Die Welt · Vol. VIII, No. 48 · 25 November 1904
3printed page
scan 3 of 20

No. 48. — "Die Welt" — Page 3.

(continued from page 2)

…period, as regards external policy, will be devoted solely to the maintenance and consolidation of what has already been created.

With this, to be sure, it is openly declared that we must be prepared for a delay in our approach to the ultimate Zionist goal, unless we find other paths that lead us towards it more rapidly. For the diminution and delay of external political work, however, we have also to seek a substitute in another direction: the most fruitful stimuli which the masses received for internal propaganda and work from Herzl's diplomatic activity and from its successes will fall away, and in order to hold and occupy our ranks we shall have to strike out upon new paths. What are these new paths? It must first be said: the way we mean to go must not run backwards; we do not wish to arrive at a standpoint with whose rejection the development of the mighty movement of modern Zionism began; we cannot go back to simple small-scale colonisation, even if we would. One cannot seize the spokes of a development that accomplishes itself with the right and the vehemence of a force of nature. The wheel of history would simply pass over us, were we to try to stop it. Zionism has once for all outgrown the "old" method. We rather take up, while tenaciously holding fast to the programmatic foundations of Zionism, the work which we had neglected in recent years, and which under Herzl we might also neglect, because his call would have summoned us back to it in good time. We have to prepare our people and its ancient land for their future destinies. Perhaps to-day, now that Herzl has accomplished the enlightenment of the decisive political factors concerning our aims, the execution also lies in this preparation.

In one direction a beginning has already been made. The economic exploration and opening-up of Palestine is being carried out by the plenipotentiaries appointed by Zionism in a manner that must arouse great satisfaction. But let no one disturb this work, which is proceeding by a strictly scientific and therefore assuredly promising method, by impatient urging. That would be the gravest offence of which we could be guilty. Let us be content if the Palestine work in the next few years exhaustively investigates the economic and agricultural conditions of the country, creates the socio-political foundations of the best possible forms of settlement, and gives the present Jewish inhabitants of Palestine orderly economic conditions. We shall surely all be at our posts when it is a matter of mobilising men and means for these purposes.

Just at the right time there opens before us the prospect of events which promise to set the work of preparation in lively motion. I mean the question of emigration. It must be greeted with unreserved satisfaction that the question of emigration, which within our movement as well as in other Jewish bodies was for long years a subject of theoretical discussion, is about to advance into the stage of practical organisation. The material of facts so far available was communicated in the last number of "Die Welt." The theses of the Deutscher Hilfsverein will seem very meagre to many. But it is a beginning which carries within itself the conditions of further development. The organisation of Jewish migration, as it is shortly to be inaugurated at Frankfort, may become the foundation for a thorough transformation of the Jewish situation; if this problem of emigration is taken in hand in the right way, it may become the problem of a home in our sense. What is next to be initiated is a supervision of emigration and an enlightenment of the emigrants from country to country, and a central office from which all information concerning emigration can be obtained. In the whole text of the Nathan theses only the decentralisation demanded is, from our standpoint, open to objection. Dr. Werner, in his article "On Jewish Migration," has remarked what was needful on this point from the Zionist standpoint. It seems certain to me, however, that decentralisation here is meant only in contrast to the massing of emigrants in the great centres, such as New York. For the rest, the constitutions planned will find our approval — but only if we may regard them as a beginning, as an introduction to something greater. That this something greater, however, will and must come is grounded, as I have said, in the beginning itself. For the organs of the emigration institution, if they mean to fulfil the tasks assigned to them in the theses, will be compelled to go forward step by step both in the countries of emigration and in those of immigration. A thorough study of the conditions of Jewry in the countries of emigration will be the next consequence, and as the result of this study the recognition will force itself upon them that a special preparation of the emigrants, and in particular of the growing youth, to make them "people fit for emigration" — for above all, fortunately, agricultural settlement is contemplated*) — is needful. The examination of the opportunities for immigration will therefore conclude with the recognition that, besides America and the regions of immigration hitherto preferred, other tracts of country, especially in the East, must be opened up. Thus in the plan, which now looks purely businesslike and sober, there lie concealed possibilities which must awaken our Zionist interest. For the realisation of these possibilities our co-operation is needed, which, indeed, is also made welcome.

Now there arises for us, to be sure, the question: Shall we work together with the Jewish bodies concerned in the problem of emigration, since these approach the question from other points of view and perhaps with other intentions than we Zionists? I confess that I answer this question in the affirmative not only because the cause itself — which at worst means only an alleviation of the lot of many unfortunates, but at best paves the way to a solution of the Jewish question as a whole approaching our programme — must attract us, but also because at this moment I hold co-operation with the great Jewish bodies to be very desirable.

Herzl's death obliges us in this point too to a revision of our method of action. Hitherto we have fought these bodies, because their work, according to our most sacred conviction, often ran counter to the true vital interests of the Jewish people. We made our standpoint clear to them; we could not convince them of the logic and the necessity of our movement. One thing, however, we knew: that when the moment should have come at which their help would hardly have been dispensable for the attainment of our ultimate goal, the doors leading to the board-rooms would not have remained closed any longer to our leader Herzl, before whom even secret diplomatic and ministerial cabinets willingly opened. After Herzl's death we do well to seize the first opportunity now offering to work together with those bodies for the welfare of our people without surrendering even the smallest tittle of our programme — all the more so as the first stage of our attitude towards these organisations may now confidently be regarded as closed. We have explained our intentions and aims to them plainly and clearly; they can no longer be in doubt about them


*) Unfortunately this is not so certain as the author appears to assume. The Editors.