Die Welt
Editorial Office and Administration: Vienna, IX., Türkenstrasse No. 9. Telephone 14.199. Published every Friday. Correspondence is to be addressed not to individual persons but to the Editorial Office or the Administration: Vienna, IX., Türkenstrasse 9. Unstamped letters will not be accepted, and manuscripts will not be returned. The editors receive visitors daily from 10 to half past 11 o'clock. Advertising rates: according to the published tariff. The advertisement section closes on Tuesday evenings. Single numbers 30 Heller.
Subscription rates: Austria-Hungary: yearly Kr. 12.—, half-yearly Kr. 6.—, quarterly Kr. 3.—. Abroad: Germany yearly Mk. 13.70, half-yearly Mk. 6.85, quarterly Mk. 3.45; England yearly Shg. 14.—, half-yearly Shg. 7.—, quarterly Shg. 3.10; Russia yearly R. 7.—, half-yearly R. 3.50, quarterly R. 1.75; Switzerland, France, Italy, Turkey, Roumania, Bulgaria, Servia, Greece, Egypt yearly Frcs. 17.—, half-yearly Frcs. 8.50, quarterly Frcs. 4.25; America yearly Doll. 3.40, half-yearly Doll. 1.70, quarterly Doll. —.85.
No. 11. | Vienna, 17 March 1905. — 10 Weadar 5665. | 9th Year.
Questions of the Day and Points of Dispute in Zionism.
By Dr. D. Pasmanik.
II.
In order that we may find our way among the whole mass of solutions to the Jewish question now being proposed — Territorialism or Palestine, colonisation on a large or a small scale, and so forth — we must take two further cardinal questions into consideration, for upon the answer to them depend the aim and the methods of Zionism.
What does Zionism aim at, and what land does it need for the fulfilment of its aims?
It may sound almost comical that one can now raise the question of what Zionism aims at. And yet the question is no idle one. In the previous article we indicated the opinion of the Achad-Haamists, according to which Zionism cannot solve the Jewish question. We must remark that this opinion has unhappily found a fairly wide currency, especially among the youngest Zionist elements. It is precisely for this reason that the socially feeling and socially thinking youth stands rather remote from us. For it is genuine Zionists who maintain it! Mr. Klausner¹) even goes so far as to declare that "the promise of the political and economic Zionists to solve the question of Jewish distress is a conventional lie." "The condition of the Jewish masses," he holds, "will improve where they are, thanks to the emancipation of the Jews. Zionism cannot solve the 'economic question of the Jewish masses,' but must solve the 'national economic question of Judaism.'" The meaning of this definition, contradictory at first sight — if it has any meaning at all — is as follows: Zionism cannot found an autonomous state for all 12 million Jews, but only for a small part of our people. The great mass remains in the Diaspora, but some tens or perhaps hundreds of thousands of the elect are to found a Jewish state with a healthy, normal differentiation of economic functions and a genuine national-Jewish culture.
Even were such a thing possible, could small groups really solve economic questions in a national sense, even then only intellectuals, or at most a few high-minded Balabatim, could warm to such a Zionism, and then it must degenerate.
A Zionism capable of life stands and falls with the mass character of its aims. Either-or: either Zionism means to solve the Jewish question in its whole extent, that is, the economic question of the Jewish masses as well, and then it will gradually win the whole Jewish people for itself; or else it means to procure felicity for an elect minority, and then it degenerates into a movement of ideologues.
Now it is plain to every thinking person that it is the purest fantasy to believe that a small group could permanently create anything national in any field whatever. This, however, we will not discuss here.
We must therefore go back to the foundations of Zionism and remember that Zionism strives for the creation of a home for the Jewish people. Whoever wishes fully to grasp the essence of Zionism must never forget the declarations which Herzl made at the Fifth Congress, when a speaker wished to restrict the Basle Programme, namely to "the majority of the Jews." Our leader then declared, amid the lively applause of the whole Congress, that Zionism strives for the creation of a secured home not for the majority of the Jews, but for the Jewish people absolutely. This also says that Zionism cannot be conceived otherwise than as a mass movement which must satisfy all the needs of that same mass.
It was precisely from the Sixth Congress onward that the obscuring of the fundamental Zionist concepts began, an obscuring that does not proceed from the cultural Zionists alone.
It was precisely from the Sixth Congress onward, too, that the pure Zion-Zionists began constantly to point out that the colonisation of a little-cultivated country, such as Palestine for example, can take place only on a small scale, that is, quite gradually, and that a colonisation of the masses is quite impossible. This is as much as to say that such a colonisation cannot relieve Jewish distress. Thus, for example, the Odessa Zion-Zionists write: "An empty territory cannot be suddenly populated. Only
¹) Luach Achiasaf, Vol. XII, p. 148. A. Pass.
