Die Welt · Vol. VIII, No. 35 · 26 August 1904
10printed page
scan 10 of 20
Facsimile · scan 10 of 20
Scan of p. 10
English · AI translation, checked against the German

Page 10. — "Die Welt" — No. 35.

(continued from page 9)

…recognizes, and which supports the Zionist organization. 2. The purposes of the "Misrachi" are: to spread political and practical Zionism; to watch that no subject and no person alien to practical or political Zionism be admitted to the Zionist platforms or Congresses; to watch that in the official work and in the final aims of the Zionist movement no deed be committed and no declaration be made that contradicts the spirit of our religion or of our Law; to watch that no person, however eminent, be recognized as an official leader of Zionism or as a representative of Zionist principles if his public utterances and actions stand in opposition to our religion and to the aims of Zionism; to ensure that Jewish education be placed upon the basis of the Jewish religion; and to see to it that all orthodox Zionists be united into one organized body.

Mr. Suwalski and Rev. Wasserzug opposed the expression "persons" in the resolution, and held that the Misrachist party wished to combat not persons but principles. And it would be folly to rob Zionism of its best and liberal-minded men.

The resolution was adopted by the meeting with this amendment.

The Goal of Liberalism.*)

No cause for agitation; the old story, which we lived through in a fresh edition when Dr. Elias Jacob of Lemberg gave us the well-meant counsel — it was in the middle of July — to submerge, to submerge in the sea of oblivion; was a Polish Bocher, ran away from the Cheder, and now deals in assimilation. A warming-over of Rathenau's cabbage, which we spurned two years ago already, has grown no richer for having been scalded with philosophical deductions.

With philosophical cobwebs one cannot catch a fly, much less ensnare Judaism. Such solvers of the Jewish Question have never yet found credence in Israel. Even thinkers of the heaviest calibre, such as Aristobulus and Philo, had to put up with the reproach of being panderers of religion from self-respecting Jews. For Dr. Jacob of Lemberg it should accordingly be a flattery if, on account of his cry "Submerge!", we honour him with this title.

It is not remarkable that it is precisely runaway Polish Bachurim, whose unedifying youthful upbringing drives them headlong from one extreme to the other, who arrive at the wicked or the crazy idea of turning their backs upon their kinsmen. But that they should afterwards feel the irresistible urge to bless their suffering kinsmen too with their beatifying idea, should then presume to proclaim to their astonished contemporaries their view of the world, by which no wise man may neglect to form himself, nay, should agitate in the full glare of publicity for their great plan for the salvation of the fatherland, in order then to await immortality in all confidence — all this is harder to understand.

But there was no cause for agitation on our part. We know that the author of the "submerging" article is entirely right in his notion of the essence of Judaism. He possesses the courage of consistency, and the fine faculty of thinking the ideas of the Jewish-Protestant Reform through to the end — a gift which the Reformers do not usually possess.

To be sure, the fine plan is neither new nor original, and suffers from the great defect of being put forward, in our fast-living age, about a quarter of a century too late. What upheaval has meanwhile taken place in the bosom of Jewry, Dr. Jacob overlooks with enviable nonchalance. He

*) Vide "Die Welt" No. 34.

proves to us with irrefutable philosophy that we must submerge, and keeps silent to us in seven languages as to how we can submerge. He does not tell us his

"New Method, Whereby the Jews of every station Are brought from life to death."

Let it not be objected that history, with iron logic, preaches the readiness of the one party to enter into a settlement in the assimilation "suit"; that half the bargain was already struck: the Jews were willing. This objection would be unfounded; for the facts offend against his theory; but the theory is correct, as he has proved; therefore the facts must be false. It is most astonishing how close occupation with philosophy can darken the free view of the world. The history of his own time, lived through by himself, has not taught him the recognition that the demand for the baptismal font which he has devised has, like all extravagant illusions, long since been shattered against the rough walls of reality. More than forty years have already passed since M. Hess could write to Dr. Geiger, in an open letter, the words which even then signified a truth: "Verily, if any swindle has gone bankrupt, it is the Reform swindle." If, then, a proposal is renewed to-day whose fundamental condition is the "Reform swindle," there is no cause for agitation on our part.

Meanwhile the affair has acquired a piquant flavour through the person of the new prophet, so that it has gained a symptomatic significance for us. The author is supposed to be an official of the Jewish community of Berlin who enjoys protection in high places.**) Rightly, therefore, has the "General-Anzeiger" made it its task to compel the protectors and fosterers of such views, the representatives of the Berlin community, to an unreserved declaration, so that it might be made known to the Jewish people openly and unambiguously, by a shining example, whither Liberalism leads us. It is to be set before the eyes of the Jewish public what is being planned for the future of Judaism in the leading circles of the stronghold of Liberalism, in Berlin!

Occurrences such as this, that a Jewish official summons in plain words to apostasy, to flight from Judaism, must startle even the most indifferent out of their sluggish repose. The tough passive resistance, which consisted in a general don't-care attitude toward everything Jewish, must be broken after such rousing facts. Such an exposure will burn into the consciousness even of the Liberal philistine, whose contemplative existence no scruple or doubt has hitherto disturbed, the lesson that a marrowless and lame-loined Liberalism cannot undertake the representation of Judaism. This cry of longing, which lights up the whole situation as with a flash of lightning, will be the smouldering tinder that gradually seizes upon the rotten conditions in Jewish communal life and makes them wither, until they are swept away without effort by the primal force of the Zionist popular movement.

Regarded from this side, the Jacob case has its deep meaning, and we will gladly welcome its symptomatic significance. Not as though we paid him our respect: of all the fine fellows who foul their own nest, the renegade is the most hateful to us. But that was not our concern here. We wished only to fix the moment at which we an example of the self-

**) The supposition is correct. The Editor.