Die Welt · Vol. IX, No. 23 · 9 June 1905
3printed page
scan 3 of 20
Facsimile · scan 3 of 20
Scan of p. 3
English · AI translation, checked against the German

No. 23 — "Die Welt" — Page 3

Dr. Soskin against Palestine.

Perhaps much has been done in this direction, but still not enough. Perhaps the right paths have not always been trodden, the politically most suitable means not always adopted. Let us confess openly that a good deal of what occurred in the Zionist movement was apt to fill Turkey with a certain mistrust, and that consequently certain diplomats, to whom the Zionist idea was contre coeur, or who by their upbringing could not but be disposed against the Jews, had occasion to turn such blunders to account against us.

Let us grant that a leading Turkish diplomat was right when he remarked that the Zionists at once climb over the roof.

The word "Charter", which was coined in our movement surely only for easier understanding and to meet the imagination of the masses, was in a certain sense a small mishap. Mark well: the word, but not its content.

It is regrettable altogether that most people imagined the matter to be easy. It lies, to be sure, within the bounds of probability that Turkey, which has granted certain autonomies to individual parts of her territory, may also be brought to permit an organised Jewish immigration into Palestine with certain facilities and some legal concessions. But it is, after all, a principle of political life that one gives where one at the same time receives.

Thus, by unceasing work, the conviction of the moral and material guarantees had to be furthered and strengthened; but the guarantee of success also had to be secured ad oculos by the creation and procurement of the requisite, uncommon means.

In all these directions starts have been made and beginnings undertaken, but still nothing whole, or even considerable, has been created.

And nevertheless men have made straight for the goal with impatience, indeed with impetuosity. Easily understood. With a certain right, after all, men expected from Zionism an improvement of the Jewish situation. Now, however, most Jews are in a bad situation, and it grows ever worse. They have, therefore, no time to wait.

The departed leader, who in fact organised the national movement, gave it its grand sweep and had many a success to show in the field of politics, who moreover believed in himself and in the victorious power of the idea, and by virtue of his poetic nature and of his faith in right and justice repeatedly felt himself near its realisation, now saw himself compelled to seek a means of speedy relief for the persecuted and the oppressed, but, to justify it on the one hand, and on the other so as not to be regarded as a seducer, to disclose to the whole Zionist world that the true aim of Zionism still required time and labour, gathering and strengthening.

We will not dispute whether the expression "in the foreseeable future" was a happy one, whether the reference to the long road that must still be travelled to the goal might not have been rendered in a milder form.

For the impatient, and for those who seek a way out of the vale of tears of the Galuth, the Uganda proposal became what the Leader himself neither thought nor wished — a new gospel.

(To be continued.)

Dr. Soskin has been so kind as to correct the statements I made regarding the number of inhabitants of Palestine, which were "directed against Palestine". What a strange form of charging one with Zionist disloyalty! On this showing the Japanese too would have acted disloyally towards the Mikado by examining the defences of Port Arthur. And in what way did Dr. Soskin seek to diminish the difficulties which we Zionists face? I said the Jewish population of Palestine amounted to only $12%$; Dr. Soskin said $12\ {}^{1}/{}_{2}%$ of the present population of Palestine are Jews. That is to say, in other words: $88%$ of the present population would be burdened by us with an "alien problem", even in the event of our obtaining the Charter. I said that in the Pashalik of Jerusalem not $25%$ of the population is Jewish; Dr. Soskin says $20%$. I fixed the limit at $25%$ in the endeavour to paint the picture as rosily as possible; Dr. Soskin severely reduces it to $20%$. I said that the greater part of the soil in Palestine is in private ownership and would not come into our possession, even in the event of our obtaining the Charter, until the whole of the land belonging to the Sultan had been acquired by us en bloc; Dr. Soskin tells us that the Sultan will not sell his share at all, but that we might try to lease it from him. I said it would be hard for us to succeed in ruling the Mohammedans, who are accustomed to despise us; Doctor Soskin replies that the Mohammedans despise us only in the towns (where they and we are crowded closely together). To crown his work, Doctor Soskin finds a new difficulty arising for the present inhabitants in the competition of the immigrating Circassians, of whom I had not spoken at all. For what reason, then, did Dr. Soskin undertake the task of "disposing of this fable once and for all"? I wish I were cleverer, that I might understand it. I have the feeling that he is more "against Palestine" than I.

Dr. Soskin moreover behaves as though the data I cited had sprung from my imagination. But I worked from the best political information there is in England — "The Statesman — Year Book", latest edition, and this work gives the population of the part of Palestine known as the Pashalik of Jerusalem as 57 to the square mile, which is more than double the ratio obtaining in the United States. Doctor Soskin accuses me of juggling with figures and of lumping together the thinly and the densely settled districts. Why, does he not know that this is the only way of determining the average? I thought every schoolboy knew that when one speaks of a density of 57 to the square mile one does not mean to say that 57 people live on every square mile. This is the only way of estimating density of population, by setting up the ratio between the area of the land and the population it is able to support, It is not always able to support more, simply because individual districts are comparatively unpopulated. Thus, for example, the density of Sweden and Norway is 25 to the square mile, doubtless because that is the maximum the natural resources of the country can bear. Dr. Soskin naturally calls these 57 in question, but whence he has his statistical infallibility is to me incompre-