Page 8 — "Die Welt" — No. 16
(continued from page 7)
…old Jewish life and mutual intercourse thirst. When in the year 1881 the first ship full of Russian-Jewish emigrants came to America and landed in Philadelphia, the rich, charitable Jewesses of Philadelphia went out to meet the refugees with loving hearts and bountiful hands. They washed the dirty little children. All was delightfully idyllic. But they did not yet know how many tens of thousands of dirty little children would come. They soon gave up the washing of children.
In the year 1886, when the first period of Jewish immigration was over, the New York charitable institutions shrank almost entirely together. Had the stream which began its course in the year 1881 been directed to a Jewish State, the American Jews would gradually have been relieved of five-sixths of their present burdens. Immeasurable expenditure is required for this roaming about of the Jews.
The attempt to solve political problems by philanthropy is characteristically Jewish in its timidity and, on the other hand, a financial madness. It is as though one wished to carry people across a river one by one, instead of building a bridge once for all. Although we have no navy, we nevertheless keep a Jewish fleet which sails about the whole year round, laden with our exiles. Yes, exiles, for even Russia is dear to those who spent their childhood there, and Dr. Maurice Fischberg will tell you how many Russian Jews are pining away with homesickness. Men cannot with impunity be torn from their native soil and transplanted to another, where they feel demoralised and uprooted, where their children outgrow them and become estranged from them. While every generation must differ from the one before it, here the much-vaunted policy of Americanisation tears the children away from their parents by a distance of four generations. Send our Russian emigrants to a Jewish territory, and you will soften the transition and forestall the demoralisation. And it is, after all, evident that the Russian Jews will not cease to emigrate in future as well. Notwithstanding the protests against Kishineff, desperate riots of reservists have within the space of one month ruined the Jewish population of 35 towns. Our Russian brethren have an army of 30,000 Jews in the field, but they are not defending their own homes — they have marched out against the Japanese. Shall I remind you of the Roumanian Jews, who have literally been given over to death by a legislation which closes to them one branch of livelihood after another? Or of the Persian Jews, of those of Morocco, who live in the shadow of barbarism? Shall I remind you of the Blood Libel, which hangs over us like a sword of Damocles, to strike somewhere at every Easter-tide? Or shall I pass over the physical persecutions which degrade the masses and remind you of the social persecution which humiliates the classes? Shall I speak of the boycotting of Jews in Austria and Germany, or mention the summer hotels and university clubs of America? Shall I call to mind the Aliens Commission in England? Shall I utter the word "Dreyfus"? A Marrano told me in Spain that in his childhood he once questioned his nurse about the Jews. "There are none any more," she answered, "they are all in hell." It is a fairly apt general picture of our common situation, even if it is painted in all too flaming colours. In our hell there are cool and comfortable little corners, but a hell it is. A people which has no territory, no ambassador, no consul, is at the mercy of every other people. Spain itself seemed a paradise to the Jews for four centuries, and only when the flames of the Inquisition began to rage did it become a hell.
To a people so ill-used through centuries the thought of a home must have been as welcome as the harbour lights to a storm-tossed traveller. But no! The same Spanish Jew to whom I preached Zionism exclaimed: "What? Give up our position here?" His position here! Only for the last thirty years has he been allowed to live in Spain at all. No office, no dignity of any kind could he hold; he could not even build himself a house of prayer. And yet, "give up his position here?"
We are told on all sides that no Jew will want to go to a Jewish territory. What? This eternal wanderer, this world-wise Odysseus, who has known all men and all cities, will not want to wander to this one place, and that place — home?
After the wailing at the altars Of strangers, after toil in a strange land, After the mourning by the rivers Of strangers, with vainly pleading hand, After the cords, the bonds, the burdens, After centuries, consumed by fire, Should they not find peace at last, And the land of their hot desire?
Western Zionism may indeed have little to offer the well-to-do Jews, save moral dignity, just as it would have had little to offer the Jewish grandees of Spain before the days of the Expulsion and the Inquisition. But for the overwhelming majority of our kinsmen — and half the Jews of the world live in Russia — it is a doctrine not merely of self-respect but of salvation. Ask a Russian Jew whether he would rather have been born in a Jewish land, under a Jewish flag, or in Kishineff. And if he should name Kishineff, would you not take him for a madman or a liar?
This freedom, this independence, which most men value more highly than life, for whose sake the Boers astounded mankind, just as our own forefathers impressed the Greeks and Romans — are they merely moonshine visions? Was the whole of mankind in the wrong, and are only the anti-Zionists in their right minds? No, anti-Zionism may disguise itself as philosophy, drape itself as religion, but at bottom it is the Marrano habit in us that has become our second nature. It is the yellow badge which we wore for centuries, which clings to our souls; it is the timidity and distrust of oneself, born in centuries of persecution; it is the longing of the prisoner for his chains, All organs that are not used become atrophied and waste away. As men, through not climbing, have lost their prehensile tails, so have we, through not governing ourselves, lost the political instinct, the love of independence. We have become blind, like the fish that in the dark caves of
