Die Welt · Vol. VIII, No. 48 · 25 November 1904
2printed page
scan 2 of 20

Page 2. — "Die Welt" — No. 48.

(continued from page 1)

…Jew), a philologist by training. The Swiss Emigration Bureau is among the best-conducted institutions of its kind.

As to the further purposes of the institution, I conceive them as follows:

a) Centralisation of travelling relief in the sense indicated;

b) Supervision of the management, the local committee and the local agents;

c) Expert opinion — for the use of the Central Committee — on questions of principle concerning emigration;

d) Supervision of publications and advertisements concerning emigration;

e) Collection of statistical material, as well as of material concerning forwarding agencies, railway and steamship connections, transport, travel and other circumstances bearing thereon;

f) Compilation of those communications which are intended for publication;

g) Dealings with the emigration and port authorities, the relief societies and private persons for the purpose of safeguarding the interests of the emigrants;

h) Collection of the legislative enactments concerning emigration, of the consular and other reports bearing on the subject, of scientific reports on the conditions of the countries of immigration under consideration, of the most important literature on emigration, and the like;

i) Establishment and maintenance of connections with communities, societies and private persons for the purpose of preventing heedless emigration and of suitably equipping needy persons and families resolved upon a purposeful emigration;

k) Giving of advice, information and recommendations to emigrants where a request for them is made;

l) Accompanying of individual emigrant trains as far as the port of embarkation; inspection of the lodging-houses for emigrants there and of the ships' arrangements; personal dealings with the ships' management and the transport companies.

I believe I may venture these remarks, inasmuch as I have taken the organisation of the Swiss Emigration Bureau as the basis of my discussion.


On the Question of Organisation.

New Paths.

By Dr. Julius Moses - Mannheim.

It appears in a high degree astonishing that, in the anxious situation which Herzl's death has created, all cares, discussions and proposals for the future seem to turn upon one point only: "How shall the future leadership of the Organisation be constituted?" The incomparably more significant vital question of our movement: "How shall the future activity of Zionism and of its leadership be constituted?" meets with only a scant and meagre interest. It is true, indeed, that the paralysing effect of the heavy blow of fate which has struck us upon our free thought and deliberation has not yet been overcome; but we must rouse ourselves by force and at least attempt to struggle through to a clear conception of the content of future Zionist work.

In drawing up the schemes of organisation with which the Zionist press is now filled, men have frequently started from an examination of the question whether the former form of the supreme leadership was cut directly to the person of Herzl, or whether it can lay claim to validity under altered circumstances as well. The determination of a programme of activity, too, may perhaps suitably be introduced by the consideration whether the method of action of Zionism, which was inaugurated before and under Herzl, was possible only with him, or can and should be continued without him.

The most salient characteristic of Herzl's Zionist activity was its political and diplomatic direction. But it is a boundless exaggeration to say that Herzl's Zionism was nothing but diplomatism. To his initiative we owe the most important institutions of our Organisation, to his suggestion the most fruitful ideas of our internal work. It was he who, in the words: "We are organising Jewry for its future destinies," formulated the programme for the internal work of the present, who gave out the momentous watchword for the struggle for the community councils. It is naturally far from our intention to convince those who never tire of conjuring up again and again the struggle against the spectre of Herzl's one-sided diplomatism of the injustice of their attacks by dissecting Herzl's mighty intellectual labour in the service of Zionism and displaying it neatly arranged in compartments.

This much is true, indeed: he could not carry out in his own person everything that was needful, and he therefore took upon himself above all that work which he alone could carry out by virtue of a brilliant special gift, and to which the successes achieved ever anew gave him warrant.

The suggestive power of his personality, in which the Jewish people saw the idea of Zionism gloriously embodied, brought it about that the activity to which the leader himself tirelessly devoted himself claimed the chief share of the interest of the Zionist masses. That was fortunate. Through it the Zionists learned to think politically and turned away from that tendency which delights in turning the theories over and over again, in narrow circles of disputation, in petty intellectual warfare. It is also false when it is lately asserted that through diplomatism the forces awakened by Herzl himself in the masses and in individuals withered away again. The spectacle of Herzl's political and diplomatic activity and successes rather kindled continually new latent forces: for nothing was more fitted to give the individual and the masses a purpose in life and a life's work than the consciousness that, by enlisting one's own whole personality in the circle of men and ideas of Zionism, one could strengthen the authority on the ground of which Herzl was able to raise the postulate of a publicly and legally secured home for the Jewish people.

Herzl is dead. But the Basle Programme has remained, which in its last clause demands the preparatory steps towards obtaining the consent of governments necessary to attain the aim of Zionism. Every attack upon this point would founder upon the political insight which our people has attained under Herzl's leadership. For the near future, to be sure, only a reserved pace in carrying out the said clause of the programme is to be expected. No other Zionist work is so dependent upon a quite particular qualification of the individual leader as the diplomatic and political. Although Herzl created relations and tied threads which were not destroyed by his death, progress in this field depends essentially upon whether and when a new leader arises for the Jewish people who, with Herzl's skill, can avoid and overcome the dangers of the thorny path of politics. And were such a man among us even to-day, he would venture to enter upon Herzl's inheritance and continue his work only after a sufficiently long time of trial and preparation. Thus, in all likelihood, the next