Page 4 — "Die Welt" — No. 12
(continued from page 3)
…ceptional position thrust, the gulf grew ever wider. Thus the world itself, with an unequalled refinement, created a type that is unsympathetic to it, only then to point its finger at him and cry: Fie, what an abomination! — To-day a small, a very small fraction of Jews has succeeded in freeing their own persons from that ugly situation. — But that profits neither them nor the community as a whole! For since the vast mass remains, and must remain, in that condition into which it was brought against its will, that unhappy figure, unsympathetic to the stranger, still passes as the type of the Jew. More than that: the Golus and that kindly method of education have stamped their marks upon the very souls of many of our race; there are among us, precisely among the Jews who have become partakers of formal equality of rights, many such Golus natures who challenge scorn and contempt by being ashamed of their people, their past, their name and their faith; who, cowardly and doglike, whining for the bread of charity, themselves join in the Hep-Hep howl; who, conscious of their Jewishness as of a guilt, are the first to raise the cry "Beat the Jew," and who, in order to prove the soundness of their convictions, do not shrink from denouncing to the bloodthirsty mob the other, better Jews who go their way quietly and proudly. — Those are the Jews who prop up antisemitism!
Now at the moment when the one disappears, the other must pass away too. — But the fact is simply that there will be an end of antisemitism as of Zionism only when the foundation of both, the Golus, has vanished. Were the highest aim of the enemies of the Jews attained, the end of the Jewish people — then indeed, but not a moment sooner, would the people's longing for Zion be over as well. — But when the exile, as we conceive it, shall have ended, when that vast latent cultural force of the Jewish people is set free, when upon the soil of Palestine a nursery of culture shall arise, then the name "Jew" will be recognised as a name of honour, then the premise of the hatred of the one side, as of the cowardly shame of the other, will be blotted out. — And so it appears that the only hope we can cherish of finally overcoming the antisemitic current lies precisely where all our national hopes lie, in striving and fighting for our Zion programme.
And this the Jewish people has always known in times of the sorest distress. That constant refrain: "Next year in Jerusalem" — those ever-recurring prayers for Zion — which Professor Geiger has called blasphemous! — they bear witness to it. In all the torment of the moment the persecuted never despaired, since they had the certainty of a better future. Only this hope, only the constant labour for the realisation of this ideal, has preserved the Jewish people. This thought, like a pillar of fire, has shown it the way through the nocturnal desert of the Middle Ages. — And if to-day one no longer understands these prayers, if to-day one strikes out these words as a meaningless phrase — well, then one has simply not followed the inner developments, but is simply nothing but a product of the fear of antisemitism. It is pitiful to fritter oneself away in mere defence; the best defence is positive work! — Instead of performing such work, instead of acting according to one's own best conscience, a great many are forever looking askance and anxiously at the wicked antisemites, so that, if one were to be guided by these Jews, Ahlwardt and Pückler would actually form the conscience of Judaism.
"Zionism" — this is the author's second thesis — "is inwardly unjustified, because it asserts a Jewish nationhood, whereas the German Jews know of only one people, the German."
To characterise this phrase, which we have had to hear often enough, that there is no Jewish nationhood, I can find nothing better than the old anecdote which I have told once before in such a case — the exclamation of the physician who, after a long time, sees his patient, whom he had given up, fresh and in good health again:
"What? You are alive and you are recovering?! Then you cannot have followed my prescriptions!"
These gentlemen amputate our language, our prayers, our customs — they would gladly amputate our noses too — and then cry out: Where is your language — where are your other distinguishing marks? — and boldly deny us our own identity to our faces. And him who has kept himself untouched and unadulterated they indignantly reproach for it into the bargain! —
Even Professor Geiger cannot deny that the Jew is everywhere recognisable by certain unamputatable characteristics. "But," says he, "what difference is there between an English lord and a Russian schnorrer, an Amsterdam diamond-cutter and a German district-court judge — if all four are of the Jewish faith?"
Very pretty indeed. Does the Professor believe that the difference is smaller when it is a question of a pimp from Berlin O — a Kommerzienrat from Berlin W — a professor of literature and a cabaret comedian, all of whom are German subjects? I will grant that the difference between many a Jewish communal representative and an Aryan antisemitic threshing-count is at times hard to discern. In earnest the Professor holds — and since a very important point of view is touched upon here again, we will disregard the childish manner of the argument — that the German Jew is rooted wholly and entirely in German culture — in language, inclinations, mode of thought, etc. There is unquestionably something true in this. — We cannot and will not deny that with most of our kinsmen in Germany Jewish sources of culture have had only a very small share of influence upon the course of their intellectual development. We need not even think of the conscious assimilationists. Nearly all of us speak German better than Yiddish or Hebrew; all of us, as boys in Quinta, railed at the treachery of the Gallic hereditary foe, as boys in Tertia mocked the shopkeeping spirit of the vipers across the Channel, and as boys in Prima wrote our Hohenstaufen drama in iambic pentameters. — For the most part we know our Wallenstein better than Jehuda-Halevy's Divan, and have occupied ourselves more with Doctor Faust than with Elischa ben Abujah. — Even in our young-Jewish poets and artists we could probably point to far more non-Jewish than Jewish influences.
But what does this prove for Geiger's thesis? To begin with, he would consistently have to rob the Germans mercilessly of a Frederick the Great, for example, since precisely this great German prince and philosopher was wholly and entirely dependent upon a foreign, French culture, and even had nothing but contempt for the German language and literature. — But further, our Western European culture is, after all, a unified one; it forms a great common treasury of the mind, to which the individual nations and individuals have contributed according to their particular character. — Mark me well! I am far from wishing, say, to repeat the phrase that poets and thinkers altogether by no particular na-
