Page 8. — "Die Welt" — No. 25.
(continued from page 7)
…not before the parliament of a gigantic practical movement, which is destined to perform useful work but not to solve doctors' questions.
How is this moral and financial credit basis to be created? Only by our — not asserting, but — proving that the average human material on which we have our eye is qualified, by its mental, moral and physical constitution, to build up a commonwealth of some kind: politically as citizens, economically as producers. Hitherto this has seldom been believed of us outside our own camp, and many of us — let us confess it to ourselves — must force ourselves to hold it credible. We must show by trial buildings that our building-stones will bear a load and can be bound to one another: without such trial buildings the outside world will give us neither the land on which to build our palace nor the means we need for it. Only through such trial buildings can we create for ourselves the indispensable credit basis, indispensable as the precondition of every further action.
Without it, even the diplomatic negotiation for the public-law security of Palestine and its neighbouring countries, or of any other territory of economic value, seems to me utterly hopeless; for diplomacy negotiates only with power, be it but a power in the making, as yet only potential. And this again is the precondition of everything further, for until a dense, compact Jewish settlement exists somewhere under legal security, all ideals of national education, whether of a progressive or a retrograde nature, hang free and helpless in empty air.
Such a credit basis, in the narrower financial sense, we can no more beg together by appealing to the Jewish heart than we can coax or extort it by invoking "national feeling"; and the collections for the National Fund, together with the entries in the Golden Book and the stamp donation, likewise have but little prospect of procuring us within any foreseeable time the milliards — the round, well-counted milliards — which are, once and for all, required for the expatriation and resettlement of the hunted millions. Whoever could believe that at the beginning of our movement, in the time of the first enthusiasm, was a credulous Utopian: whoever still believes it to-day is something far worse than that.
Such sums as we need, if we are not to be smothered in "charity," can be obtained only on credit, and only if one furnishes the masters of the great credit market with stringent proof that one has the honest intention and the ability to pay them decent interest and to amortise honestly. And for that we need experiments in small-scale colonisation. If we can set on their feet model colonies which do not merely drag themselves laboriously along with all manner of assistance, but which pay decent and punctual interest on their invested capital and redeem it, then no sum we ask of the capital market is too high, and all the marvels of modern civilisation — railways, harbours, canals, waterworks — will open up the land of our future and create wealth for its people.
The Zionist movement has done me the honour of adopting the plan of co-operative colonisation submitted by me as the basis of its practical work. Perhaps many a fellow Zionist regards these particular ideas with scepticism; perhaps he will put forward another agrarian organisation or — which, to be sure, seems impossible to me — show us a way that will lead us more quickly and effectively, without agrarian colonisation, to the creation of the credit basis: I shall be ready to examine every such plan without prejudice and to take counsel upon it. But whoever among us does not unconditionally acknowledge and strive for the creation of the credit basis, by whatever means, as our next goal, him I must regard as an incurable visionary and a grave injurer of our movement: for this we must make clear to ourselves, that in the course of years the party will at the least crumble away, if not burst asunder, if the leadership does not succeed in keeping confidence and hope alive through tangible results.
Well, for the present I am indeed entitled to regard the plan of agrarian co-operative settlement submitted by me as the official one, and can only lament that the unhappy circumstances of the last years have delayed its realisation more than was the intention of the Actions Committee and especially of our departed leader Th. Herzl. It is to be hoped that in the near future the men and the means will be found to put into effect the whole comprehensive programme which our Palestine Commission has drafted and brought to — theoretical — adoption. Meanwhile I should like to direct the attention of the whole body of Zionists to a work which seems to me destined to bring to our first model colonies a new element of strength and prosperity, and so to heighten our prospect of creating a strong credit basis.
I speak of our "Bezalel," the creation of the Bulgarian Court sculptor Boris Schatz, our gifted fellow Zionist, who proposes to create a home for artistic handicraft and the arts and crafts among the Jews of Palestine.
Home work and domestic industry have, wherever the people, detached from its mother soil, stood as propertyless proletarians over against the capitalist middleman, proved to be one of the surest means of proletarianising the population economically and impoverishing it culturally. For this reason I am also flatly opposed to the well-meant proposals to introduce great export industries into Palestine with Jewish workers (for example, ready-made clothing). The conditions of world-market competition have hitherto always proved stronger than the goodwill and the tribal feeling of the employers, and I want no East End with its sweatshops in the Holy Land.
But where home work and domestic industry are carried on by a population rooted in its own inalienable soil, capitalist misery has never yet been able to develop. Here industrial occupation is, on the contrary, regularly a source of greater prosperity and, in consequence, of a higher moral and intellectual culture. No one will find it hard to account for this difference: where a population is provided with food and dwelling by its landed property, it offers effortless resistance to the pressure of the middleman towards the lowering of wages and other conditions of labour. Only hunger works for starvation wages and "throws wife and child beneath the Juggernaut wheel of Capital," as Karl Marx expressed it. Thus free peasantries flourish mightily through the very same home work that grinds the day-labouring population to pieces; Kropotkin has recently once again (Fields, factories and workshops) brought together rich and valuable material for this long-known law.
That is why I have always contemplated the incorporation of industry, especially in the form of home work, into my co-operative agricultural colonies in Palestine as well. They not only raise prosperity and intelligence, but also multiply the number
