Die Welt · Vol. IX, No. 23 · 9 June 1905
4printed page
scan 4 of 20
Facsimile · scan 4 of 20
Scan of p. 4
English · AI translation, checked against the German

Page 4 — "Die ✡ Welt" — No. 23

(continued from page 3)

...hensible. We know that one can prove anything with figures; on the other hand, as regards Palestine, one seems able to prove all figures. In the "Jüdische Statistik" edited by Dr. Alfred Nossig the number of Jews in Jerusalem is given by Dr. Moses Friedländer as 28 518, by Dr. Saad as 40.000; Baedeker gives the figure 41.000, in a correcting note only 32.000. Finally Dr. Nossig himself, at the end of his work, on the basis of older data, actually arrives at the figure 13.000.

It is the same with the other towns. While Sunez gives the figure 7140 for Safed, Baedecker records 13.000, and the figure given by Sunez for Jaffa as 2970 actually grows in Baedecker to 10.000. The only person who really knows his way about is evidently Dr. Soskin.

He has, moreover, peculiar information about the area of Palestine as well. Whereas in all my books I find the extent of Palestine given as 10.000 square miles, his Palestine is twice as large. Even if Palestine were ten times as large as Dr. Soskin's wild estimate, it could not take in more than some three million Jews. Lastly, the Crown lands, which I thought we might acquire from the Sultan, are unfortunately unhealthy, and their acquisition costly. And finally, it is not I with whom Dr. Soskin disagrees when he says it would be easy to drain these swamps, but the patriotic Palestinian Mr. Ussischkin, to whose pamphlet "Our Programme" I owe my information. Mr. Ussischkin is the first Zionist who faces the Palestine problem sincerely instead of with childish rhetoric, and who looks at the land of which he writes (p. 12): "This land, because of its climatic conditions, is the least suited of all for the beginning of colonisation on a large scale . . . immense preliminary outlays are necessary for its sanitation . . . Moreover, this land does not lie waste." And since, according to Ussischkin's "Our Programme", the only way of obtaining Palestine can be "only by purchase", Dr. Soskin's assertion that the Crown land cannot be bought is the stoutest blow of all "against Palestine".

Israel Zangwill.


Mr. Zangwill for Palestine?

Mr. Zangwill is not satisfied with my correction in Number 20 of "Die Welt", and endeavours, by picking out individual statements from my article, to prove that our two statements hardly contradict each other at all, and that it is really I who am the "culprit" who began it and who supplies the evidence against Palestine. I shall endeavour to avoid the sharp personal tone which marks Mr. Zangwill's remarks.

In his article in No. 17 of "Die Welt" Mr. Zangwill had cited figures which do not correspond to reality, and had drawn from them the conclusion that Palestine was thickly populated, and that therefore, even with the Charter in our hands, we must be prepared either to drive the tribes that possess Palestine out of the land, sword in hand, after the example of our forefathers, or we shall have to contend with the problem of an alien population, etc. Mr. Zangwill arrived at this utterance by assuming the population of the Liwa of Jerusalem to be "52 persons per square kilometre". To be sure, in his present reply he speaks of 57 persons per (English) square mile, which means only 22 souls per square kilometre. He thus knows no difference between the English square mile and the European square kilometre (1 English square mile = 2,59 square kilometres); for had he spoken of 22 souls per square kilometre, he would not have come to the assertion that the Liwa of Jerusalem is so densely populated: 22 persons per square kilometre would indeed be a dense population for northern Scandinavia, but by no means for the Mediterranean region. But a population is certainly thinly sown which in truth, as I set out more precisely in my article in No. 20, shows not 22 but only 15 1/2 souls per square kilometre.

That even now the difference between the English square mile and the European square kilometre has in fact not struck Mr. Zangwill is proved by his fresh utterance: "Whereas in all my books I find the extent of Palestine given as 10.000 square miles, his (Soskin's) Palestine is twice as large." My Palestine remains 29.000 square kilometres in size, and with the addition of the land east of the Jordan and of the Haurân an estimated 35.000 square kilometres, while Mr. Zangwill's Palestine is 10.000 English square miles, that is to say 25.900 square kilometres, in size! Wholly incomprehensible becomes the sentence that now follows: "Even if Palestine were ten times as large as Dr. Soskin's wild estimate, it could not take in more than some three million Jews." Italy, which shows quite similar, if in some respects less favourable, conditions, happens to be ten times as large as my Palestine, that is to say, it has 286.682 square kilometres and has 33 millions of inhabitants. And so, were Palestine as large as Italy, there would still be room for only three million Jews — sic volo, sic jubeo. Any other reason Zangwill remains owing.

Here, as everywhere, the saying holds true: "It is the tone that makes the music." In part Mr. Zangwill's figures on the Jewish population of Palestine happen to coincide with my own. But whereas Mr. Zangwill seeks to prove from these figures that the conditions of population in Palestine present insuperable difficulties to our taking possession of it, and seeks to make the necessary capital out of this for the East Africa project, I, on the basis of figures with which Mr. Zangwill, according to his latest remarks, believes himself to agree, have demonstrated that Palestine is thinly populated*) and that precisely on that account too it is especially suited to our aspirations.

Mr. Zangwill's remarks in Number 17 of "Die Welt" contained inaccuracies and were apt to arouse among the uninformed a false ill-feeling against Palestine. I therefore held myself bound to correct these errors. Among them, besides his statements on the density of population, were his assertions that the lands belonging to the Sultan could be bought up entirely and that they were already in part occupied by Mohammedans from Barbary and the Balkans. Now, to be sure, Mr. Zangwill quotes


*) Compare the following countries, which show similar conditions: the Lebanon district with 59, Samos with 118, Sicily with 135 souls, and Malta, for that matter, with as many as 550