Die Welt · Vol. IX, No. 7 · 17 February 1905
2printed page
scan 2 of 20
Facsimile · scan 2 of 20
Scan of p. 2
English · AI translation, checked against the German

Page 2 — "Die Welt" — No. 7

There is no necessity to enter more closely here upon this position, but whether we turn our attention to the Jews who still dwell in Russia and Poland, or to the great majority of those who have emigrated to the West and to America, and to the position which they occupy there, we cannot look towards the future with equanimity or without anxiety.

The assertion has been made that the position of our people is a matter for philanthropy, with which a national movement has nothing to do. The constant persecution of our people, the oppression to which it is exposed, often by Jews themselves, when it makes an effort to free itself from its position, must, if it is continued, result in a serious deterioration of the raw material out of which, as we hope, the Jewish nation will be built up again. Here is matter for reflection for those who have the rebuilding of the Jewish nation at heart. Nor is the deterioration only physical and material. When life and limb are constantly threatened, the striving after a practical national existence is gradually destroyed. The immediate necessities of life stand in the first place, and when these are secured, the material advantages have thrown all higher aims into the shade. Very many of our people, when once they have attained freedom and prosperity even in a small measure, therefore cling anxiously to these personal advantages, for the past is burnt into their souls. So great is their fear of forfeiting these advantages again that they will not even consider the higher needs of their own Jewish brethren. Their greatest endeavour is to merge themselves politically and socially with other nations, and at best to have something in common with the oppressed Jews only in the human sense. These together see that the former are strong and prosper, and the ivy always clings to the oak. Can we, who strive for a rebuilding of the Jewish nation, disregard this constant impulse towards the denationalisation of the Jews?

There are many who seem to think that the very persecutions of the Jews and the position of the Jews in the world will help us to attain our goal — that the force of circumstances will compel the nations to leave Palestine to the Jews. This may well be, but I hope it is not so. I hope that Palestine will be opened to the Jews in consequence of their demand for a political existence for its own sake, and not as a place of refuge from violence and persecution.

The prospects for a new, renationalised Jewish people will be much better if the former, and not the latter, forms the prelude to the realisation of our national hopes. I say this in passing. We must, however, be constantly on our guard lest the ranks of the Zionists be recruited from those whose motives are purely philanthropic, instead of being in the first place political.

If this is admitted, it would assuredly be to the advantage of Zionism as a political movement if — supposing that this were possible — the position of our people could everywhere be so changed that they can lead a free and secure life. In such a case we could be sure that the striving after a national existence was founded only upon the highest motives of which man is capable — the wish to secure the continuance of a great historic past, in the consciousness of the possibility of a great historic future. The world would then regard our demand for a "legally recognised home" in Palestine not merely as a way of escape from bitter persecution, not merely as a means to personal security; it would see in the aims of the Zionists not merely the wish to live, but also the wish to revive the Jewish life which is hallowed in all Jewish hearts by four thousand years of attachment, bound and hallowed by a continual communion between the Jew and his God.

I will adduce a local example. Nothing would so contribute to swell the ranks of the English Zionist Federation as an outbreak of anti-Semitism in this country. Yet those who joined our cause in such circumstances would assuredly not serve it in the best sense. Unconsciously perhaps, but none the less surely, their motive would be in a certain degree unreliable. Zionists resist the legislation which is directed against the alien immigrants, because in their view it has an anti-Semitic tendency, and do not consider whether some new adherents might not be won for the Zionist societies by the passing of such laws. They know that such laws bring hardship upon Jews who are fleeing from persecution, and must entail further degradation for them, and they hold that they are a forerunner of anti-Semitism; in comparison with this, growing support of the Zionist societies signifies nothing.

It is therefore assuredly unjust to say that the East African scheme is of no legitimate interest to Zionism, since it does not concern Palestine. A magnificent scheme for a Jewish settlement of 5000 square miles, where by degrees many thousands of Jews can settle, must in and for itself possess the liveliest interest for those who, like the Zionists, have undertaken to care for the general raising of the condition of the Jews, as inseparably bound up with their revival and renationalisation. Now when such a proposal is made, not for a part of our people which finds itself in the country from which the proposal proceeded, but for the Jewish people as a whole, it would be madness if the Zionists were to reject this first recognition on the part of a great Power that the Jews are entitled to regard themselves as a people, as a trifle deserving of no attention. Yet the offer of the English Government makes still greater concessions to the Zionists, in that it was accompanied by the promise of an autonomy through which the settlement would be permanently recognised as a Jewish one. That the territory to which these proposals relate is not Palestine, and that in consequence it can never become a Jewish State, apart from other circumstances, may be an excellent reason — and undoubtedly it is — for the Zionists to refuse to undertake the work in East Africa alone, as a Zionist organisation. They cannot, however, logically either disregard the East African offer or refuse to perform their share of the work. We have here not only the opportunity of saving thousands of Jews from destruction, of raising their condition, and in many respects of mitigating the critical position of the Jew in the world, but also of justifying the contention of the Zionists that only colonisation on a large scale, which brings with it the political existence of the Jews, to which all Jews and not merely a part of them shall have access, can contribute to the raising of the condition of the Jewish people. It