Die Welt · Vol. VIII, No. 17 · 22 April 1904
3printed page
scan 3 of 20

No. 17. — "Die ✡ Welt" — Page 3.

We have also taken a hand in the founding of the Hamburg Trading Company, and have interested both our friends and our Jewish Colonial Bank in London in it. I think it unnecessary to discuss at length of what importance this Trading Company may become.

We have also founded a periodical, "Altneuland", in order that our ideas may lie clearly before the public — and not only the Zionist and the Jewish public generally, but the Christian and Mohammedan as well. Let everyone know what we want and how we pursue it, so that all the world may see that this is a great, modern movement of civilisation, standing in the fullest harmony with the demands of our time. We may now note with satisfaction that our periodical is meeting with much approval, so that we hope it will shortly be able to support itself. We are not short of material, especially as we attach value to drawing into the range of our consideration kindred regions, regions which we know to differ but little from our fields of research as regards climate or population. We further intend, as hitherto, to draw into the circle of our discussions the Jewish colonies in other countries as well, and to exercise a serious, objective criticism upon all attempts at colonisation that have been made with Jews.

With regard to the field of research, we intend to direct the greatest attention to agriculture. Here the chief matter is the founding of an agricultural experimental station. That without this systematic, methodical preparation an agricultural opening-up of the country is hardly conceivable seems to me incontestable. I will only recall what an example worthy of imitation the Germans have given us in this respect. In all their colonies they have established a number of such experimental stations and have gained the best results from the knowledge acquired there. The application to our work is obvious. Oranges, grapes, lemons, almonds, etc., could in this way be planted under far more favourable conditions. Many possibilities may be imagined here, and this very thing would be easy to accomplish, since we have the best connections everywhere. But with regard to the soil, too, we shall be able to learn much that is useful through such preparation. I am thinking of the draining of the swamps, of the more intensive cultivation of the soil, and of other prospective works in this direction. These would be only some of the points that force themselves upon us.

With regard to the material for colonists, too, there is the possibility of an extraordinary improvement. Besides the experimental station proper, where the experiments are made, we need a kind of training farm, that is, an estate upon which the new settlers, and the sons of the colonists as well, might learn the most rational methods of husbandry. On such an estate they would have the opportunity of training themselves in two or three years. The training farm could be supervised and directed from the experimental station. Thus theory and practice could be brought into the most useful connection with one another.

But the whole manner of husbandry might possibly be transformed as well, if the settlement co-operative proposed by Franz Oppenheimer were introduced. Such an experiment would, to be sure, have to be made with an estate farmed on a large scale.

These are the most important questions with which we are now occupied. — Prof. Warburg thereupon makes his proposals concerning the necessary purchase of land.

On the motion of Herr Architect Marmorek, thanks are expressed to Prof. Warburg for his address.

In the ensuing discussion on Prof. Warburg's report, which went more closely into details, Dr. Herzl remarks: He is an enemy of small colonisation who speaks of it, for by giving utterance to this intention one creates impossible conditions of purchase in the places where one wishes to work.

Director Kremenetzky further renders the report on the establishment of an orphan school in Palestine for the Kischenew orphans. Originally the intention was to combine the orphan school with the project of the school farm. The A.-C. is not averse to this project. But it lies in the nature of the case that the A.-C. has not yet come to any decision, since it can accept only a systematic project, a proper execution and a guarantee of orderly administration. In the administration of orphans' moneys the greatest care is the first duty. In the last few weeks a suggestion was also submitted to the A.-C. for the establishment of the orphan school in connection with the Lämmel School in Jerusalem, which is among the best schools in Palestine. The speaker requests that a commission be appointed for the carrying out of these proposals, to report at the afternoon sitting. This motion is adopted, and the sitting is adjourned until the afternoon.

Fourth Day of Proceedings.

Thursday, the 14th April. (Afternoon Sitting.)

Prof. Warburg opens the debate on the proposals of the Palestine Commission by giving further information on certain points.

Dr. Alex. Marmorek supports these proposals most warmly. He sees in them not only a great economic success but possibly a political success as well. France, for example, at once grasped what value such scientific institutions possess in countries which lack such establishments. Thus the fact that most of the governors in Africa are medical men is not only interesting but also highly instructive. A further example is furnished by England, which immediately after the conquest of Khartoum set up an agricultural and bacteriological station, by means of which it first rooted out the old evils. The speaker pleads, however, for proceeding first to the establishment of the experimental station and the medical station, because it is as useful for the colonists to draw the best yield from their soil as it is useful for colonisation to rear a healthy human material.

Dr. Herzl most warmly recommends the proposal to create a settlement estate on the lines suggested by Dr. Oppenheimer, because it will be a very important experiment for us with a view to the later colonisation on a large scale. The settlement estate has for us the same value as an agricultural experimental station. Dr. Herzl demonstrates in particular that even in the improbable event of the failure of the settlement co-operative, any pecuniary risk to the movement is excluded.

Dr. Klee associates himself with these remarks.

Pineles thinks one would have to be very cautious in the purchase of estates in Palestine, for he knew from experience that when, in the year 1882, the old "Chowewe Zion" in Roumania bought the estates "Samarin" and "Tantura", now "Sichron Jakob", and that in the name of their President, Isak Loebel, and when he died soon afterwards and they elected his son, Dr. Loebel, as President, who likewise died soon afterwards, the Turkish Government confiscated the said estates for itself. After great and protracted difficulties and expense, and thanks to the intervention of the Austrian Legation in Constantinople, since the Loebels were Austrian subjects, as also of the French Embassy, since we had meanwhile sold the estates to Michael Erlanger in Paris, the confidential agent of Baron Edmund v. Rothschild, and after two Turkish merchants (Mohammedans) went from Galatz to Constantinople and testified there on oath that Isak Loebel had left yet another son and heir, it was possible to succeed and to have the estates entered in the land register in the name of Herr Michael Erlanger. The latter had several sons, and the succession is thus assured. From all that has been said it may be seen how cautious one must be in Turkey in the purchase of estates, which the speaker commends to their kind notice.

Dr. Jacobsohn is of opinion that an experimental station should be created first, then the training farm. These two institutions will also train up the people with whom the experiment of the settlement estate could be made.