Page 6. — "Die Welt" — No. 5
(continued from page 5)
… will bring great benefit to the country. That in founding the farm we shall take the experiences of Sedschera into account need hardly be specially said.
(Conclusion follows.)
Our Organization.
By M. Ussischkin.
II.
§ 9. The members of the A.-C. elect from their midst three men, who form the Bureau or Secretariat of the A.-C. and who must reside permanently in Basle.
§ 10. The remaining 20 members of the A.-C. are divided into 4 sections of 5 members each (the Palestine Commission, the diplomatic, the financial and the agitation commission). These sections, together with the Secretariat, discharge the duties laid upon them through the united assembly of all members of the A.-C.
These two paragraphs require the most thorough elucidation, because in them lies the centre of gravity of the alteration of our statute of organization. I propose a reform which breaks radically with our whole past régime. This reform consists in the following: A. The absence of a President of the A.-C. B. The division of labour into sections. C. The permanence of the seat of the Central Bureau. D. The remuneration of some members of the A.-C. But these reforms have sprung from a vital necessity: since the death of Herzl one hears in the ranks of Zionists and non-Zionists only one and the same question: "Who will be the successor?" that is to say: "Who will be President of the A.-C.?" Now if we consider the whole composition of all the members of our organization, there can be but one single answer: No one. One has a name, but possesses no organizing talents whatever and no energy; the second possesses energy — but he lacks the name and the intelligence necessary for the leader in ideas; the third has other positive qualities, but is wanting in strength of will and in vigour; the fourth lacks the outward polish, the manners of the great world and the knowledge of languages which are necessary for representatives of a political party. In a word, the man whom we need we have not in the party, and one standing outside it we cannot take. Such a man, if he exists, must come to us of himself, as Herzl too came to us seven years ago, and then it will not be we who elect him, but he himself will take the movement mightily into his hand. But if we elect as President of the A.-C., as official representative of the party, a man who does not possess all the necessary qualities, then this man will either do nothing at all, or he will do it very badly, or he will be a chessman in the hands of others. This post of President of the A.-C. will bring the cause no benefit, but only harm, for the post which the first President filled with so much splendour and honour will have many pretenders, and I fear that at our Congresses the historical scenes of the times of the Diadochi after the death of Alexander the Great will be repeated. It is not splendour and representation that we need now, but an energetic and efficient working body, for we must confess to ourselves that in the course of seven years there was almost no work at all at the centre. With the exception of the purely diplomatic work, which was exclusively the affair of Doctor Herzl, everything else presents a very unedifying picture. Whoever has attentively followed the criticism of the activity of the Smaller A.-C. at all the Congresses knows that the decided question was always put: "What has the Smaller A.-C. done?", and never was a satisfactory answer received. The Bank was created, on the one hand by the drafting and registration of the statute in London, and on the other by the sale of its shares. The second part of the work was accomplished by the general Zionist organization, but the first was done by the centre, and very badly indeed. This whole Smaller A.-C., together with the Committee of Five, the Bank directors, jurisconsult, commissions, etc., worked out a statute which in its clumsiness and confusion has not its like; they altered, illegally and wantonly, the fundamental statute concerning the place of the Bank's activity, and the revision of a whole series of paragraphs of the Bank statute is now on the order of the day. The registration of the shares and the first working years of the Bank were so unskilful, so confused, that had not an outsider (Levontin) come to London, the disentanglement would not have been so easy. How much money was spent, without bringing anything in, on conferences of the directors, of the Board of Supervision, of the jurisconsults and the like? It is three years since the Congress founded the National Fund. A year earlier its statutes were drawn up, a whole series of Fund commissions existed, conferences and deliberations of these commissions took place, and the statutes of the Fund are to-day still in the same position as four years ago. Of the commissions for culture and colonization all indeed know that they are mere fictions. An exception is formed by the Palestine Commission, which was elected at the 6th Congress and has accomplished something in the last year. Who is to blame for all this? Vienna as a city, as some suppose, or the composition of the Smaller A.-C., as others maintain? Neither the one nor the other, I answer — the blame lies directly with our organization. Far too clumsy and complicated is our apparatus of organization (the Greater A.-C., the Smaller A.-C., the Board of Supervision, the Committee of Five, the members of various commissions, the directors, governors, etc., etc.). On the other hand we had not a single man who devoted himself wholly and entirely to the cause and did not occupy himself with it merely among other things, who had specialized, who had explored to the bottom this or that side of our national movement. (I do not, of course, speak of Herzl.) Hence everything was done by fits and starts, on the inspiration of the minute, superficially. Wherever under such conditions the future centre may be, and of whatever men it may be composed — the results will still remain the same. What must now be created is not only a brilliant representation, but also an efficient working body, which shall devote itself wholly and entirely to the people's cause.
Our work in the future I picture to myself in the following form. The Greater A.-C., at its first sitting after the Congress, works out general directives for all sides of our programme and hands over each part of the work to the section concerned, the three members of the Bureau or Secretariat being at the same time members of all four sections. They study and prepare every question, and in joint consultation with the members of each section it is decided who carries out this or that piece of work. Let us take
