would rise again; that we were passing from being protected to being persecuted, and further still to the martyr's stake. But people said I was a pessimist and was exaggerating. I wish it had been so, and that events had given me the lie. But at the same time I traced out the path of deliverance. When the night is darkest, a streak of light begins to brighten the world. Into this darkness there fell a ray of hope, — Zionism. The gentlemen who signed the manifesto*) had seen neither the one nor the other, and now, overtaken by events, they accuse us instead of working with us. We proposed to work hand in hand with all the party tendencies within Judaism, but they thrust back the hand that was offered, and first of all they say: What are we to do? I have told them what they should do first: Go and weep over your short-sightedness, over your former folly, and then come and help us! What use is it to ask the world, what are we to do? The echo answers: Do! Act, and do not weep! United we can move mountains and put a stop to persecution; with the money that has been spent in Russia we can prepare a secure future for our people; we can demand, in the name of justice, of humanity, of the great blessings which we have brought to the nations, that they avenge our blood and rise up to protect our people. Then our turn will come to act. Protesting is of no avail now. We have not come together to-day merely to protest; we wish to work and to arrive at practical resolutions. We know what we ought to do, and therefore we have come here,

Note. Speech delivered at a mass meeting in Leeds convened by the "Agudath Hazionim Association" of that city.

*) The reference is to the manifesto which Rothschild, Claude Montefiore and other gentlemen published against Zionism and Territorialism. Editor's note.