Die Welt · Vol. IX, Separate Edition 2 · 29 July 1905
11printed page
scan 11 of 20
Facsimile · scan 11 of 20
Scan of p. 11
English · AI translation, checked against the German

No. 2, Special Edition — "Die ✡ Welt" — Page 11.

(continued from page 10)

…confess that this was a mistake, and that the full value of the British Government's offer was thereby lost; and I went so far as to suggest to Dr. Herzl that, if he did not believe himself able to accept the original offer, he had better let it drop for the moment, in order to approach the Government later, when he should have gained the strength for it and organised public opinion to that end. But for various reasons Dr. Herzl was unable to follow my advice, and accordingly I approached the British Government in the sense he desired.

The result was that on the 25th of January of last year the Government, after deliberating on some modifications, formally offered us the 5000 square miles on the Guas Ngischu Plateau. This proposal was laid before the Actions Committee at the beginning of last year, and it was resolved to send out a commission to examine this territory. But still we lacked the means for the commission, since only a small sum of about £160 had been collected.

The matter was in this unsatisfactory state when our unforgettable Herzl was taken from us. Some weeks before his death he had written me a letter with instructions in which he said: "You, my friends, can now make a trial for the event of my death and carry on the business for the time being without me." — In the forefront of these instructions stood the sending of the commission to East Africa, and that which evidently seemed to him of the first importance was impracticable. The Jewish people — consider this — needed a little money. One could easily see why Dr. Herzl attached such value to the commission.

Had he not been able to do it, our movement would have become the laughing-stock of the world. We might indeed justly have been called "visionaries," since the Congress had taken a resolution of such importance and our people would support that resolution with nothing but applause in answer to opposition. Jewry was in an evil plight. Herzl dead, and the East Africa project, which at one stroke had stamped the status of our movement in the eyes of the world as a practical undertaking, provoking the scorn of our opponents and the pity of those well disposed to us on account of our impotence. "This people," it would have been said, "which wished to undertake to win Palestine, had also resolved to send a commission to East Africa. It had shown itself incapable of carrying out this latter resolution; what prospect had it as regards the former?" And the world, which did not reckon with party differences, which took no account of small differences of opinion, would have seen only a total collapse at the first practical work that came to us. —

Well then. He who watches over Israel slumbers not, nor sleeps, and deliverance came from a wholly unexpected quarter. A Christian who was sympathetically disposed towards our movement asked me, in the course of a conversation, when the commission would go to East Africa.

"When we have the money," I replied. And after inquiring the amount, he spoke of other things. By the next morning's post I received a letter from this friend in which he offered to contribute the whole sum required for the commission — some £1600; and our good friend Mr. Moser in Bradford placed a gift of £200 at my disposal. With these contributions and the small sum previously subscribed we were in a position to appoint the commission, which consisted of Major Gibbons, a distinguished English explorer, Mr. Kaiser of Arbon and Mr. Wilbusch, engineer.

The commission set out from Basle on the 25th of December of last year, travelled direct to Mombassa and then at once by railway to the station lying nearest the territory. It enjoyed every possible assistance on the part of the British authorities and stayed somewhat over 6 weeks in the territory. Major Gibbons has apparently seen the greater part of the territory, but the examination may be regarded as of a highly provisional character. The commission returned to Europe at the beginning of April, and the report was published some weeks afterwards, still in good time for the session of the Actions Committee in Vienna.

The report consists of 4 parts and can be bought from the Jewish Colonial Trust. Three parts consist of the individual reports of the three members of the expedition, and the fourth is a commentary by Major Gibbons, the leader of the commission, on the reports of his colleagues.

As his result Major Gibbons reports that the territory is very favourably situated as regards climate and sanitary conditions, but that its agricultural prospects are not so considerable as the British Government had evidently supposed when it made its offer. Nevertheless he is of opinion that a small colonisation of some thousands of persons is practicable, and that the territory, apart from a small part, is a country suited to cattle-raising and not to agriculture.

Kaiser reported in general that the territory is of no value for a Jewish settlement, and his opinion of the prospects of the region is pessimistic so far as Jews are concerned. Wilbusch's report on the territory is wholly unfavourable from every point of view; he held it to be worthless in every respect except for the natives and wild beasts. Gibbons criticised this report very sharply and declared Wilbusch's conclusions to be quite inadmissible.

It is impossible in a report such as this to reproduce in full the details of a voluminous report, and it may fairly be expected that everyone who gives his vote on this momentous matter has himself become acquainted with the contents of the reports of the members of the expedition, which were published in the "Welt" and elsewhere. Let it suffice to state here that when the report was deliberated upon by the Actions Committee, which met in April of this year, it was the unanimous resolution of the Actions Committee regarding the report to recommend to the Congress not to concern itself any further with this question, but to inquire of other bodies interested in Jewish affairs whether they for their part were willing to take up this East Africa proposal.

Of these outside bodies only one, the Anglo-Jewish Association in London, gave its consent to take part in a conference that might be called together, so that this plan too was abandoned. In conclusion I take the liberty of reading to the Congress an extract from a letter which Dr. Herzl to Sir Francis Montefiore in December