No. 20 — "Die Welt" — Page 3
(continued from page 2)
…uld happen if the Jews were permitted to take part freely in English life — things almost as bad as those my friend Lucien Wolf fears will come to pass should the Jews be permitted to found a colony in East Africa. One of the reasons enumerated in the pamphlet is the accusation that the Jews sacrifice a Christian child at the feast of Passover. If this absurd lie still found credence in England two centuries ago, we must not wonder that in barbarous lands it still achieves its deadly success. There is a passage from a fine old English poem — Drayton's "Polyolbion" — of the year 1622, a century before the appearance of this pamphlet, at a time when there were no Jews in England, which contains a right view of alien immigration. The passage refers, namely, to the Dutch immigrants who settled in Norwich:
"To the industrious Dutch that friendly place, Who excel in labour and in the crafts of art, They who seek refuge here, and eke out their lives there, Maintain themselves by hard toil where Englishmen oft die, They feed on roots and husks, sparing sheep and ox, And live so temperately, are no gluttons, as we are."
That was the magnanimous British view. The natives of Norwich did not complain that the Dutch took the bread — or the beer — out of their mouths. The truth is rather this, that no stranger can take a step in a country without having rendered it a service. The Jewish immigrants do not stand lower than the Englishmen whom they are said to displace; they are a more cultivated element. The poor Jews of Whitechapel are superior to the Christians of Whitechapel in the same measure in which the rich Christians of Belgravia are superior to the rich Jews of Belgravia.
The Alien Bill nevertheless proposes to exclude, not the respectable, industrious alien, but the incapable and the imbecile. How this measure could diminish competition, the Government does not explain. The incapable and the imbecile certainly cannot get on in England — except in Parliament. If the British lion is hungry because the Lion of Judah comes hunting in his preserve, what avails it to let in all the young and strong lions and to exclude merely the poor, toothless creatures? The danger of the Alien Bill arises not from any benefit it will bring England, but from its uselessness. What will the next step be? Perhaps that of excluding all the industrious, of closing our gates to Jewish immigrants altogether?
It is true that a great part of English Jews still remain here in happiness and in honour. But so long as a single Jew suffers merely because he is a Jew, so long does a stain remain upon Jewish honour, a cloud over Jewish happiness. And are we ourselves in England really so free and independent as we believe ourselves to be? There is, for example, Mr. Lucien Wolf, who fancies himself the flower of Englishmen. Well, when Mr. Wolf flattered Dr. Herzl by imitating his visit to Herr von Plehwe, even the Foreign Office had difficulty in getting Mr. Wolf into Russia. Imagine what an outcry would have been raised if real Englishmen were systematically forbidden entry into Russia! And Mr. Wolf nevertheless still believes that he and his generation are fully emancipated Britons, "who rule the waves and never will be slaves." In general politics Mr. Wolf is a thinker; in Jewish politics a coward. England is, taken all in all, the most Quixotic of all countries, yet has been guided predominantly by her own interest. Poor aliens must be removed from London, but in South Africa, where labour is needed — ah! there it is another story! Poor aliens must now be imported — the more pigtails, the merrier.
The Chinese believe that there is a bird — a phoenix — so good that it neither picks up a living insect nor harms a growing plant. But it has not been seen since the days of Confucius. Such a phoenix among the nations, a people so perfectly right-eous, may perhaps exist beyond the river Samlatyon; it has never yet been discovered. Flickers of righteousness all nations have, to be sure; the sense of justice is strongest when one's neighbour has done something wrong. England accuses France over the Dreyfus affair, France does the same to England over the Boer War, America accuses Russia over Kishineff, Russia holds up to America the burning of Negroes. There is indeed in every country a righteous minority that sees the beam in its own eye, an honest party that desires justice throughout the world, but it is still too weak to make its way in the world. We Jews, however, cannot wait for the slow magnanimity of others. "If I am not for myself," said Hillel, "who then?" The nations have their own affairs. Dr. Herzl told us that Russia had promised to help us with Turkey. But Russia has other cares now. America was indignant at the horrors of Kishineff, but now she is fully occupied with the approaching presidential election. All the more reason, perhaps, to make use of the spark of righteousness — such as England's offer of the East African territory is — before it dies out. But we must not be dependent upon others; we cannot always wait, like beggars at a banquet, for the crumbs upon the floor.
Our great blunder was that we tried to live in a world of war without any means of protection. But the law of life demands that everything which cannot defend itself shall be rooted out. Look about you upon creation and see whether any other creature — whether man or beast, fish or bird — is quite so helpless as the Jew. But I had forgotten that Nature has given yet other means of protection. Some creatures cannot fight — they have neither claws nor teeth — they offer passive resistance. This mode of defence is called mimicry, or assimilation. Certain creatures escape their enemies by resembling their surroundings so completely that the eye cannot distinguish them from the trees, the ground or the snow. Only in this way do they deceive the enemy's vigilance. This mode of defence is very popular among the well-to-do Jews of the Western countries. To tread softly and to lie, never to do anything distinctly Jewish, to shout with the crowd, to keep step with the mob, and, if one is a member of Parliament, to vote for the Alien Bill — that is our Jewish mimicry. What a glorious mode of defence for the descendants of the Maccabees!
There is yet a second way of defending oneself without fighting — and that is rapid movement. It is the method of the fox and the hare. The continual movement of our masses from place to place is almost the condition of our safety; it is the secret of our survival.
He who in battle only takes to flight Will live to flee again.
Who would believe that our trembling rich and our ever-wandering poor are the descendants of the Jews who for years defended Jerusalem against the Romans without and the anti-Zionists within? That shows what comes of trying to live without a land. Are
