Die Welt · Vol. VIII, No. 20 · 13 May 1904
4printed page
scan 4 of 20
Facsimile · scan 4 of 20
Scan of p. 4
English · AI translation, checked against the German

Page 4 — "Die Welt" — No. 20

(continued from page 3)

…we, then, such cowards as we seem? No; we have bravely shed our blood in every land, we have proved our courage on every battlefield. But for whom and for what have we fought? Not for ourselves, but for our adopted country — for England, where we are raising a monument to the Jewish soldiers who fell in the Boer War at the very moment when England is setting about destroying the work of Jewish emancipation. We fight for Russia, for Roumania, for Germany, where no Jewish soldier, however brave and gifted, can rise to be an officer. Yet it has been said of us that we are no true patriots towards these countries. Far from it; our patriotism is positively pathetic! When I was in Spain a short while ago, I met a Jew living in Madrid who told me that he had travelled about among the Roumanian Jews. He happened to have in his pocket a Spanish illustrated paper with the portrait of Alfonso, the young King of Spain. The Roumanian Jews noticed the picture. "Why, that is our King!" they cried. More than four hundred years they have been gone from Spain; they were cruelly driven out of it with fire and sword, and still they preserved the memory of the land that once sheltered them, still they remained loyal and devoted to the King of Spain. This truly proves what a wonderful capacity for patriotism we Jews possess; and how foolish is the nation that spurns the treasure of our love! What has become of Spain since she freed herself of the Jews?

I do not believe for a moment that we could win our rights by physical force. Fighting is useless, except in actual riots, and in that case I believe — though I may perhaps be blamed for it — that it is a disgrace for a large Jewish population to go like sheep to the slaughter, the more so as we have seen that the Russian Jews know the use of the rifle. I have been told that it is easy for one far away in England to talk big; he does not live in a country where the soldiery itself is ready to shoot him down. But the England of seven centuries ago was like the Russia of to-day, and yet, when the English Jews were attacked, they fought like men, and the defence of York Castle in the year 1190 is one of the most heroic episodes in our history. For six days the Jews of York withstood the assault in the castle, and when their provisions were at an end, most of them killed one another, and chose rather to be baptised in their own blood than in the holy water of the Church. "We must prefer a glorious death to a shameful life," said the Rabbi, and the Parness himself gave him his knife.

But except in the case of a "pogrom" or a riot, physical combat will not serve our cause. It is absolutely impossible for us to organise ourselves. Even a Jewish Napoleon could not make a military power out of us. But the moral struggle remains to us: mutual help, the power of money rightly applied, the power of the mind. In every country we have men with brains and men with millions. The Zionist movement calls them all to union, so that we may illustrate the old moral of Aesop, that a single rod may be broken, but a bundle of rods can defy a giant.

Zionism has a gulf in Jewish life to fill. We have tried to live without a Jewish policy, each little group caring only for itself. It is as though the Japanese fleet were to put to sea without a plan and every ship be left to itself. Zionism offers us a plan for what we should do with our wandering masses: its name is the word so dear to our Board of Guardians — repatriation. But not to the step-fatherlands Russia and Roumania,

but to the true Jewish fatherland — Palestine. But this plan is no easy one — no easier than the task of any other country. Why should the Jews alone expect roast chickens — and kosher ones at that — to fall from heaven into their mouths?

The Zionist movement falls into five stages, which must be passed through before one can speak of success. The first stage is the organisation of the Jews and of the financial machinery. The second is the opening of the door of Palestine and the obtaining of a publicly and legally secured territory in our old land. The third stage is the successful establishment of this home, the agricultural, industrial and commercial regeneration of Palestine. When I said that the day on which we obtain Palestine would be the most terrible, though also the most joyful, day of our movement, I meant that on that day we shall enter upon the third stage; we shall then be put to the test, to see whether we really have the men and the material to build our own home, and we shall then have to convert all our fine speeches into deeds, as bank-notes must be exchanged for gold. The fourth stage, after the happy establishment of the home and the weeding out of many of our faults in the course of the work, is the raising of our commonwealth to a model land, with the wisest and justest solutions of social questions, so far as that shall be possible. For our land cannot be merely a State among States. Moses built the Jewish State upon right and justice, and however much the edifice may be altered, the foundation can never be changed. The fifth stage of Zionism is the fulfilment of the Jewish mission: to reveal to the world the social solutions and the ideals of right which have been developed by the spiritual genius of our race. In vain do we look about the whole world for a people fit for these tasks. There is still opportunity, that the law may go forth from Zion and the word of the Lord from Jerusalem."

Mr. Zangwill then came to speak of the East Africa project, the controversy concerning it, and the results of the Vienna Conference. He held that we still stand on the same spot and that nothing in the matter has been changed. He then polemised against the statements of individual members of the Conference, Messrs. Ussischkin, Jacobsohn and Tschlenow, and declared that he adhered to his standpoint on the East Africa question, which is summed up in the words that in any case one "must keep the bird in the hand," and that he would consider the rejection of the East Africa project a grave error, never to be made good. He then turned in sharp terms against the policy of the Ica, which stands passively by in the face of ever-growing Jewish distress without undertaking anything. It was high time, he thought, that it should be ashamed to bear the name "Jewish." For the recently published document of Baron Hirsch has proved that he could by no means have been an opponent of Jewish concentration, of Zionism. Why, then, does the Ica not follow the spirit of its founder's statutes? After this biting and telling remark he closed with the following words:

"Ladies and Gentlemen! I have honestly endeavoured to set before you the state of our movement. I do not give myself up to the illusions of our Russian friends. But neither do I despair. Our progress has been slow, but sure. Zionism has now penetrated into the West End Synagogue — the last stronghold of narrow-mindedness — and even the Chief Rabbi is beginning to regard it not without sympathy. The Jewish national idea appeals to many to whom Palestine is a matter of indifference, while Jewish colonisation in East Africa has won the goodwill of almost all Israel. These are no small struggles, although we