Die Welt · Vol. IX, No. 12 · 24 March 1905
3printed page
scan 3 of 20
Facsimile · scan 3 of 20
Scan of p. 3
English · AI translation, checked against the German

No. 12 — "Die Welt" — Page 3

(continued from page 2)

…hold for the whole — for should it perhaps be argued that it is precisely division alone that brings salvation, one would come to saying that the smallest fraction, that is, every individual, must help himself alone or else deserve to perish — one would come to a denial of all the social foundations of our world-order; with this logic one would literally go to pieces.

"Zionism signifies no inner development of Judaism, but is a consequence of antisemitism."

That is the author's first thesis! — That this proposition is erroneous we shall soon see. — But first something else: I miss the antithesis in this thesis. Could not Zionism, even if it were a consequence of antisemitism, nevertheless signify an inner development? Can anything in the world develop solely from within — are not influences coming from without, rather, decisive for development? Is the idea of German unity invalid, must the German Empire dissolve, because the imperial coronation at Versailles was a consequence of France's war of aggression? Even to chance — to use that senseless word — we owe a good deal! Though James Watt's aunt made tea without any thought of inventions — we nevertheless make use of the steam-engine invented on that occasion; — we recognise the law of gravitation, although the apple fell on Newton's skull without any particular intention. Berthold Schwarz was seeking the philosophers' stone and invented gunpowder — and it is fortunate that he did so; the Professor, since he had not gone into the laboratory expressly for that purpose, would probably have refrained from the invention. It would be worth while for once to discuss seriously the relation between antisemitism and Zionism. — Professor Geiger insists absolutely on having the one regarded as cause and the other as effect. Here antisemitism is the cause and Zionism its effect — but in the further course of his exposition he suddenly turns the story round; now Zionism is dangerous because it is apt to produce antisemitism! — From this contradiction alone it is evident that we are dealing with a circulus vitiosus. In all probability the relation of the two ideas is not, after all, so simply to be characterised. Zionism, says Geiger, is a fruit of the most recent antisemitism! And in proof — he points out that throughout the whole of the Middle Ages it needed only the slightest impulse to make Messianic or national hopes burst into bright flame. — From this, one would think, the very opposite is surely to be concluded: namely, that in all times and under all circumstances the national idea of Zion lived in the Jewish people, that the sacred fire glowed on unceasingly. Where no spark smoulders, no bellows can produce a fire. — It is quite true, and is by no means to be denied, that through antisemitism many a man has remembered that he is a Jew — that antisemitism thus appeared as a part of that power which ever wills evil and yet at times works good as well. The definition of a nation as a group of men with common enemies applies above all to us Jews! — But how comes it that precisely the better elements — this Geiger too admits — have drawn this conclusion and rallied round our banner?! — How comes it that mere defence has suffered shipwreck, and that out of nothing, out of mere negation, a positive whole has come into being? — And further — has this idea taken hold only of those who are oppressed by antisemitism? — Has not Zionism received its strongest accession and its best leaders precisely from the ranks of those who, by position or other fortunate circumstances, are entirely removed from the consequences of antisemitism? And are they not, on the other hand, precisely those who harbour an understandable fear of the antisemitic leanings of their fellow-citizens who combat Zionism — so that antisemitism, the dread of the wicked antisemites, actually constitutes the gravest danger for Zionism? — Can one not say, with far more justice than belongs to Geiger's thesis: Anti-Zionism breaks with the inner development of Judaism; it is a consequence of antisemitism!? And then, how can the author here reproach Zionism with having been engendered by antisemitism, when in his introduction, in assenting to the justification of the Zionist idea for Russia, etc., he says precisely the reverse — that he values Zionism only where it is a consequence of antisemitism?

From some quarters we have now and again heard: Why, you want exactly the same thing as the antisemites, the exodus of the Jews! — There our idea was conceived not as a counter-current to antisemitism, but as a force moving in the same direction — running parallel to it or as its continuation. — This conception, too, is naturally incorrect, incorrect as to premises, aim and ways. — The premise of antisemitism is: the Jews are a culturally harmful community — that of Zionism: the Jews constitute an eminently important, vigorous factor of culture. The aim of antisemitism is: the extirpation of everything Jewish from society — that of Zionism: the creation of a centre of strength for everything Jewish! — The way of antisemitism is: the restriction of the Jews' freedom of movement, the curtailment of their capacity for development — that of Zionism: the furtherance of a free Jewish development released from hampering barriers. — Even to-day the enormous mistake is often made of seeing in antisemitism nothing but an ephemeral phenomenon, called forth by a few foolish or malicious people. Nothing is more false than that. A current which has seized such enormous masses must have a deeper origin — cannot have arisen from the pebble-throwing of a few ill-bred boys. Conversely, shrewd speculators in public opinion, intent on their own advantage, have known how to turn the existing current to account. — Zionism, says Geiger, will cease when antisemitism disappears. — There is something true in that. Both, namely, will end at the same time: at the moment when Zionism shall have attained its goal, antisemitism too will have its foundation withdrawn. For — and that is the kernel of the matter — Zionism and antisemitism do not stand to each other in the relation of cause and effect; they have the same cause. That misfortune of the Jewish people, the Golus, the exile, — has called forth among friends and foes alike, as an unnatural and impossible condition, a reaction, the desire for a change. — And while the one side says: Strike the homeless dead! — the other says: Give them a home!

In truth, the real cause of antisemitism is nothing but the anomaly of our existence, the existence of a people instinctively holding fast to its nationhood and scattered over the whole earth. Through the manifestations of antipathy — by which I mean the massacres, the burnings of Jews, the exceptional legislation, etc., the Jewish mass was then ever more and more into an ex-