No. 43. — "Die Welt" — Page 13.
(continued from page 12)
…results announced, but at the same time expressly forbade him to make public use of their communications. A celebrated German professor, whom I will not name because he died recently and could not answer my accusation, wrote Marmorek an enthusiastic letter about the cure of a desperate case, and at the same time published in a respected medical journal a report in which the very same case was represented as a failure of the serum treatment! Parisian physicians crept to Marmorek at dusk and begged for serum, but glanced anxiously about them at the house door lest they be noticed. In the "Figaro" there appeared an article which gave it to be understood, in veiled terms, that anyone who distributed a secret remedy not sanctioned by the authorities, even free of charge, laid himself open to criminal prosecution. Amid this unchaining of every cowardice and every baseness that dishonour the human soul, Marmorek remained calm and upright. He did not answer, he entered into no polemic, he went quietly on with his work and contented himself with giving the serum to everyone who asked for it.
Of the eminent clinicians, not one asked for it. It was lesser men who first broke the ban laid upon Marmorek. The beginning was made by four Parisian private physicians with a communication to the "Société de Thérapeutique" on two cases in which they had jointly used the serum with success. There followed an Englishman with a favourable report in the "Lancet." Others, encouraged by these proceedings, ventured forward with their experiences. The "Progrès Médical," the "Münchener Medizinische Wochenschrift," the "Berliner Klinische Wochenschrift," the "Deutsche Medizinische Wochenschrift," the "British Medical Journal" raised their voices one after another. The literature on the serum has grown to this day to 18 publications. The World Congress on Tuberculosis came. Before it the case of the anti-tuberculosis serum was to be carried further.
Marmorek was one of the first to enrol as members and to give notice of a communication. I have seen his membership card. It bears the number 27. The communications were to receive their places on the order of the day in the sequence in which they had been announced. When this was made known a week ago, we saw to our astonishment that Marmorek's communication had been given the 144th place: the Section for Therapeutics, before which Marmorek was to speak, held in all six working sessions of 2½ to 3 hours each. That gave at most 16 working hours. It was quite out of the question that the 144th, or even the 100th, communication would be reached. Marmorek disdained to point out that a breach of right had been committed against him when he, the 27th to enrol, was banished to the 144th place; but at the first session he demanded with emphasis that a sub-section be branched off, in which the high numbers might be given the floor. The chairman of the section was disposed to make difficulties; the resolute attitude of the members of the Congress, however, compelled him to give way.
The sub-section was set up, and on Friday afternoon Marmorek was to be heard in it. The appointed hour arrived, and the chairman surprised the meeting with the announcement that the order of the day had been altered and the session given over to the discussion of the therapy of lupus. Thereupon arose a storm such as a scientific congress has scarcely ever seen. Two hundred physicians thundered at the chairman until he wholly lost his composure. The section insisted on hearing Marmorek. The chairman tried to parley. It availed him nothing. His intrigues and those of the men behind him were foiled. Seven men who had come forward for lupus withdrew pitifully, and the section was at last able to occupy itself with the anti-tuberculosis serum.
Marmorek spoke for only a few minutes, concisely, matter-of-factly, modestly, as always. He contented himself with communicating the results of the treatment in the some 350 cases that had come to his knowledge. After him, however, twelve physicians from seven countries, among them professors, hospital physicians and directors of sanatoria, took the floor, recounted their cures bordering on the miraculous, and all closed with veritable outbursts of enthusiasm, with hymns to Marmorek and his serum.
The battle was won. But the victory was to remain confined to the four walls of the sub-section. So it was willed by the same people who had tried to silence Marmorek at the Congress. The daily report issued by the secretariat of the Congress made not so much as a single word of mention either of the session of the sub-section or of the communications of Marmorek and the twelve physicians who had spoken of their experience with his serum; and so it came about that the entire Paris press, with the exception of three newspapers, simply passed the occurrence over in silence. To be sure, this last stroke too has miscarried, for there are some of us who were resolved to denounce the conspiracy of silence to the great public.
The resistance to Marmorek's discovery is in itself understandable. Physicians and patients have not yet got over the terrible experience of Koch's tuberculin. After the ignominious failure of that supposed remedy, which the whole civilised world had greeted with the highest expectations, distrust of every new serum is justified. The aversion to experiments in this direction has been kept lively by the swindlers and quacks who at short intervals come forward with supposedly unknown methods of cure, promise mountains of gold, and soon sink into well-deserved oblivion. One thing more is to be added. In sanatoria, that last resource of therapeutic despair, several hundred millions of marks are invested in Germany alone, and over a milliard in the whole world. To this milliard, its administration and the running of the institutions, the personal interests of tens of thousands are attached. Although these will not have it so, it was nevertheless judged at the Congress by impartial judges that the real curative results of the sanatoria are equal to nil, and that at most they come into consideration as holiday colonies for the working population and possess a social-political significance. It is to be expected that those interested in the sanatoria will oppose the most determined resistance to every discovery that would at once render them superfluous. That is not ideally moral, but it is human.
One may not complain if Marmorek's discovery was at first received with the strongest doubt. That he was bound to expect. It is necessary, it is useful, that it be subjected to the most exacting, for my part even the most hostile, examination. What cannot be tolerated, however, is that men seek to kill him and his work by silence, that they refuse,
