Page 6 — "Die Welt" — No. 38
(continued from page 5)
…not sine die — to adjourn it, that it must be quite permissible to continue this meeting; surely no new meeting is needed in such a case; this meeting will be continued on the day fixed, and I maintain that, in these unfortunate circumstances in which we find ourselves, having no lawfully appointed proxies of the Founders' Shares, you would do best to adjourn the debate upon these resolutions to a fixed day, so that the meeting is not dissolved but is continued on the day fixed by this meeting. I believe that this is the only right course which we can take, since in the prevailing circumstances we should not be acting honourably were we now to decide the matter finally.
The Chairman: I do not wish the meeting to gain, even for a moment, a false impression regarding the exact legal opinion of our counsel, Mr. Armitstead, and of our solicitors. These gentlemen have informed us that, according to Section 51 of the Companies Act of 1862, what I have already told you a little while ago, namely, that if this meeting is adjourned the whole matter would have to be begun over again. I am no lawyer; I know nothing about it. We can of course make it interesting and spend the Trust's money in fighting out this question. It seems to me that that would be one way out of this difficulty; but I hope that it will not happen. Now one of two things is possible: either to adjourn — if Mr. Bentwich moves the adjournment, he must take the full responsibility for it, after all that I have already told him.
Mr. Bentwich: I should like to have read the Section and the opinion of Counsel.
The Chairman: I have not the opinion of Counsel here, but I have told you of it.
Mr. J. Moser: May I ask something regarding the mishap which has occurred? I should like to get an exact view of the matter. I do not wish to dispute about legal points. Mr. Chairman, we do not have present the representative of the Founders' Shareholders whom we expected here in good time; I maintain that if Mr. Temkin had been able to be present here, this whole discussion would not have taken place. He has fallen ill and has therefore remained on the way. I think it is only a lawful demand if one asks that the difficulties of the present situation be overcome by bringing to the spot the legally binding representatives of the Founders' Shareholders. That is my proposal; and that, in my opinion, is something which could be done and should be done, and could also be carried out by this meeting. If this meeting does not do it, that is another question; but it could be done, and that is just the point.
The Chairman: I have informed you that the best advice, the advice of our lawyers, is to the effect that we cannot adjourn. We have no magic carpets with which we could suddenly convey Dr. Kokesch hither, or anyone else in the place of Dr. Temkin, who has suddenly fallen ill. All that was to be done has been done. We telegraphed to Dr. Marmorek. We telegraphed to Mr. Moser, so that he should know of it in his capacity as a member of the Council of Administration and could come here when he pleased. Besides, here is Section No. 51.
Mr. Bentwich: Will you kindly communicate to us the opinion of Counsel.
The Chairman: I have no written opinion of Counsel here; we had an oral expression of opinion.
Mr. Bentwich: As I understand, you had an expression of opinion from Counsel.
The Chairman: Yes, but not a written one.
The Secretary reads Section 51 of the Companies Act 1862.
Mr. Bentwich: This brings us entirely to the point which I proposed to you, which I mentioned regarding the one month which the law prescribes as the time-limit within which confirmation must take place. Has this period expired to-day?
The Chairman: Yes, to-day.
Mr. Bentwich: That is a great pity. This is of course a new fact. Were the resolutions first passed on the 31st of July?
The Secretary: I explained the matter to you just now. We had to reckon with the difficulty that the notice of all General Meetings must be published fourteen days before the day on which they are held; in this case we had to arrange matters so that the advertisements of the notice appeared in good time in newspapers which come out only weekly, fortnightly or monthly. For this reason we were compelled to choose the last possible day, the 31st of August; and as regards the opinion of Counsel, I venture to remark that the relevant statements had already been sent to the Small Actions Committee in Vienna before the first meeting was held. We have no written opinions here; but there is a written opinion in existence which confirms the facts stated here, to the effect that the meeting must take place on the 31st of August and not later, but that the proceedings, should the resolutions not be confirmed, would become void.
(Interruption.)
Mr. Bentwich: I venture to point out to you that, through the convening of this meeting for the last possible day on which the confirmation of the resolutions could take place, the following evils have arisen: we have present here neither the Chairman, nor the Vice-Chairman, nor any representative of the Founders' Shareholders; we are therefore in the greatest embarrassment, and it is therefore incumbent upon you as Chairman to reckon with these difficulties, so that the proceedings at the Basle Congress may not remain without result. I believe that, if we are compelled to come to a decision to-day, you ought to take the necessary steps to ascertain how the Founders' Shareholders would have voted, and that we should do what is needful so that the votes of the Founders' Shareholders are accepted and recorded.
Mr. B. Grad: Do you wish us to understand that you have obtained the opinion of Counsel on the particular question whether the meeting could be begun to-day and adjourned?
Mr. J. Moser: That is the point.
Mr. B. Grad: I think that you did not ask Counsel about it at all.
The Chairman: We did ask.
The Secretary: Gentlemen, may I explain to you once more that this question was laid not only before Mr. Lewis but also before Mr. Armitstead, the Counsel of the Company (who is doubtless well known to Mr. Bentwich, since he has been its Counsel from the beginning of the Company). Both gentlemen have plainly declared that the resolutions must either be confirmed to-day or that the whole proceedings would then become void.
Mr. Bentwich: May I ask a question in order to gain further enlightenment in this matter? Supposing that a vote by ballot is demanded,
