No. 12 — "Die Welt" — Page 5
(continued from page 4)
…tion may be claimed. Quite the contrary, I am convinced that only the development of the individuality of single persons as of nations can lead to the creation of new values of culture. But their product, that which has been created by the several nations, by the geniuses and talents of the several peoples, is the common property of all. Only the Romans could raise that wonderful edifice of law which to-day affords protection to all nations; only the Greeks could find those ideals of beauty in which all men to-day delight; only the Jews could lay down those maxims of the art of living, grand in their simplicity, which serve as the foundation for the development of all peoples. — If to-day we are rooted in Occidental culture, that means that we draw advantage from all that the civilised peoples of the world have created since the beginning. We Jews have contributed not the smallest part. But while men are now already beginning to dispute with us even that which was never formerly disputed, our oldest gifts upon the altar of mankind, they have long been agreed in denying us what we have given for centuries and down to the most recent times. Everything of cultural value that a Jew creates is at once annexed by the community within which he lives; only the evil that a Jew does is charged to the account of the Jews as a whole. Mark Antokolsky was not permitted to live in Russia, — but his works stand as the flower of Russian art in the Alexander Museum in St. Petersburg. — Instead of many other weighty examples, only one drastic one, which put me personally in a mood both merry and melancholy enough. At the Chess Congress in Hanover in 1902, of 18 masters present, 9 were Jews. And there the struggle raged as to whether this time the Germans or the English, or the Americans or the Russians would prove themselves the most gifted for the royal game. And a fellow-citizen "of the Mosaic confession," who rejoiced at the high percentage of "co-religionists," remained dumb when I begged him to enlighten me as to what the inner connexion between chess and religion might be. —
To this day and everywhere we furnish specifically Jewish values of culture; — only they are not recognised as Jewish. Every building-stone we bring is accepted, but others receive the receipt. — Yet one cannot say that the culture we possess contains fewer Jewish elements than Germanic or Slavonic ones. —
That we are now brought up within a particular circle of thoughts and interests which we have in common with our non-Jewish fellow-citizens lies in the nature of things. And it would be quite right so, since we have infinitely many interests in common with them. — The evil is only that we neglect our own particular interests utterly. — If, from the first awakening of his understanding, the boy were told not only of Hermann the Cheruscan but also of Judah Maccabee, — if he were told not only of the brilliant tournaments of the Middle Ages but also of the life of the communities in Worms and Mainz in the pre-Lehmann era, — I believe German patriotism would not suffer by it, but in return we should obtain young Jews somewhat more upright and more conscious of themselves than those who come from the Gymnasium to-day.
But is it not downright faithless, — not on the part of Professor Geiger, — with him it is merely thoughtless! — first to cut off all knowledge of everything Jewish, to hide all Jewish values under an alien mask, — and then to cry out: You have learned nothing Jewish, you are not Jews! — Yes, if we had followed their prescriptions, — if we were to follow them for two or three generations more!! But that is over once and for all! We are not only loyal citizens of the State to which we belong, — like the others, but we also fulfil our duty towards our race, — like the others. We have become whole men; we demand for ourselves the right to live out our individuality, — our national individuality. And we know that only by claiming and exercising this right, which everyone else claims freely and unhindered for himself, shall we attain earnest and full equality of rights.
Yes, we know still more! We know that in this way we shall also assure ourselves of the gratitude of the whole civilised world! For that is the gravest side of this subject. By forcibly suppressing a development of Jewish culture we rob the world of high and irreplaceable values! We are of the opinion that, by fostering the Jewish genius, we are able to open up undreamt-of treasures to the world.
It has not come so far, then, as Professor Geiger would have us believe, that we have resolved to renounce our nationality, — quite apart from the fact that that would be an impossible undertaking, for blood is thicker than water, — baptismal water too. It may be that so far there are only beginnings, — but what is decisive here is wholly the will and the feeling. Professor Geiger in particular will grant us that, he who always operates with these two. Since he does not feel himself a Jew, since he feels only pity, — he is, in his opinion, no member of the Jewish people! — And further, — when he proposes exceptional laws against us, — who wish to belong to the Jewish people, he thereby presupposes, he thereby admits, that our will alone stamps us as a separate nation!
I hold, moreover, that will and feeling are decisive only in so far as conclusions as to the truth may be drawn from their presence or absence. The existence of our people is a fact, — attested by our vitality, by our will and our feeling. The blind man may deny the light — the sun sends forth its rays. All arguing and all protesting avail nothing there, — it only attests that the opponent is blind or forcibly shuts his eyes.
Now the Professor says further:
Zionism is dangerous and pernicious.
Over this we will not now waste many more words! We possess to-day documents of probative force, — testimonies of scholars and artists of all civilised peoples, who thank us for our work, who declare that our work is proving beneficial to all mankind as to our people. We can point with pride to the fact that we have already created great works of culture, — we have quickened millions of the despairing with new hope, and we have called into being great organisations that dispense culture. In the almost 8 years of our existence the dangers must surely have shown themselves in some way. — Where are they? — Governments have negotiated with our Actions Committee as the representative of a loyal and earnest movement, — demonstrations of sympathy have reached us from all sides, — what has become of the dangers that were prophesied for us? — To a Jew, Professor Dr. Ludwig Geiger of Berlin, was reserved the glory of denouncing us as a danger, of demanding legislative measures against us. It is true, this is a danger which we certainly did not foresee, and which, given the
