Die Welt · Vol. IX, No. 46 · 17 November 1905
9printed page
scan 9 of 20
Facsimile · scan 9 of 20
Scan of p. 9
English · AI translation, checked against the German

No. 46 — "Die Welt" — Page 9

(continued from page 8)

...and as though a new social and political life would at once arise upon its ruins. But the old will not make way at a single stroke for a young order of things. Relying on the fact that not one of the laws hitherto in force has been directly repealed by the Manifesto, the Russian ancien régime declares that even after the publication of the Act of 17th/30th October all former laws have remained in force and must be applied until their express repeal under the new legal constitution. ("Government Messenger" of 20/X., 2/XI., No. 224.) It must be admitted that this view is quite correct. In this way Russian society has in fact received nothing as yet. For the present it has merely been enriched by the bare promise that it would be granted the unshakable foundations of political freedom and of a civil order of law, a promise, however, pronounced in a firm, clear and categorical form, which inspires fresh hopes of a speedy introduction of the fundamental elements of a legal order into Russian reality. The radical parties, the general Russian as well as the Jewish, take a different attitude towards this document. In their manifestoes they warn society against a new trap laid by the autocratic Government, which they accuse of failing to carry out a whole series of promises, as well as of unwillingness to do anything whatever that might bear witness to its good will to break with the old régime. The sharp form of the criticism and the extreme demands put forward, which ignore the evolutionary process of improvement in the forms of social and political life and hold back the emergence of the population from its state of revolutionary ferment, were bound to bring in their train a splintering of Russian society, which of late had acted with an astonishing unanimity. Instead of concentrating their forces in order to demand of the Government the carrying out of all the reforms within the framework of the Manifesto of 17th/30th October, the extreme parties introduce elements which hinder society from concentrating its forces upon positive, creative work. Manifestoes of this kind, especially when they proceed from the extreme Jewish groups, call forth bitterness and indignation among the moderate elements and even among the representatives of the radical bourgeoisie. When the moderate elements break off their alliance with the extreme parties, the latter will lose a considerable part of their influence and will scarcely be in a position to play an important political part. It would be a mistake to think that they are dangerous to the Government and that the concessions were made thanks to the demands of the extreme parties — the Social Revolutionaries and the Social Democrats. With these parties the Government has fought, and not without success. But when the demand for political freedom had become the watchword of the moderate elements and of the radical bourgeoisie as well, the Government lost its chief point of support and was obliged to capitulate.

The Manifesto of 17th/30th October naturally extends to the Jews also, and the latter, as citizens of Russia, have together with the others made a valuable political acquisition. But when one considers that the Jews in Russia live under the pressure of two atmospheres — the general and the specifically Jewish want of rights — one cannot but record with a feeling of deep disappointment the fact that in our magna charta libertatum every reference to a concession of equality before the law for all without distinction of religion and nationality is entirely absent. It is true that in the most humble report of Count Witte, which received the All-Highest endorsement "To be noted," mention is also made of the necessity "of working out the questions relating to the equality before the law of all without distinction of confession or nationality." But if it is asserted of the Manifesto that it has granted rights merely on paper, without converting them into laws, and that all former laws have remained in full force and operation, then it is surely impossible to deny that the above-mentioned remark in Witte's report has binding significance for no one, that the Jews have been passed over altogether in the Manifesto, and that in this solemn act neither equality nor any improvement whatever in their legal position has been promised them. And yet Russian Jewry has made countless sacrifices to change the general conditions of political life in Russia. Western and Southern Russia are drenched with the blood of the best sons of our people, who, in the belief that the situation and the destiny of the Jewish people are inseparable from the political reconstruction of Russia, expected a radical solution of the Jewish question from a change in the general conditions of Russia's political life. In their hatred of the present Government and in their blindness these elements resist every attempt to strive even now, as individual Russian classes of society are doing, even now for individual alleviations for individual groups of the Jewish population, before ever the Imperial Duma is convened, which — God knows when — will concern itself with the Jewish question and give God knows what answer to that question. The same elements prevent resolutions from being debated and adopted at meetings and in the various unions which demand an improvement in the position of this or that class of the Jewish population.

While the Poles approach every general question from the standpoint of their national interests and play only a feeble part in the all-Russian movement of liberation, take no active share whatever in it, and husband their strength and their lives for their national cause, striving to turn every phenomenon, every circumstance and moment to account in order to give prominence to their national existence and their national interests, the Jews take the most lively part in the general movement of liberation, endeavour to thrust the Jewish question into the background, forget their national interests, and concern themselves only with contributing as powerfully as possible to the realisation of the general principles of the movement of liberation.

Such tactics and such a policy have as their consequence that the Government, in view of the absence of any persistent demand on the part of society for an immediate improvement in the position of the Jews, has not fulfilled even those points of the law of 12th December 1904 by which it was intended to improve the position of the Jews in so far as it "to the interests of the Empire and to the welfare of the Popu-