Die Welt · Vol. VIII, No. 17 · 22 April 1904
2printed page
scan 2 of 20

Page 2. — "Die Welt" — No. 17.

(continued from page 1)

…these contests of opinion will not only do us no harm, but will fructify our work ever anew, will ever bring new points of view to bear, and will preserve us from lagging with our programme behind the times and their altered conditions.

That is why we are filled with so firm a confidence that we must reach our goal. Not only do we strive towards it in a manner befitting our time; we have also secured to our movement every possibility of development that can make it great. Like life itself, our movement is a thing in eternal flux. Unchangeable, immovable is One thing only: our goal, Zion.

So now, too, after the Vienna deliberations, we may count upon our cause being once more mightily advanced. A certain time we had to devote to the composing of the differences of opinion that had arisen. That time is past, the Charkow episode closed. Now there is once more nothing for all of us but our work. Forward! That we may make up what we were obliged to neglect.

W.


The Conference of the Greater A.-C.

Fourth Day of Proceedings.

Thursday, the 14th April.

Morning Sitting.

Director Kremenezky reports, in the name of the Inner "A.-C.", on the work in Palestine. His remarks culminate in the statement that the Inner "A.-C.", without being bound by any resolution of Congress or by any vote of the Greater "A.-C.", has done everything both to promote practical undertakings in Palestine itself and to support private undertakings, as for example the Geullah, as far as possible. (Half a million francs was placed at the disposal of the Geullah by the Jewish Colonial Bank.) At the request of Dr. Herzl, Dr. Kahn delivers a short address on the land laws of Turkey and Palestine. The land legislation of Turkey differs quite essentially from the corresponding European legislations. What we wish to do with the N.-F. — that the land shall remain common property, that only the right of usufruct shall be granted — already exists in Turkey. In principle all land belongs to the Turkish State. When, therefore, land is purchased, it is not the right of ownership but the right of possession and usufruct that is purchased. Five classes of land are distinguished in Turkey. The first class is Miri land, where the right of sovereignty belongs to the Treasury, which leaves the land to individuals to cultivate and to pay the tithe. The second form is that of Mülk estates. Here one possesses full right of ownership, but in the case of these one must obtain permission from the Treasury for the erection of buildings and the laying out of plantations, for by Turkish law the soil belongs to the owner of the tree planted upon it or of the house built upon it, and the Treasury thus gives up a right to the land when it grants permission for the erection of buildings. The third form is Metrukeh, where an entire commune is the owner. There are communes in Turkey that hold a collective right, and it is then decided by lot, after two or three half-years, to whom the individual pieces are to be left in usufruct. The fourth form is Vakuf; these are endowed properties which serve particular purposes. The mosque, for example, is a Vakuf. These properties cannot be administered by private persons; they can only be endowed by private persons. The administration is conducted by a special Ministry. The fifth form of Erasi is Mevat (dead earth), that is, land not yet arable. Whoever cultivates land not arable receives the right of usufruct over it. The land, however, is Miri.

Dr. Herzl sums up this report in the sentence: "In Palestine the way even to acquisition under private law lies only through public law."

From the Report of Prof. Dr. Otto Warburg.

The report which I have to render can, in view of the shortness of the time since the last Congress, comprise but few facts, and can take into consideration only the beginning of the organisation which we mean to take in hand. In the interest of this organisation we consider it desirable to arrive at a uniform and speedy agreement upon the individual questions. We have therefore fixed Berlin as the seat of the several sections. The establishment of the juridical, technical and chemical-agricultural sections has already been begun; the medical section will shortly be constituted. The purpose of our Commission is not a scientific one. What is to be taken in hand is the practical, economic exploration of the country. We therefore in no way represent a competitor to the scientific associations which occupy themselves with the theoretical exploration of the same and of the East. We have even, among others, placed ourselves in communication with the German Palestine Society, and may count upon the support of that association, in that we shall receive from it the economic material which it comes upon in the course of its labours, just as we shall gladly place at its disposal the purely scientific material that we shall obtain in our investigations. Naturally, these are mere beginnings. As regards the sections, we have sought to win, besides the gentlemen in Berlin and in the East who occupy themselves with researches of this kind, others also who are to be found outside Berlin and who concern themselves with such special questions. The work in the sections can, understandably, by no means be regarded as concluded. The difficulties that confront us are so great that we cannot expect to see any larger economic works completed even this summer.

The legal work is so complicated that our section will probably need years in order to master it completely. The importance of this work in particular is evident, as is our endeavour to proceed in this field with all due caution.

As regards the technical section, the difficulties lie elsewhere. To the technical section have been assigned tasks for which, on the theoretical side, a number of preliminary studies can indeed be shown; but the point is to transfer these experiences to a particular terrain. We have, it is true, some people who are well informed on individual questions. But so long as technical men do not study all these questions on the spot, we cannot speak of any certainty. These studies on the spot, however, again require a long time.

With the agricultural section but little can be carried out in Europe. We can indeed study from reports what grows in the field of research and how it grows, in what quantity and of what quality. But that does not suffice to bring us to decisions as to what is to be done there. We have some excellent collaborators, so that we may hope in time to be better informed. The knowledge, however, which we require we shall naturally be able to possess only after years, when we shall also have procured the necessary means which such a task absolutely demands. For the present we mean to begin where it is most needed.

We shall therefore strive above all to acquire a certain survey of the several classes of land that are for sale, so that we may be able to give reliable information as to their actual value and as to the probable costs of transport. This, to be sure, is not so easily accomplished from here, and our means do not for the present suffice to maintain a larger staff in the field of research itself. It therefore appears to me the most important thing to find here a solid basis for these investigations. That seems to me practicable for the near future.