Die Welt · Vol. IX, No. 5 · 3 February 1905
7printed page
scan 7 of 20
Facsimile · scan 7 of 20
Scan of p. 7
English · AI translation, checked against the German

No. 5 — "Die ✡ Welt" — Page 7

(continued from page 6)

… a few individual examples: Some memorandum concerning our movement has to be presented to some politically influential man. It is quite superfluous to bear the title of President of the A.-C. in order to acquit oneself of this mission. This person will be a member of the diplomatic section and appears in the given case as representative of the A.-C., that is, of the whole Zionist organization. Negotiations have, for example, to be conducted with some great colonization society concerning joint work in Palestine. It is quite superfluous to be President of the A.-C. in order to conduct these negotiations. The member of the Palestine section best fitted for it will conduct these negotiations in the name of the A.-C., that is, of the whole Zionist party. Exactly so must it be with the work of the other sections also. But all these labours will be good and systematic only if, through the mediation of the members of the Bureau, they are united and made to work into one another. Otherwise complete disorder will set in. I must repeat once more that these sections work independently in common with the Secretariat. They receive merely general directives from the Greater A.-C., that is, from the united assembly of the members of all sections, and must render to it an exactly detailed report of their stewardship, without concealing even the least thing, and that not less than once every half-year (for this purpose a conference is convened).

Our centre or Bureau, the residence of the members of our Secretariat, must cease to wander about in the wide world, and must have a seat fixed once and for all. The Jewish people has already grown weary to disgust of wandering about in the wide world, and wishes at last to build a fixed dwelling-place for itself, and our organization must do the same. If our centre or Bureau, with the death or the retirement of this or that active force, is transferred from one point of the earth to another, it loses stability and permanence. At least one point of the earth's surface we must have, even before our rebirth in Palestine, towards which all Zionists of the globe can direct their gaze, as to the spot where Jewish freedom is being forged. Our white-and-blue flag must wave not once in three years, during the Congress, but 365 days in the year at one fixed place, and that can only be Basle, the place of our traditions. All international movements for freedom have their permanent bureau in international Switzerland. Let our politicians, who are so much in favour of the transfer of the centre to London, put to themselves the question what would have happened if, after the Hull incident, a war had broken out between England and Russia; would even a single Russian Zionist then be in a position to send his shekel to London? And we do hope that our movement will grow and will draw upon itself the serious attention of all governments. We must therefore be prepared for all possible political combinations.

(Conclusion follows.)


A Critical Voice on Zionism.

Properly speaking I ought at once to correct myself: critical in the true meaning of the word the utterance of the Berlin University professor and representative of the Jewish community in Berlin, Dr. Ludwig Geiger, is not. It is merely a vague effusion of feeling, which in political life appears of no account, for politics leaves feelings and personal moods aside. There facts decide. It is sometimes very good and instructive to read the "Kölnische Zeitung"; not on account of the coloured presentation of the world's events, but: here and there one comes upon a Jewish man of letters who has his outpourings on "German Literature and Zionism" printed here — not, be it noted, in a Jewish paper.

After an introduction, in the manner of a history of civilization, on the motif "Jew" in German literature, the author arrives at last at the most modern literary current among the Jews: Zionism. Short, objectively framed criticisms of Herzl's "Das neue Ghetto" and Nordau's "Doktor Kohn" follow. Prof. Geiger occupies himself quite thoroughly with the work "Das neue Jerusalem," which lately appeared anonymously, in order finally to pass utter condemnation upon Zionism — be it well understood, the political, not its literary emanations. It is, to be sure, a peculiar thing to construct what is Zionist — like life in general — out of literature.

I believe that there will not be over-many who doubt the literary judgment of Prof. Geiger, but very many will laugh at the politician Geiger, especially when they read the following outpourings ("Kölnische Ztg. First Supplement No. 77). There stands word for word the following: "My purpose is only to point to it as a typical phenomenon. Zionism is as dangerous to Germanism as Social Democracy and Ultramontanism. It has something of both: of the former the radicalism, of the latter the looking beyond, the longing for a fatherland other than that which belongs to him by language and character. Certainly Social Democracy and Ultramontanism can work far more mischief, because their adherents are numbered by millions, but Zionism too, if the sensible do not call a halt, can bring its army up to hundreds of thousands. As, therefore, against Ultramontane works of history and Social Democratic doctrines, so too must warning be given against the Zionist sham wisdom. Let the German Jew who has a voice in German literature recognize, as he has been accustomed to do for 1½ centuries, only in Germany his fatherland, only in the German language his mother tongue; let him call only the German people his own, and let only the future of this nation be and remain that upon which his hope hangs. Every desire to form a people with his brethren in faith outside Germany is, quite apart from its impracticability and from the gross ingratitude towards the nation in whose midst he lives, a delusion; for the German Jew is by his national character a German, and Zion is for him the land of the past, not of the future."*)

A commentary is in this case wholly superfluous. Only one small reminiscence may be permitted: last year Prof. Geiger delivered at the Berlin Alma mater a one-hour course of lectures on "The Jews in German Literature." In the introductory lecture he touched in similar words upon the Zionist movement. The consequence was scenes of uproar, whereupon in the next following hour Prof. Geiger replied that he had not the intention of holding a course of disputation, and begged, to him, as he also umge

*) We remark that we share these opinions of the author only in so far as he has in view a ramification of Zionism directed against Germanism. Concerning the Zionist endeavours as such we have repeatedly expressed our dissenting view. (Note of the editors of the "Kölnische Zeitung.")