No. 37 — "Die Welt" — Page 5
(continued from page 4)
...is, is a matter of complete indifference, even for the most fanatical Zion-Zionist. Not as a Territorialist, not even as a seeker after a "night shelter," but as a man who stands firm on the ground of the Basle Programme, I repeat that the geographical locality in which our model experiment takes place — an experiment which is meant only to bring us moral and financial credit — is in principle entirely immaterial. Only as a matter of expediency would I prefer Palestine for this model experiment as well, for the simple reason that its success, admitting no further objection on grounds of agricultural technique or climate, would at once open credit to us in its full extent.
All this seems to me as clear as daylight — perhaps I am mistaken. But in that case he who would refute me ought at least to make plain to himself that I am here pointing out the beginning of a road to the goal, a road which we can, after all, set foot upon with the slender means of political influence, men and money already at our disposal; he must therefore be able to show a better, easier, shorter road, and indeed a road which, like the one I propose, promises us some success with our slender means of men, money and power as they exist at present. I hold every man a believer in miracles who expects decisive results from diplomacy and the support of the Great Powers, and every man an incurable visionary who expects them from propaganda and agitation, before the basis of credit has been laid. A small group can work in no other way than by drawing the masses to itself through manifest economic successes, and so becoming a mass itself. Propaganda and agitation can never achieve more than to create the means for the first organisations. That Herzl did, that Zionism did, in fully sufficient measure, by rousing those who think and feel; now we must offer something tangible to the dull masses, or else the movement will trickle away into the sand.
I know that Christianity and Social Democracy will be held up against me as proof of the efficacy of propaganda. I can only say here that both owed exceedingly little to propaganda and almost everything to the pressure of overwhelming social conditions. The Jews, to be sure, also stand under mighty social pressure; but we all know that there are other ways of escaping it besides the Zionist endeavour, and hence Zionism may hope for the masses only when it practically opens to them a way out "to the place of lesser economic and social pressure." Without that, propaganda will meet with no rising success, but probably with a very soon declining one — declining, I fear, to nothing. Signs of this are already not to be mistaken. Here lies the kernel of truth in the view of the dissenting Syrkin group — there is a kernel of truth in everything!
Let us return to our "small colonisation." I hope I have now made it clear to the most mistrustful among us that it bears only a passing resemblance to charitable colonisation. It is, to repeat, not an end, but a means to a far higher end; it is meant not in the sense of private economy but of national economy; it is to serve not the persons of the first colonists, chosen by chance, but the community as a whole; it will be measured by that standard alone, and must achieve incomparably more if it is not to be abandoned as a failure. What it has to create is not a home for Schmeije Pinkeles and Schlaume Karfunkelstein of Bialystok, but for the people of Israel as a whole; it is the fixed point in the ocean of mire that threatens to swallow up our people, for we few, who feel in ourselves courage and strength enough for it, must have it in order to rescue the sinking; this "δός μοί που στῶ καί γῆν κινήσω," this one single indispensable fixed point, which gives our gigantic lever its point of application, the hypomochlion — this our model experiment is to create for us: ! ! THE CREDIT BASIS ! !
II. The Guarantee under Public Law.
After these explanations I shall not need much space to settle accounts with the second opposing opinion, which would refuse us the means of the Zionist Organisation for initiating our model experiments until the Charter has been granted or Palestine occupied by England.
This opinion, lately advocated by our honoured old friend Dr. Kahn, calls our attention, and that of the Zionist public, to the fact that the acquisition of landed property in Turkey at all, and still more so for a juridical body such as the National Fund, is a very hazardous matter. We should have to put up a man of straw as nominal owner, and how easily might the man of straw, or his son or grandson, succumb to the temptation of turning his nominal property into real property — against which there would be no legal safeguard, not even one under private law. We must therefore under no circumstances stake the sacred money of the National Fund on so uncertain a card. Not a pfennig of it may be lost.
Should this view prevail, then there is an end of every practical experiment. For the Jewish Colonial Trust and the National Fund are entitled by their statutes only to investments and land purchase in Palestine and the neighbouring countries. Cyprus is not to be considered for political reasons, El Arish for climatic ones; the Turkish lands drop out on legal grounds — consequently we are done. We members of the Palestine Commission then have no task left but to collect geographical, meteorological, technical, agronomical, commercial, etc., facts, so as to be at least theoretically "archiprêts" for that Greek Kalends when the ripe Charter falls into our lap from the political apple-tree. I declare that I have neither time nor inclination for this fool's part. I demand that Herzl's last — in very truth last — will be respected, and that the well-considered resolutions of the Greater and Lesser Actions Committee be carried out, according to which land and working capital were to be placed at the disposal of the experiments proposed by our Commission out of the National Fund. If this resolution is overturned, I shall lay my flute upon the table and lay down my office. I will not share the responsibility for leading millions of unhappy people by the nose, nor will I waste my time and strength on trifles.
Dr. Kahn is entirely right in his description of Turkish legal conditions. He has told us, in his remarks, not the least thing we did not already know. If, nevertheless, we arrived at our proposals to grant land out of the means of the National Fund for an experimental station, a training farm and a settlement co-operative, then from this let no one perhaps
