Die Welt · Vol. IX, No. 17 · 28 April 1905
6printed page
scan 6 of 20

Page 6 — "Die Welt" — No. 17

(continued from page 5)

...see, which can and will accrue to Zionism from the rise of the East African colony; as impossible as it is, at the beat of a crow's wing, to foresee what effects in detail the avalanche will have. But to some probable political consequences I should still like to point. Precisely when the distress of the moment no longer presses us, we shall be able to negotiate with the Sultan from a stronger position. Here is the platform desired by Mr. Feiwel, in serviceable form, because it lies outside the sphere of power of him against whom it is to serve us. Old Archimedes already knew that the lever with which one would force the earth out of its orbit must be applied from a point lying outside it. It has been written somewhere in the last few days — I do not know whether in Mr. Feiwel's article — that the Powers would convene no special congress for the solution of the Jewish question. That is quite correct. But when once they form a congress for the regulation of affairs in Hither Asia, perhaps only after one or more wars, then we must work to ensure — and for that we need statesmen at our head — that the Jewish Palestine question, too, form an item of the agenda, and well for us then, if we can already point to successes which prove our capacity for independent cultural work and for the building of a society.

Another benefit for Palestine I expected, further, in a material respect. If it is true, as Mr. Feiwel has intimated, that Herzl in 1898, at the time when in London he made that much-criticised utterance that the Jewish people would set itself in motion in the near future, already held in his hands the assurance of a district autonomy, and that the matter then came to grief only through the failure of Jewish high finance, then it may surely be expected that capital, should the question once again become a live one, would show itself less reserved if the colonising capacity of our human material had already been proved by a successful example.

Gentlemen! All the favourable results which I expect for the furtherance of Zionism from the acceptance of the East African project and from care for its purposeful undertaking I cannot prove to you, just as one can prove nothing exactly so long as it lies in the future. But a good deal, such as the co-operative settlement as a foundation, is theoretically so well prepared that the moment for the experiment seems to have come. Here for once the opportunity offers itself to us to show that Zionism does not find its satisfaction merely in theorising. We have already once had a time in which the possibility of independent work was taken from us. In those days we occupied ourselves with immersing ourselves ever more deeply in complicated theoretical speculations, in which, in intricate systems and disputations, we laid down for every side of life, down to the finest details, how we would do things if we had the power and the opportunity to work. The result of this labour of deepening, carried on for several hundred years, was the Talmud with its commentaries and sub-commentaries.

To-day we are already on the way, out of sheer deepening and scientific dissection, to dispute Zionism asunder into a new Talmud, with 1000 paragraphs, with commentaries and sub-commentaries, with Halacha and culture-Hagada. And everyone has his own special commentary, and whoever has not studied it quite exactly "understands nothing of Zionism". — It must for once be said aloud: the sublime idea of Zionism is simple and clear to grasp, and the plain man who has beheld it with his heart stands just as high as the most learned Zionist of "deepening".*) Indeed, the dissectors and system-builders should only beware

*) The course of the discussion compels me to a subsequent explanation of the sense in which I wish the expression "Zionism of deepening" to be understood. As a matter of course I regard an ample scientific investigation and clarification of all the conditions that come into question for the success of our work as indispensable. What I set myself against is only the notion that a "deepening" of the simple fundamental idea of Zionism — the Jewish people in the Jewish land — is necessary, desirable or possible. What I wished to combat is only the method which abstracts the idea from its material substratum and works with it as an independent object, turns it, tugs it,

lest, out of sheer looking, they unlearn how to see! Above all, though, lest out of sheer "work" they forget the opportunity for work! If we now let the white stag run past because we are too busy talking about it, then let us only beware lest history one day say of us: "But the great moment found a little generation." Not everything, I have already said it, will come to pass as we imagine it. Some things will prove mistaken, some will develop in another direction. But theoretically we are sufficiently prepared, and only the deed can make the final decision. Faust, at home in every faculty and possessed of all the knowledge of his age, finds at last no other way out of the recognition of the insufficiency of theory than flight into life: "Let us plunge into the rush of time, Into the rolling of event! There let pain and pleasure, Success and vexation Alternate as best they can; Only in restless action does the man prove himself."

Gentlemen! When in olden times, before there were steamships or the compass, the mariner sailed out upon the sea, he often could not steer for his goal by the straight and shortest course. Before reefs and shoals he often had to make detours, calm hindered his further passage, contrary winds forced him to tack or to cast anchor, and before storms he may well have had to seek refuge for a time in a harbour lying off his course. But in the northern sky there shone for him, as a sure guide to his goal, the Pole Star. — Our Pole Star shines in the East. We, too, may for a time be driven from the straight course by reefs and contrary winds; storms such as now rage about the Jewish people may compel us to seek refuge for a while in a hospitable harbour lying off our course. But in the East our Pole Star shines for us, immovable as the Pole Star in the northern sky, and shows us the final goal: Kadimah.

Ugandism, Territorialism, Palestinism, Zionism.

It is a wholesome crisis that Zionism is now passing through — so one always tells oneself by way of comfort when one looks into the seemingly hopeless confusion which the discussion of the most important problems brings to light. Behind the lustre which the glorious personality of a Herzl lent to our cause, and behind the unity again and again made manifest and anchored in his powerful individuality, there slumbered unreconciled antagonisms which sooner or later were bound to break through. That began even in Herzl's lifetime, and his idealist's heart, which was no match for the rough storms of political passion, broke under it. Now, indeed, one heard the edifice of our organisation, which had shot up all too quickly, cracking in every joint. The windbags whom the thunder-word of the mighty one had scattered in all directions came hurrying busily up, in the delusion that their combined blowing would bring to its fall the mighty edifice which they had so often declared a house of cards. The offended woodworms slipped out of their dark holes, whither they had fled before the radiant sun, and purposed their

transforms it, until it stands in direct contradiction to that idea which formed one unity with the material substratum. This method has always been to blame when a science went astray. This method leads to the impoverishment of our outlook, and its upholders resemble the miser who sits upon his chest and has quite forgotten that money possesses value only in so far as it can help to procure the goods of life. This impoverishment I wished to mark as being on the way, when an ardent youth, out of sheer fear that the Palestine idea might be stolen from it, already pushes aside the equivalent factor, the people, by artificial juggling with concepts.