Die Welt · Vol. IX, No. 12 · 24 March 1905
7printed page
scan 7 of 20

No. 12 — "Die ✡ Welt" — Page 7

But it is not romanticism alone that speaks for Palestine and against another territory.

We need a land large enough to be able, if need be, to receive the whole Jewish people. Palestine satisfies this condition too, — Palestine, be it understood, not in Ussishkin's sense, but in Warburg's. According to the calculations of the latter, Palestine alone, at a medium state of cultivation, can receive 2½ million people, while the countries adjoining Palestine can receive the trifle of 100 million souls. Room enough, then, for the Jewish people. In fact one cannot speak of Palestine alone at all. In our age of rapid communication one cannot surround a country with a wall. Even if at the outset we wished to colonise Palestine only, further development would quite naturally lead to the colonisation of the adjoining countries. We shall attempt to show in the following article that the idea of the "greater Palestine" has, precisely now, in view of Territorialism, become a vital condition of normal Zionist development. For the present, however, we content ourselves with pointing out that Palestine with the adjoining countries is "the best, most favourable and most capable of development of territories."

In this respect we can appeal to a very impartial witness, whose authority the Territorialists too will acknowledge: to Israel Zangwill, whose article "The Commercial Future of Palestine" is reprinted in the recently published book "The Voice of Truth."

Yet all these proofs will not make a single Territorialist renounce his "philosophy of life," because, as a practical man, he can point again and again to two facts: 1. We have not got Palestine, this land is not being given us; and 2. Jewish colonisation must be begun as quickly as possible. We hold, however, that precisely the second demand, which is entirely justified, — more, whose fulfilment in the near future belongs precisely among the vital necessities of Zionism, — can very well be fulfilled, even under the given circumstances. Of this we shall speak in the following article.

For the present, however, we should like only briefly to touch upon the first point. It is simply a sign of degeneracy when representatives of the Jewish proletariat speak of a freedom given as a gift. Autonomy will be given us! What is given can also be taken away. Let us but remember the fate of the Boers! We do not thereby wish to pass judgment upon events already past, but we must nevertheless emphasise that no given autonomy is guaranteed.⁵) As things now stand, if the Jews wish to have their own national school, they must beg the means for it together from the whole world. Perhaps under certain circumstances one may yet receive a colony as a gift, but never, never freedom. The Jewish proletariat, which has entered the Zionist movement at all only within the last two or three years, has no moral right whatever to become very impatient. Has it achieved all that it could and should achieve? Who knows whether we should not have Palestine already, had the Jewish people in its totality supported the work of national liberation? Who is more called upon to work for the liberation of the people than the conscious Jewish working proletariat? And truly, what people has attained its national freedom in seven or eight years? What work of liberation has ever been accomplished in so short a time? Do but look at the history of the peoples and classes struggling for independence: what readiness for sacrifice, what joy in labour, what fighting spirit and perseverance, above all perseverance?

But when we shall all have done our duty, when we shall have transformed the great majority of the Jewish people languishing in the Golus into a Jewish people conscious of its destinies and fighting tenaciously for its freedom, then we shall obtain Palestine. Even those who reproach official Zionism, and our Herzl in particular, with optimism must admit that the non-attainment of our wishes is to be ascribed not so much to Turkey's aversion in principle as "to the circumstance that to her counter-demand we could offer only a promise, no performance. It would seem to me, from Herzl's own utterances," writes Mr. Feiwel, "as I heard them from his own lips, that this latter situation had already arisen."

From whatever standpoint we consider Territorialism, we come to the conclusion that it is the philosophy not of a Jewry striving after its regeneration, but of the Jew lashed by want. An emergency measure, however, is never an act of State.

But an emergency rightly recognised may well influence the act of State. Territorialism compels us to arrange Zionist activity in such a way that every justification for its existence would be made impossible. It is not enough to say: Back to Palestine! We must also be clear about the "How." In short: what was fairly expected from the Uganda project we must seek to realise, at least to the same extent and in an equally long time, in Palestine with the adjoining countries. Neither Territorialism nor Chowewe-Zionism — whether open or concealed — but political, that is, integral Zionism, which lets itself be determined by all the necessities of the people.

What do our Zione-Zionists propose? Of this in the following article. Geneva, March 1905. Dr. D. Pasmanik.


To the Yes-Sayers!

True to the resolution of the A.C. adopted in April of last year, the "Welt," as the organ of the Zionists as a whole, would be ready to accept objective and pertinent articles for and against Uganda, so as to let opinions and views clarify and settle. It has, for instance, printed the article of Mr. Greenberg with the same pleasure as the rejoinders of Dr. Pasmanik.

Regrettably, all the articles so far received from Ugandists and Territorialists are without exception of such a nature that they stray into personal territory and, in place of objective expositions and arguments, contain merely attacks on particular persons as the bearers of opposing ideas.

The appeal below, despite the suspicions and accusations, perhaps brought bona fide, against the A.C., is still among the tamest pronouncements of those Zionists who also propagate the Uganda project.

We therefore publish it with the necessary reservations and hereby declare decidedly that


⁵) Every autonomy is guaranteed by law or by treaty, as a rule by both. The comparison with the Boers does not hold, since it was they who believed themselves strong enough to break the treaty with England. (Editor's note.)