Die Welt · Vol. IX, No. 46 · 17 November 1905
10printed page
scan 10 of 20
Facsimile · scan 10 of 20
Scan of p. 10
English · AI translation, checked against the German

Page 10 — "Die ✡ Welt" — No. 46

(continued from page 9)

...lation corresponds." As Count Witte explained to the New York bankers, the Russian Government justifies its course of action on the ground that Russian society is not yet prepared to bestow equal rights upon the Jews, and that only by way of gradual measures can an improvement be effected in the grievous economic and legal position of the Jews. And in truth, Jewish equality of rights appears undesirable not only to those elements which support the old bureaucratic régime, but also to a great part of the radical Russian elements. This fact is admitted even by some candid representatives of the Jewish radical party.

It is precisely this circumstance that moves many of them not to push the Jewish question by itself into the foreground, lest they discredit their allies. One may easily see, however, that just now, while the Russian radical elements still stand so greatly in need of the help of the Jews, the moment ought not to be let slip for obtaining what might later be refused, or what would demand a desperate and bloody struggle, once the programme announced in the Manifesto of 17th/30th October has been carried out and the radical groups of Russian society no longer require the help of the Jews. Meanwhile, however, broad strata of the Russian population, who see in the Jews the chief culprits of the present troubles, are, supported by agents of the ruling power, organising veritable slaughters of the Jews, combined with open robbery of Jewish property, amid the complete indifference of the authorities.

Justice requires us, however, to confess that the responsibility for this bloodshed falls also upon the extreme Jewish party, whose call for the destruction of everything existing and for the establishment of a Social Democratic republic in place of the present order fills even the best part of Russian society with indignation. How many Jewish kingdoms might be built up, if the Jewish people would shed as much blood for its national freedom as it has already shed for the freedom of others! We had occasion to attend a meeting of an artisans' association which stands at the head of the movement of liberation; the telegrams were just then being read out announcing the slaughter of the Jews in various places, yet among all the radicals there was not a single one to be found who would have raised the voice of indignation and protest against these atrocities in the name of those assembled.

From the specifically Zionist standpoint the Manifesto of 17th/30th October must be welcomed, since it gives the Zionists the right to hold meetings and to organise unions and grants them freedom of speech, so that they may carry on a broadly planned agitation in favour of the Jewish movement of national liberation. A few years will pass, and the Russian Jews will be convinced that the long-desired reconstruction of Russia has not given them, and could not give them, that which every people can attain only upon its own territory. The future will show whether the Russian Constitution will give the answer to the Jewish national question, and whether the formula of the cultural-national self-determination of the Jewish people will be recognised and carried into practice. There can scarcely be any doubt, however, that the Zionists too will obtain full freedom of action to develop the propaganda necessary for the creation of a united Jewish will and for the union of all the scattered parts under one national banner. The latest events in Russia have shown anew what a people is able to achieve through a unanimous will and with firmly united forces. And the salvation of our people lies in the unity of a will directed to the attainment of a definite goal.


The Concert of the Powers.

The news that comes unceasingly from Russia, the greatest European reservoir, outdoes itself in horror. One must go back to the descriptions of the most terrible ages of barbarism, to the times of the darkest Middle Ages, and to the ancient history of the so-called uncivilised peoples, if one would find anything like what is now taking place in Russia. Whoever has ever turned the pages of those volumes of Graetz's History of the Jews which tell of the fanatical outbursts of hatred against the Jews in Spain or Germany, at the time when it was darkest, will hardly, or only with difficulty, read of like scenes. And while all this is being enacted upon one of the greatest members of the European body politic, the history of the world is nevertheless not so cruel as not to bring a joyful event as well: we mean the untroubled harmony of the Concert of the Powers.

Concert of the Powers — that is the right word for this phenomenon. Concert, peace, harmony, accord! Is there perhaps a corner of the so-called civilised world where this concert might be disturbed, a player who disturbs the harmony of ideas, or does a sound ring out from any corner of the orchestra that brings a shrill discord into this idyllic performance? The shaping of most recent times has brought it about that the conductors of this concert change. Now England, now Germany, now America, which has lately joined, and so on and so forth. All of them knew how to wield the baton with equal skill, and one might believe that it was really one school of orchestra that had trained them for the same system. And the score always bears the same direction: No interference in the affairs of a foreign State — that is to say, nota bene, when it does not suit us. For there is a peculiar circumstance about these internal affairs. If it is a question of the Armenians, then evidently they are not internal affairs; if it is a question of the Jews, then they are internal affairs. The question of the Kutzo-Vlachs is no internal affair of the State concerned; even the manner in which the Spaniards conducted themselves in their own territory in Cuba and in the Philippines seems — believe it or not — not to have been an internal affair, for America interfered. But the massacres of Jews, which have been repeated at an ever quickening pace in Russia for thirty or forty years, are strictly internal affairs of that Empire. Crete, Macedonia, the corns of any foreign, Christian subjects of Turkey are no internal affair. Jewish children, women and old men are strictly internal affairs. Whoever will not understand this logic does not know the system of the prevailing culture at all. Even the simplest definitions of the law of this culture