Page 8. — "Die Welt" — No. 14.
(continued from page 7)
…Dubois-Reymond has described as an error of thought peculiar above all to youth.
But will great capital, then, be willing to take the matter up at all? — Shortly after the VIth Congress Dr. Karl Peters expressed himself on the affair in the "Tägliche Rundschau", and, with regard especially to the question of money, gave it as his opinion that Jewish great capital would have to take a friendly attitude towards the plan, if only because the assimilated Jews of the West see their own social position threatened ever anew by the mere existence of a numerous wandering Jewish proletariat. This sober consideration of an outside observer will not be escaped even by those Jewish great capitalists who have no ear for the Zionist leading motives.
But we need not look so far afield at all; for the great relief societies already stand before a wall which will soon bar the whole world to immigrants without a gap. Even England, America, Canada are already preparing to close their frontiers to the stream of immigrants. Then the relief societies will receive from our hands, with a feeling of deliverance, a colonial territory secured by legal guarantees.
How, then, can we learn from the East Africa project for our final aim? — As you know, the Vth Congress resolved that all lands to be purchased from the means of the National Fund shall remain common property for all time and may never be transferred into private ownership. Therewith it linked the beginning of our new history to ancient Jewish tradition. "The land shall not be sold for ever, for the land is mine; for ye are strangers and sojourners with me."
The indispensable condition for the transfer of the Charter to be obtained to the capital companies is therefore: Guarantees must be given that the land shall never become an object of speculation. It must remain in the ownership of the company to be formed until, by amortisation, it passes into the inalienable possession of the village and town communities that have arisen. There may be no right of mortgage in the country. This demand is the minimum of what we must require. It is desirable that Zionist forces should further devote themselves privately to the cause — as Zionists indeed work in the relief associations, in the Toynbee Halls, in the Bnei-Brith lodges — so that Oppenheimer's plan may prevail, that the backbone of the colonisation must be formed by a system of agricultural productive co-operatives, whose yields are designed in the first place not for export, but for satisfying the home demand. Herzl already stated it with all sharpness in the opening speech of the Vth Congress: "Our settlers shall live on the soil from the soil, not anxiously look out for the market price as feeble traders. They should seek the market only with the products which they have over and above their own needs. Every settlement shall administer itself as an agricultural productive co-operative according to the principles which experience and science already place in our hands to-day."
That is the way by which all the conclusions drawn from the capitalist economic methods hitherto, on the question how many people the land might feed per square kilometre, would become void and be far outstripped by reality. In this way it can be successfully prevented that, together with immigration, the social question be brought in, as the phylloxera with the vines, because to every inhabitant the full yield of his labour is assured.
These are the points of view I had in mind when I spoke at the beginning of the East African territory possibly becoming for us an economic experimental station of the highest importance for our final aim.
(To be continued.)
Reply to Mr. Greenberg.
By W. Schabotinsky. German by A. Benjamin.
Mr. Greenberg may justly be acknowledged as the leader of the Ugandists. First, a large share in the origin of the project itself is ascribed to him. Secondly, for that very reason, he is more than anyone else initiated into the open and secret details of this project. Thirdly, he is the only Ugandist who in the name of Uganda developed a certain energy not only in words but also in deeds. Notwithstanding all the enthusiasm of the Yea-sayer majority, no one gave means for the Expedition, and no one would have given anything had not Mr. Greenberg succeeded in raising the necessary sum himself and in furthering the Expedition. However the Expedition may be composed, we owe it solely and entirely to Mr. Greenberg, and we must justly regard him as the leader of Ugandism. Therefore his open letter is in a certain sense a semi-official declaration of the Ugandists, and from this letter we can now form an idea of the seriousness and the grounds of the Uganda theory.
Mr. Greenberg is by no means a Territorialist. For him Uganda is not even a Jewish State. "The land proposed is not Palestine and will consequently never become a Jewish State." Mr. Greenberg goes even further than many of those who share his views, and even acknowledges the necessity of real work in Palestine; but Uganda must nevertheless be accepted. "But whatever may happen, let us guard against the disgrace which must necessarily fall to our lot if we Jews leave this offer of the English Government unregarded!" And why Uganda is necessary, Mr. Greenberg explains to us as follows. First, "it is very important that the ever-worsening situation of the Jews be alleviated (materially)". "And we are convinced that this alleviation is present in the great Jewish settlement which is now proposed to us." Secondly, "this raising must precede the movement which has as its aim the rebirth of the Jewish nation", that is to say, the settlement of Palestine and the creation of the Jewish State there; for this task is too hard for the inhabitants of the present ghetti, and can be carried out only by free, nationalistically educated citizens of the future settlement in Uganda.
Let us do full justice to this motivation; there is much truth in it. The more our movement develops, the more clearly we see that for the creation of the Jewish State Jewry must provide itself not only with tears but also with strength, that we must grow strong. Louder and louder sound the voices saying that this self-strengthening must find expression, besides in national union and the development of national self-consciousness, also in the raising of our economic and legal position. Our poverty, the tormenting process of our emigration, the disgrace of our rightlessness — all this demands im-
