Page 2 — "Die ✡ Welt" — No. 16
(continued from page 1)
…that peace has now, it is to be hoped, been concluded with sincere hearts and for a long time. Peace in our movement — may it become the hope of peace for our people. W.
The Conference of the Greater A.-C.
On Monday, the 11th of April, the conference of the Greater A.-C. was opened. There were present: the gentlemen of the Inner Vienna A.-C., and further: From Austria: Dr. Krenberger, Dr. Goldwasser, Adolf Stand, Karl Resek. From Hungary: Rabbi Roth. From Germany: Dr. Klee, Dr. Friedemann as deputy, and Director Wolffsohn. From England: Greenberg and Cowen. From Roumania: Samuel Pineles. From Servia: Dr. Alkalay. From Belgium and Holland: Henry Grünau and H. Kann. From Switzerland: Dr. Farbstein. From Russia: Dr. Bruck, Dr. Jelsky, Prof. Mandelstamm, Jassinowski, Dr. Jakobsohn, Dr. Kohan-Bernstein, Dr. Tschlenow, Dr. Belkowsky, Engineer Ussischkin, Rabbi Rabbinowitsch, and Messrs. Dr. Scheinkin and Dr. Rosenbaum as deputies. From France: Dr. Alex. Marmorek. From America: Dr. Stephan S. Wise. As representative of the Zionist Commission for the Exploration of Palestine: Prof. O. Warburg.
After the reading of the incoming correspondence, which includes declarations of assent from all countries, the minutes of the last A.-C. sessions are read and the agenda of the conference is fixed as follows:
1st Day: a) Statement of the President. b) Debate.
2nd Day: a) Continuation of the debate. b) Question of the court of arbitration. c) Bodenheimer-Farbstein draft.
3rd Day: a) National Fund draft, rapporteur Farbstein. b) Bank, rapporteur Wolffsohn. c) Palestine Commission, rapporteur Warburg:
- National domains;
- Purchase of land;
- Kischenew orphan school;
- Hamburg Society;
- Girls' school, Jaffa.
Dr. Herzl's Opening Speech.
The Chairman first delivers an obituary tribute to the late Colonel Goldsmid: "Colonel Goldsmid knew how to enter entirely into the new and greater tasks. He was a dutiful Zionist, and in him our movement loses a great champion."
Dr. Herzl now takes the floor for the opening speech. He said: "In spite of all the difficulties and the affronts I have had to suffer, I have resolved to speak to you words of peace. I know what disquiet exists among the masses of our brave, poor, good, faithful Zionists throughout the world, and especially in Russia; with what great anxiety they look forward to these negotiations; how they fear that these laboriously created beginnings of a national organisation for the accomplishment of the national work might be damaged. Above all, I wish to forget everything that has been done against me personally. But where I must, so to speak, awaken is at the moment when it is a question of calming our organisation, of accomplishing the work, of strengthening our unity, of carrying out the mandates which we have received from the Congress and which, by accepting our offices at the Congress, we have bound ourselves to carry out." Dr. Herzl now recapitulates the events since the Congress. He dwells somewhat longer on the promise of the Russian Government to intervene on behalf of Zionism at Constantinople, which was a great success and improved the Palestinian prospect enormously. "This success, great as it was, does not entitle us to suppress the magnanimous offer of the English Government to cede a territory to our distressed masses. My personal standpoint in this matter is that we had no right simply to reject such a proposal without having consulted the people. I will describe this proposal in one word: 'It is a piece of bread.' I, who perhaps have cake to eat, have no right to reject a piece of bread offered to the poor because I do not want it or do not need it. I am perhaps filled with enthusiasm when the ideal impulses prevail even in famine; when it is said, we do not want this proposal — but we were bound to put the question. The proceedings at the Congress shook me deeply. Not, perhaps, because there was a large minority, or because they walked out, but because I had to ask myself: the people with whom you have worked for so many years really believe, then, that I could give up Palestine? That shook me deeply, and I went to the Nay-sayers and told them what was in my heart. From the good will of our friends I then expected that they would gradually enlighten minds and explain the matter to them quite simply. This Congress has not yet taken a final decision concerning East Africa; it has merely determined that we take cognisance of the proposal in the form in which one takes cognisance of all such proposals; at the same time the material had to be gathered for a real decision on the matter, so that the people might arrive at a decision not by phrases but from knowledge of the facts. In this confidence of mine in my colleagues, however, I was grievously deceived. Immediately after the Congress an agitation was set on foot which has done our movement grave harm. In particular, my intervention in Russia was not to the liking of some gentlemen, although I decided on this journey only at their request. This journey, as you know, was successful. This success did not, however, prevent war from being declared on me. At Aussee I gave the representative of the Russian members of the A.-C., Prof. Belkowsky, every possible explanation of the whole situation. For this purpose I showed him a document which I will read here. (From this document it is evident that Dr. Herzl never thought of giving up Palestine, but after the Congress continued all the more energetically in his work for Palestine.) I then expected that Belkowsky would enlighten his colleagues as to their grave error. I would add: this letter was dispatched long before the agitation against me began. I dispute the competence of the Charkow Conference. With it you have set a worm in the movement; I wish it to be rooted out. No more was demanded of me than that I should influence the Congress against myself. I repeat what I said to you at the outset: we hold ourselves bound to carry out the resolutions of the Congress and the investigation of the actual conditions, as the majority of the Congress has made it our duty. Nevertheless we have, during this time, done the utmost for Palestine that is possible according to our judgment and our conscience, with all the zeal which you may recognise from the document read and from many steps. We shall return to this. I wish to state that in our zeal for Palestine we need take a lesson from no gentleman. But we have yet another zeal, and that is, if at all possible, if it is possible without sacrifice of conviction and without neglect of our duty, to establish unity and to keep our organisation intact. For this it is necessary that the gentlemen who have taken up an attitude of rejection should make it clearly known whether they recognise the resolutions of the Sixth Congress as binding in equal measure upon majority and minority. Now I should like to recall only one thing. You know how it went with the two mothers before Solomon: she who wished to divide the child was not the true mother.
Monday (Afternoon) Session.
The Discussion of Dr. Herzl's Speech.
On Monday afternoon the debate on Dr. Herzl's statement was opened. Ussischkin is the first to take the floor. He wants nothing from Herzl; he wants from the whole Zionist world the assurance that we shall not take up any work that coincides with Palestine. The question is not whether Herzl continues to work for Palestine or not; the question remains the same as it was discussed at the Congress, namely whether we are prepared to occupy ourselves with the question of colonisation outside Palestine. Even though 295 voted for East Africa, I declare hereby publicly that this resolution is not obligatory for me, since it violates the Basle Programme. You may rest assured that if you persist in your standpoint, we cannot work together. Dr. Herzl said the whole matter was like a little piece of bread which we may not refuse. That is a humanitarian standpoint. One need only see how Herzl's disciples now conceive this Zionism. My letter has been called a revolutionary letter against our organisation. But the East Africa project was a coup d'état from above, and the answer to it was revolution from below.
