Page 14. — "Die Welt" — No. 43.
(continued from page 13)
…to try his serum in the clinics, that he is slandered behind his back, that men dare to condemn his serum without knowing it.
In our day there shall be no Semmelweis. That we do not permit. A man of science, a man who has given his proofs, shall not be suffered to be haughtily ignored by the mandarins of medicine when he comes forward and declares: "My serum cures tuberculosis!" Against such treatment we now have the flight into publicity.
Half of all mankind dies of tuberculosis; 3,500 physicians assemble for a solemn World Congress and proclaim that every treatment of this most murderous of all diseases has suffered shipwreck, and that to the patient who begs for a cure, or at least for relief, one can only say: "We will sterilise your sputum, so that you do not infect others; we will widen the streets, so that the healthy may have better dwellings." The hundreds of communications to the Congress are for by far the greatest part learned trifles, self-important laboratory toyings of so pitiful a barrenness and so dreary a poverty of thought that one is appalled at this waste of time, labour and technical skill, at this senile formalism of a withered, empty pseudo-science. In the midst of this pompous but hollow, I should almost say absent-minded, bustle there appears a learned investigator and says: "Here is a specific serum against tuberculosis!" Twelve physicians, most of them of position and repute, step forward after him and confirm: "We have tried the serum, and it has proved itself!" And this savant is not the centre of the Congress, this discoverer is not the triumphant hero of the gathering? On the contrary, men seek to prevent him from speaking and, since he has spoken nevertheless, to stifle his word within one session-hall? That is so monstrous a thing that it must be recorded for the history of morals.
What Marmorek's serum is worth, that the physicians of both worlds shall examine. There is absolutely no excuse for not trying it. For that it is entirely harmless has thus far been proved by 12,000 injections into several hundred healthy and sick persons and into several thousand animals; and since it does harm in no case, it is the duty of the physician to try it in a disease absolutely incurable by any known remedy, even if it yielded not, as Professor Dubard-Dijon and Primary Physician Levin-Stockholm stated, 55 and 52 per cent of cures, but only ten, but only a single success in a hundred cases. For even a single cure is still better than none at all.
One of the speakers at the Friday session, the Paris general practitioner Dr. J. F. Soulier, spoke grave words: "Take care!" he cried to the professors at the presidential table, with the fine indignation of a noble man revolted by underhand tricks, "if you continue to treat the Marmorek serum as non-existent, the mothers of the people will imperiously demand of you that you treat their sick kinsfolk with it, just as they forced the anti-diphtheritic serum upon you when at first you were inclined to neglect it."
Dr. Soulier is right. I am truly no medical demagogue. Nothing is further from me than to stir up the sick against my professional colleagues. But when the conceit of mandarins or mental sloth, envy or malice, when the blackest and basest of human instincts conspire against a discovery that may perhaps save a million human lives every year, then it is a duty to break through the professional clique, to turn to the widest circles, to throw the glaring light of publicity into the rotten corners of the business of medical science, and to cry out to the sick: "There is a curative serum for tuberculosis. It has already proved itself many times. It is harmless. A physician has not the right to withhold this remedy from you. For he has nothing that can replace it, and in the present state of science it is your only hope of cure."
It seems to me that the physicians would do better not to let it come to their being addressed thus by their patients.
Paris, 8th October. Max Nordau.
Letter-Box.
Oesterreicher S., Szatmar. Translation unrestricted. An. na. Depends on the contents. Hasmonaea. Must be paid out within one year. Beginning immaterial. W. Heller. The matter is very sad. With regard to your request, please consult our advertisement section. S. Haber. When opportunity offers. Dr. Scherlag. Kindly sketch the contents in a few words. H. Sch., Breslau. Many thanks. Blindness. E. Spiegel. How can we possibly take upon ourselves so great a responsibility? That you must settle with yourself. Gwozdziec. Despite great pains, it was impossible for us to learn anything pertinent. Perhaps you might apply, with a curriculum vitae, to the Baron Hirsch Foundation. M. S., Gaya. Already noted. Shortly. Thanks. Dr. E. M., Teplitz. Many thanks. Proposal passed on. Full minutes to appear soon. Small edition not necessary. According to information they are resolutions, not suggestions. S. Gottfried. Declined with thanks. J. H. C. K. No. W. editor at the "Weg." S. G., Jaffa. Please apply to the Berlitz School in Agram. Rat bor. Paris 7, Rue de Chevalier Honoré.
DONATIONS
for the National Fund:
| Donor | Amount |
|---|---|
| Hugo David, Vienna. A. H. "Maccabäa..... | 3.— |
| A, H. J. "Maccabäa, Vienna | 1.— |
| National Fund Commission, Przemysl: Kaaroth, Erev Yom Kippur 5666, through Lauterbach and Tag in the Main Synagogue K. 13.44, Reiff, Wahl. Liebenheimer in the Zasanie Synagogue 11.20, Tuchmann, Friesel sen., at Scheinbach's 10.30, Laub sen., Schlaf in the small Beth-Hamidrash 6.70, Walker, Laub jun. in the great Beth-Hamidrash 6.40, Brüll, Aug in the society "Jad-Charuzim" 3.60, M. Gottlieb, Manz in the society "Tikwat-Israel" 1.14, Schlecter at Bernstein's 3.—, Knöpf, Gottfried in the Wygoda prayer-house 3.—, Bloch, Herschdörfer at Blech's 2.70, Fried, Friesel jun. in the Merchants' prayer-house 4.—, Schenker, Ickiewicz in the society "Halwuas Chein" 2.54, Kaudel, Berger in the "Talmud Tora" 3.10, Nagel, Körner at Nagel's 2.—, Rothenberg, J. Gottlieb at Hirt's 2.10, Ch. M. —.10, Tuchmann, Spandorf at —.20 each, Reiff Lauterbach Knöpf at —.10 each, Blatt —.44, "Poale Zion" 15.— אקאדמית, "Hadassa" 30.— במעשמיאל, "Agudath Herzl" 31.46 אגודת הרצל חברה | 76.46 |
| Leo Schickler, Czernowitz | 1.— |
| Collection by Arnold Horn and M Frost at the house of M. Feldman, Leipzig: M. Feldman, Schwanenteld, Lipper at Mk. 1.— each, M. Dornfest, S. Dornfest, Berger, J. Schipher Friedmann and A. Hübler at —.50 each | 6.69 |
| M. Fleischner, Vienna | 1.20 |
| Vienna: Anonymous K. 1.60, Platschek —.20. Founders of the "Unitas" | 1.80 |
