Die Welt · Vol. IX, No. 37 · 15 September 1905
4printed page
scan 4 of 20
Facsimile · scan 4 of 20
Scan of p. 4
English · AI translation, checked against the German

Page 4 — "Die ✡ Welt" — No. 37

(continued from page 3)

...societies would already be called a great success, we should not hesitate to confess openly as a complete failure; and what would induce them to stride onward along the path once taken with renewed strength and with new propaganda blowing every trumpet, would only induce us to break off our experiments and to lay this part of our mandate, as one we cannot fulfil, back in the hands of those who commissioned us!

This I must explain more fully:

If the colonisation societies were to see all the peasants they have settled attain a modest prosperity, so that they could make their way without subsidies from outside; if their little holdings were to arrive at roughly the average cultivation and yield of the better estates of Palestine, then their members would have achieved far more than they dared to hope in their boldest dreams. We, however, if we achieved only that — we should confess ourselves beaten.

For we want — and must — achieve far more!

We mean to lay out colonies on a plan of organisation of which we expect far more. They must, according to our expectation, come to a material prosperity that rises far above the level of the best peasant settlements in Palestine; our peasants shall not merely be able to subsist decently, but must reach the point of paying very decent interest on the capital lent them for their settlement, and of repaying it very quickly.

That is the minimum we demand, and must demand, of our colonies. For if they do not reach this minimum, then they must simply remain "private-economic," can never thrive onward to "national-economic" effectiveness, — and then our experiment has failed and, so far as we are concerned, will be broken off.

For only if they strike home as brilliantly as we demand as the minimum, only then can they create for the Zionist popular movement that which it needs above all, which alone it needs:

THE CREDIT BASIS!!

I emphasised this with great force recently in an article in the "Welt," when I commended our "Bezalel" to the Zionist world; I seem still not to have emphasised it with sufficient force, for in all the discussions since then the word has not cropped up a single time. And yet it ought to be our Alpha and Omega, for all the hope that Zionism can cherish of a realisation of its ideals, if it does not hope for miracles, stands and falls with the possibility of creating it:

THE CREDIT BASIS!

Without moral and financial credit our political action is hopeless, without financial credit our economic action. I repeat here with all sharpness what I wrote in that article in the "Welt": "The beginning of the Zionist movement was only an amiable dreamer and enthusiast, who held the Zionist ideal attainable without the creation of a credit basis capable of bearing the load; whoever does not see even to-day that we must now have no other immediate aim at all, him I must regard as a grave injurer of our cause."

Without moral and financial credit we are ridiculous mice crawling about the club of Hercules; we are firing dust-shot at fortress walls. Our present forces stand in a disproportion, as tragic as it is comic, to the greatness of our political and economic tasks. We are to conduct politics with European and Asiatic Great Powers; to conduct politics means to negotiate from power to power — and we are a few officers with a troop behind us that is not numerous, not well disciplined, not very united, and above all wholly untried and enjoying the worst of credit (I speak here, of course, only of the slight belief of all non-Jews and of most Jews) that we are capable of founding and maintaining a national economy and a State in any sense whatever. We are, further, to expatriate and resettle several millions, at the least many hundreds of thousands, of wholly destitute proletarians: we dispose, reckoning high, of the thousandth part of the means indispensable for it.

Unless a miracle happens — and politicians above all should least reckon with miracles, such as a great political upheaval and the partition of Turkey, etc. — we have not the slightest prospect of ever obtaining security under public law for a settlement in the Holy Land, through the good will or against the ill will of the Sultan, unless we have first furnished him or the European Great Powers with proof that we Zionists are capable of raising the territory transferred to us to high value, so that it promises to become either an important market for European trade or a rich object of taxation for Turkey, or both. And unless a miracle happens, we have just as little the slightest prospect of ever obtaining even a fraction of the necessary funds through Shekel payments and National Fund collections, unless we have first furnished Jewish and Christian capital with proof that our settlers will pay decent interest on loans and repay them securely.

This twofold proof is our credit basis. If we succeed in the proof, if we create the credit basis, then our goal is attainable. If we fail in the proof, if we do not create the credit basis, then our movement will run dry in the sand.

Where we attempt to furnish this indispensable proof of our abilities and of our good will is, in principle, and to me, a matter of complete indifference. With a better basic organisation it might have been done in Argentina; it can be — and in part will be! — done now through me personally in Germany; it might also have been done in Uganda, had that been a territory serviceable for colonising purposes. For this reason alone I voted in 1903 for the dispatch of the expedition, and for this reason I would now, too, had its result been different, have voted for an experiment there, precisely because I hold a realisation of the Zionist hopes to be possible almost only in Palestine, at all events incomparably easier in Palestine than anywhere else, by reason of the "imponderables"! The creation of the credit basis is an unavoidable step towards our goal, but it is after all only a preparatory step — and where this step taken